The Huron Expositor, 1941-01-31, Page 6—.1
I I I I . 1�� . . I : i � , , 11 I �.: ;'� :, I I , tt
11 I * A
I 11 � . I � . . — .'' '�11,11Fl " 7"''."""711,11,11 11�1,1 R 1�1p , -r,-!--'--, ��%�17_7 : �r,- �,- r-,,.-,.-,_ ,�7' -r�n �" �.:_ -'-7 � �, '!� 11 1�,- I -17 11 7,11, 1-1 I - 7,171771_11117�1. 7� 11 d I ,�,__ 1,17 I 97 - —.� '77", "' .
. . . �
__ __ . 11 11 —11. � I I . 1. I 711, __ " I— -1 -11— — ...... i, � . I � I � I 77 imp . I �, I . I , I 11 I I I I I � I I I I I I "I I I , k, I I �� � , I I I �, , . I � i I I I I , i � . .. , �.. ..
I I � � I I I q I I . I I . I , . I I . I � I I I I . � I . I , I , I I I I I . I � I I I : � :
I � , ,,, � I I I I I I . � I I I � , , ! I 1 . I .1 I , I I , " , 11 � I , I � , I �. � I I 1, I I 1, I ,� .: : I � , � , , L, 1 . . I I ,� � � . I I I , I �, , � � , ; �!��Ii "
1'�, 11 �, . ,�_, , " \ : I , I .� , I � i I I I I I , , . I 1, , ,, I � � � . I I � � , , I . , 1, I I I I .1 I . . 11 . . I I . ; , ��`
,�, - � , 11 I �� , . ��. .. 1. I � . I � I I . . I � I � I , , I I ; ; � . . I I I I 11 ,, I . . I I I 1. I . 1. � : , ,� �
, , , I , I 11. � � I .. . I . I . I I . " I 1, I I I . 1�1 " I 11 . I I I � " I � " 11 , , , , , I I I � , .1 I , 1. I , , — � . I I !
-,
.1 I " I I I .� , , I . I I I , . � . n I .. I I 1. I I � . . � I - . I , I � — . . . I 11 1
I . � I . I � . 1 I .1 1 9� 1 . ,. � . � . . I I � I
I I . J � . � . I . I I . . � � . � . I I . I : ,, � � I I
I . I I '' I � I . '' 1, 4 , .. . 11 , . I I I . I I .. I I k 1�, � ,; "' 94�'. 1
1 1 , I" .I � . 1:1 I I I I '' . . I , , � . .. I . � . I . 4 I ,
;:..; , " .,. I �1� -� . ..'...'_... . I X1 , I . 1,
��.� I I 1. ,-.1—.1.11 . � 11 , ,, ; , I
I �, I I ,I I
. . I "I .. I . I I . A � , ._J ,
� .,_ I _0 " � " ,
, , ,,, r; , I il ,.I!. - -� I - - I I , .
*,tj,,��,:,:�"..:,;, I '. .. . I I ; -1. I I . .
? I :
�_ _ �, , ;
, I � -, �Q'1' , " 7:, a . ..... �,�,,� '' � ''. 1. � ��,._ 11, - . I � � � . 1-.-11.11 ... 1-1 .... -11 —1. -1-11 ...... ____...� ;
; !..11"3-W ''" I I I= , _��
�, . XPA" �'. 4 *, IMMIena 0 �
�,,,��o,;��.'O'.,,.. 0"', , ___ I -1.11.1.. 'r --,., -- --p-1 .- -- - -,� -, _. 0_01. I
:, 1. I lilm , - ; i��i;.F-ei;.��;i�i";i�4A�....;i __ .
_�.VNI,Itl i.1m1;1.1,;,1,�.q',11_1 ... i F .=.=_._... rm � .1
- � 11 � 1. I '11-11.1-- 11 i_ I - I ... 11 1. - i r, — � . � � �� -, -- - : I
�_� . .d. - - . I.. � � . ... ... _ 1, -1.11-1.1-1 � . - . . . . I . .
-�T 4�1 " ,� . .
, it. . . I , . ; .. `1
�,-,'�,!""��,��".i..�,.;5..4".�1.11. 1.111�N."-ill ,11 �.'101.4. ;�4-%o0."6�iio;io,fP - - :�'., , -3 s--- -_ �1.el - I I I. -I., .1.1 _. 1. ,
. I ..
". W .. 1. I I . I . ': , .I.. . . I
. �, .,�' " , .. , : i . I I
_! �. -;;,.�, %, I.. " � � , 'i:!0 , � , I � I I
" "" I I i I .
- - - . — - "' I-,
..,,f� ,-�V.i .�f - . I I , . I � .1 .,
;� )1,-V,"�:A ,, 'i . .. I . �'il'.
. i, , ".", ;t "'...., . .1 I . .
� , ", 110 1 . �kt.�. f . . , I I . I � I 4 . . . .
...-,-;W�i,�",�:R,,� " I . ..... .. . I I ; .
..Ili.. I,; e �,,J� "ZJ�,"M` . �' �.y . . I . -i , .
.
i �.. " _4'e".5,1�N*: .. , - . I .. .. . . J I . I , O'�
.11'.1.1 ,�, f4y? .
.,
---_M, 1. i7i� 1 1
�,.,���J`1�;`T'.' 2,�.� , " � N1. �;, . % . I . .1 .
. �;,.,, . . .
" , -;,i -t�'-'! �!�a� �., M11 _:...., I % I - I . .
'-! Y"t " "', ", � - * � I 1, . . � . 1-
,;, ,_f" � , 11- - . . . ...
!. : . � I I I . I I
lllkk 1�1� M, oQ,.,,� 31"Vi. ,INZ� - I . . . .
; i%' il, - �, '�",�;.,il ... 1-M .k, " . I I I ,
., .. "." . . I .. . I . I i, I / . I - I . I . , � I . . . 3
w n"I'Q nn-% ...'... , . . . ..... — . . I . I � � 11 I � .. . 0 . I I .
lill � ,,, -�, � � Z- �, i 1� . 1
0. _ �, � I . 14
.'.�'.1 I z; 1: ': . - . I I .., ", 0 �
.,, 1"4. J. I . I .. ...
..,
� ..... . , I'l. �P, - :1 . I � I .
I I . I -T, � . . 1� . � ,
... . 1,W .4-. ". �. � . . . �
,;,'. IJW. - i . . I ,. , . -
1 , �p . I
le"'PIPI&l .. I . . � , .." -1 I � . . . . , . ,.
il .% ". I — - I . , 11 � � . �1� I � I/ I.: I 1.11 . , 0. I I 4, ;,I. '. � . I
N - R ; ,� _.� , ___ - .. . - I I � 1: . T-77 I .11,
� I I .... I..... 1. � . -.1 I I 1. � -, 0. I
I I . - "- i .,Z. Rl I I i .. .... .. �".. .".. . - , . . I . - � I � I I I -1/9, I . 11 � . 1
I, N -";;. I . , . * ,,, - - I .11 . � '14 . . 1. , .
�� :: , e . .11 . , "! , I
.. M,4.,;�, 1 . .. - . . . � __ I .. .
�. , , ,,I..�., �, . . '. ." . , t . . .. . .��.J, , , � . .
W. .,...!�� 1 . . . I . , I I . � . F I
— . . . — I i�- I I .
. - , � . I . I I .. . . , 1* . , � ... 1. - 'J . ; /!:,. ". . .
. 14 10,11li , .. .. ia . . I . I
.. - ,_ I . �. . . '. � ., I . � I I .1 . .
-P- I .. . .1 . . . 1. . . . . I I .
, , I it .$
,. � . I - `� .: , . . . . .
11111�� I �, ,-, .." * , um". , ..
.. , , , I I . I I I
,�, , I . . . . . . . . ;
", i�, "I' ,�� ,.. � �,,,j 1, , I . %( . I
, , T �;..;!�� � - A :. I . � . I ". I I . I . . � � I I 1�
I
, . I
,�.,A 11 I , . . " I - I , .4 .111, . � � .� i � .11 . .1. . . I
, . . ,I - -1 11 , I I . . I
1p� . 4,,!,4 1� 11 'I :: �, .. . 11 ." 1 .. I . � .. I
� 1:�� !V;':,�,��? �.,',,?,�� t""T,l�,����"i'i"":�;,-,;�� '� , , � - , - i", - I I . . .. � I . - I -1 . . I � , , . I , ,
., � . , �� . . I I � . , . ,�! � .
� .
, I I ,. I , . , I ;, . I I . I
�,i ,, , '. ,��,.; ��1�4�.j,: ,. , 1. . . . . 1: . t I .0
� ��� , ,�!'�Ijtj,l�,�j,�;11;,,- , .-%. I . .
i e , 1. , , ILIX " ,,, , I . .
- , ,Y�l n 3,.,�. �,, �� I
, I I . I
,
_10 1� 4, . ...
"IA", ; ,cy.","',�:', .
I I : - . I I . . � � I . . . . I I ., 1.
,, � . .— - _ -.---- � .
__ -- -- --- - . __ _ — — ___. -- . �- _ _ - . . � I .
11 . - . . . . I I . I � - I - . � - � I ,�;,
"... .. - I: . I I . . . � - �.._ - . I - � . . I I .. .. � . .. . ... . _'... ... - I - . . � - . 11
I .. V.: . � 1. � I - . . ... I - . . � . -:.. -_ .1 . . . . � - . - . I .- .1 I., . _. . . . - - . . .- 1. . � _s�, - - .. ... . � , . I - - - . I.. . . I � . I
, , I . I I I ... . . I , - -_ . ii.. _ Al
1 _ � . . .. I . - .. . I - *- " --- "---- ._________.___... - _.. . . . � � . - . , '. , _ - _.
_ -----. � , - . I 01 0 . I . 0 .. A - .... ..;�
S. 11T'11._RF.1'. "I I * I I . .
�, -, .. . , r, I -
'. ,M.'. - , - - .10 . . . I . I
, � ff .. .... . , -"..! " .1 I " . . . . .- . .1 I
" ":.,.�& . .- ?I �
,
1, , �V" i�� - . .1 I
'. k. !�.... . - . - ... .. _ I , - -1. - - �- - _ - � ..
, I I _
" � t�
t, �4-t�q',: � I I I . I -nm rov --NA% #
I , . . 0 .. Do tnto P , .. "'t"al
1--l"Pii, I I t ' . 1. , I
, lro_l;�,: . .
- ,,,. , I I �
. .
�:,_ .Ft'n'. I - �.. � . . .1 I C
- ";�,
.r:,, i.:!- .
_
�.;�_ '_.��..,:.* . - ' '.1 0 - O'. RI 11 . . I I
�
�
. . . . . .....�_.
...;... ' . - -
. . 1.
.11,111,111,111, -l_!,!...1, . �
1,
� lU,-_',', - : "I
"..':...k.
I ... ,.,;:,!1_-__!�.1 . ro
-11 " � ,
.. f1w, - - � e - ,i
.
. __
...�� �_�...,�..,_ - I's
._::. Conference on't is eport
y,,Ji.;!.-.'., - I
11.�' I I I
,
I
lew..,`.�`- - � �. �- � .
��_1,3",,.._ . . . . I .
�� ffill:b.: , I . � I
"
..'�.��.i! 11 I I I
11 ..... ilr'-%,�,: . .. . � IT IS PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT at this critical phase ol our national life that the people of the Province) � I -4 ."
,�4.... ... I . '
,, �
�,, ,,.z��".,. - - , . of Ontario should be given the facts �and allowed to base their considerations and judgment on them. .
N. _. . � . . I it
i I - . . - .
...
11 "Z". I There is very little doubt that in man instances o inions have been based on speculation, propaganda �
,"...i ,. . y . P.. � I I . � � I I
��
.�v: . . and rumor. . � ,� � I � I
1_..?,.1!:* . . .1 � .. I -j* I ' . I I � - . I . 0
�.,. - .
���, .. ��'. . The statements given herewith are taken from the 0 eport . . i
!.. �,.11, . � - fficial R" s of the Conference as published by the � I I I
, ,��, I I r I
! ... ��- Dominion Government. . . . �
kl'�'� " . . .
. I . I I t
I I I
.. . ..
. . .
F�. * I . . NON ZTCRELL F HEPBURN RIME MINISTER I Already a Fuel Controller has been' appointed and as its credit closely approaches iths. A Z-fOiN. J. B. MeN MINISTER OF . I
.�,_ t of the dominion. AIR, X.C., PRIME
I
D PROVINCi
, " . AL TREASC;J&R OF ONTARIO, he has.the power to regulate the distribution of gaso- feature of the arraingercient not generally realized is NEW BRUNSWICK, (V.I. 2, palli 23) it I I
, , ; I .41VM . Xs a war measure, he could deprive us entirely that in the case of Alberta the dominion would assume ta �
-
I
11 - . (Y91_1, Psge,ii 14 to 20). line. "At the on ot, I must say that we do not concur �
11-�-�, . I - -, _ "Mr. Prime Minister and gentlemen, during this time of reveiiires, f,reffi-the licensed vehicles and gasoline. nottonly the provincial debt, but the defaulted interest in the findings of the commission as act out in chap" i i
, �
_.. of stre and strain and ruthless warfaro I have never V�e shotIld then hs�ve to go to the dominion authorities on he same. This had reached $3,400,000.by 1937 and V and VI of section F of Volume = where certain
,
If, , g with a tin cup in our hands saying --'either contribute, stands now at a much higheri figure. Ontario's federal a Advanced by the government of NeW . 1.
. I
,� I ,y criticized the Sirois report or its recommend- the extent of our loss of revenue or pay for the taxpayers provide nearly half the dominion revenue ' V a - I I
- I
,
;,..-, . . pub Bola c . .
I .. .ti.a.."I 'did make a statement about the timing of the to . ' Wriongwic re diseusaed." . .
�"-'" i . publication of the report because I believed then, and -PPelal services of Ontario' -and, believe me, they are out of which this gift to the bondholders would be .-:11 - �,
I __ . .t_ --1-aried in this age of growing patern0sto. provided.' --.-, .
, .. . I .11 believe, and am joined in this belief by many per- When the Prime Minister addressed to me on Novem. That showi the chancing apiniou of that great pub- RON. JOHN- BRACKEN.- PRIME MINISTER OF 1 $ -
11
- I I I going, that I did a public service in calling attention to lication. Whyi Because that and other newspapers, MANITOBA (Vol. 1, psge 30). . I
. -
I - I her 2nd, 1940� a letter with refer nce to this proposed
?. .. . � the act of throwing Into the arena of discussion a highly I e I
,
�,�. sensing public opinion, are reflecting the growing sue- I I .
m. . contentious document at a time when people who love conference, he said in part: I . "Manitoba does not think it unreasonable, it it I . � f , ��
1. . the Empire and all it'stands I -or are concerned with 'While the cost lof unemployment relief.has been' pition oF the awakening public.mind. As a political wanted tZ borrow in u y- on the credit of that dominion. � . I ... � . - . � i,
"I ecessful prose- a y that there is a fast,L developing body of a c
� '
I . one thing, and one thing alonew-the an reduced the war hi� cast additional burdens on govern- that it 6holdIld be expected first. to obtain the approval . .�
,_ - , bserver,�I as
- . . oution of a victorious war in *Vich our national secur- opinion. 'not without cause, now promoting the idea d P . . 2
P-1 meets alid taxpayers alike. It has inevitably increased of such National Finance Comonission. We fed sati9fie I
'P .., . . � I -L. ity is at stake. For if our effort fails, HitIlor, and not the competition between governments to Be � rev- that behind this -untimely move, ostensibly as a war no difficulty in'61ititining the approval .
. cure meBsure, is a well -cooked, nefarious deal to make good that we shall have .
� ... � . . . I I the delegates present at this dominion -provincial con- enu�s, and has aggravated the overlapping, muaber�' the losses in depreciation of certain bonds hold largely of such A bodT in &H, cases where our.application merits � �. � I . I
� � , _/ . .. . . . . . farence, will settle our domestic problems. , .. some and discriminatory character,6f much of our tax by financial houses, to collect ultiplaitt interest on Alberta such approva.. If aocase comes up in which 'such &P- . � I .
"I. � I In this regard the policy of the government of structure.' � . bonds 'and to cause a sharp ap�feciation in bonds of provall 19 withheld, that will not prevent as if we I I �. .
. . � . I I Ontario has not changed in, any particular. These of us certain provinces, which bonds air- think the obje.et is a 'worthy one from borirowing upon . . I . . I
,, who represent the central 'province have,.been con- were ' cause, of . own , . it. it has been Buggested that such . . ..
.�,� - , . � . . Ontario Co-operates on Invome Tax: cumatances beyond the control of the 1P.-tave Pr97 our .r It, alone . I . I 11
.- . ..., . sistent in our attitude. at much Ies. the. provi�ici I creiili will be ima .1
I . I take this opportunity of referring to the actions of vinci6i treasurers, actually sold borrowing upon !i , smentiltious - ire 11, . .
w .:1 . I I . Some while ago A former associate of mine in the the government of the province of Ontario with respect although the coupon rate was abnormilly high. " ...ibl - if th commissions re= ,,a,.,, whia, I 1,
,Rr, P , , We do not agree.
. � I . . . '. � . . . 'House of Commons, my good friend the Minister of to the Income Tax Act of Ontario.� Perhaps I should possible hags capital apIreciation is not even subject .ad, :kclive. e . � I . �
1�, to Toronto, at which time he dia- explain that the Income Tax Act of Ontario differs to federal income tax. . . - can borrow now could still borrow if the commission's . I t
l - . . . cussed with Mr. Nixon, Mr. McQuecton, Mro Walters from the acts of most 'of the ,other provinces in this I solemnly warn those who are obviously pressing recommendations were in force. -The' ouccess,of Ptuch " . I .
.. , I I and myself the advisability of implementing the recom' respect -that we allow as a deduction from the income for such action that they may aggravate that suspicion borrowing in either case depends, upon. the ,tax of � � . I
.1, . I . mendations of the Sirois.report. Along with my col- rn- - I I
. . � .. of the Ontario taxpayer the amount of tax paid to the and destroy completely public confidence in gave the province which is attempting to borrow. For or
�: , . leagues present, I urged yes, almost begged him 10 "Ile dominion government under the Income War Tax Act ments. . ample, with their resources -we do not think that either I I . .
7, . - " . . before we impose our own tax. . I I Ontario or Quebec will have.any difficulty in borrowing I i.- . . I -
. . .. his influence to prevent this becomirigg a national issue . ,
� . � . nveyed,, my mes- . if this report is implemented; some - � - 4
: - . during %i,ur time. I am satisfied lie co Is that interfering or competing with the dominion, Canada Must Be United oother provinces .
'. I might bat is there not a questi n as to whether I .
. . . I I sage to the Prime Illi nister. I was, therefore, somewhat especially" as' it has been admitted. by former ministers Now I come to a subject of even greater importance these could borrow satisfactorily even it the .
a . . = i ,
14 '��.r perplexed when, a few days later, I received a litter of finan�e of Canada that for the dominion to levy an -national unity. We have it to -day. All Canada'is report is not implemented! If they could not;. then I . . . .
;, . .. ffdrd the Prime Minister of- Canada advising that a con- i come tax at till is to invade provincial fie;ldB Of behind the prosecution of the war. We a ' . d pigmentation . 11 I
: fier�ilce would be called and that the federal go ern. tn ,re a unite they are certainly no worse off after im .:.
K I . ! ovation I I .. iople. We need,be. We have a com . - I
, intent was, in effect, recommending favourable consider. Pi men foe in.the because ,theri they can borrow in proper ca,ses upon . (
�, To make such an allowance as I have set outis not dietators. 1 -happen to knew something about religious I
:� . ation of the commission findings. Again, in order to the credit of Canada.
I . I . competing with the, dominion; it is taking a secondary and racial issues. I can speak feelingly an this subject. I . . . ,
I I . � . maintain our. consistency, I replied as"follows: th position to thedonainion. Furthermore, let we state We tried, as a government, to remedy a simple ob- : ,th The fact is, and the report makes it clear, that in . I . . I I .
. . I 'I have your letter of November 2nd, Lregurding , e that the province of Ontario'was the first province in vious injustice and Inequality with regard to school e matter of future borrowing. the provinces. are -to .
. SiroiA commission report. Canada to arrange with the dominion to save the cost tax revenues. We failed, and the very ones we tried to be.left in exactly the same position in which they no- L
� . . . I 'I -was hopeful that a discussion of this probleiii of collection of the income tax and the economic ,waste help were as anxious as anyone else to have us retrace, are. Indeed, th'ey can continue to borrow upon their . . I
; . ,cciuld be delayed until after the war so that there could of time of taxpayers; Ontario arranged, with the our steps. Is not a similar situation, on a larger scaleliown credit. In addition, they are given a new and . . I
: . . be no possibility 6f any controversial issue arising dominion government that the Ontario tax should be developing today? valuable right, exercisable Nrh;lly at their own option, I . . I f
�, I which might impair national unity and the effective collected by the same doii�inion officers and at the same Already there are rumblings that Quebec is getting of borrowing upon the credit of Canada." . . 11
- . I I
''. I prosecution of the war. time as the dominion tax is collected. ' preferred treitment. I know that, to some extent, there .
: I 'Howcvgr, in vietv of the fact that a conference is to That. is not competition. That is cooperation, ad- are extenuating circumstances. But the fact remains RON. T. D. PATULLO, PRZME MINISTER OF � .. I
I
0 be called it is the intention of this government to make a e credit being given by all tax- that ebec is being relieved of some of her municipal BRITISH COLUMBIA, (Vol, 1, pages 44 and 45)- . . . . ..
debts�ia
,� � .1 - o while other provinces are not. Quebec is to � .
.�. I- I . available its representatives any tirile that may be re. payers affected. "Money, of course, is at the root of this whole qaes- � I
I receive an ,eight million dollar yearly irreducible sub- I . I
�1. , quired after the middle of January, as suggested by Further, the dominion government on September lien. While monetary measures should be baged upon .
': . . you., . �U4, 1939, added a surtax of 20 per cent. applicable to sidy, while others including'Onturio, are not to receive . I
circums
"
1, .1 . . . . . M* income of,1939 and subsequent periods. This meant a a cent. Again there tire extenuating . tailces. the productive capacity of our people, the productive I I .
�1. . Later still, on December 28, 1940, the Prime ', in- lesser amount of income left in the hands of the tax. But explanations do not always explain. such cases capacity of our people can be amplified by irise mone- . I I
, - ,, ister in a letter stated in part: . .. tary measures and other considerations. ' ' .;
":; . . payers to he subject to the Ontario tax. The province. of.. with certain sections of society. I . . .
)_1 I , I �. 'In view of requests from several of the provinces. a Ontario agreed to abs6rb this loss in revenue. I The Toronto Telegram is a powerful newspaper and We are now told that it is nectissary immediately to . . I
�, . 4 . I I proposed agenda which we will rt-vornmend to the reficets tile opinions of many citizens of Ontario who implement the recommendations of the commission sno-
. I
" * I 1. I Ontario Suffers Revenue Loss I have a great respect for its considered opinions. The cessfully in order to prosecute the war. The go era- . . . , -
.t; � , uonference has been worked out and is outlined below.' v .
11 - . . gr0es with this vietv- I . .
. I I Not having been asked for, nor having made y Toronto Telegram has dealt with this.aspect of the ment of British Columbia dinate . .
I an On August 7tl%, 1940, the 20 per cent. surtax and am, sorry that the,winning of ti war haii been used ,s . . 11
, .� . . I I I recommendations, I therefore am free to suggest that ,ill the old rates under the Domifii6n Income, Tax Act report with great effect. I shall not quote. from its n the provinces . .
i", I . further consideration be given to the following sentence I an argument to fasten permanently upo .
, . . were repealed and in t6eir placeis newer and higher editorials=that is not necessary. Al) can Bay is not .
1i I . . .. in the letter in question: to underest'imn'te the power of the press in this regard. and the Dominion of -Onnada a change in dominion- . , 'i, 1
4 . - rates were enacted, and at tile same time, exemptions - _...__ i._.. - _ _ ___ ., __
i:. - lations which I firmly believe wiLL-w.ork ------- ___ .
� I 'I should like to emphasize the view of the govern- were cut. These changes were applicable to the incomes This new issue being developed presents a challenge provincial re, * . 1,
, r . al unity. To blibil -to-the injury land not to tile- benefit of the dominion .
1, � I . ment that the opening session should be, confined W of 1989. Besides these changes in rates, the *new to those of us who believe in natiow . I
L . - - - � ourselves to the obvious ig not fair to Canada, not fair and the provinces of whi ell it is WmPOSed. � I .
I
1.1.'� . I getleral-s.tatements a nd not,to-debate on po nts of detail National Defence Tax was enacted applicable to, Incomes o our neighbouring province of Quebec, especially If there had been no commission, 'war rn�ongures . I
I � � or special circumstances.' � . earned from July list, 1940. The effect (if these added, t' c . .1
b� I "I . I � imposts was to seriously reduce the reveiiiies of the when by this deal, Be ording to the best constitutional would still proceed; and right uow without -any change . . . I I
" , . - - 11 . dvice I can get, Q iel ec and the rest of us will have - c
,'I . province of Ontario, and it is estimated that for too ' ., n our constitution the doutinion an take any.ac�ioa
i�, � Public Should Be Informed . to agree to a surrez'ild?r to a central authority of rights 11 t .
�� - I . I The following paragraph of the letter informs us that ' fiscal year which begins on April 1, 1941, the province and privileges granted by the British North America deemed necessary to the winning of the war; and the I .
3 � of Ontario will suffer a loss of revenue of upwaros of ple are solidly behind 'the government that every -
7. 1. the conference will then' r"olve itself, into working two million dollars. Act. I say that so long as' rev colleagues and I have PeO ess shn[I be brought into action . I I �
, I . any say in directing public p;licy for Ontario ap,d so resource.which we poss I I I
,�,�: , . . � . . � committees, which will sit Ili camera. We have turned over the Elgin Hospital -a seven . at the earliest possible moment for the purpose of fur- .
��' . The Ontario delegates desire that- we state our case million dollar institution-al),ii many other provincial long as there is a British North America Act in its .
, .. ering our War .effokt. . I I
V� I I -publicly and briefly and at no time be a Party to a pr.operties4L without payment or reward and will con. presept form, which cannot be amend�d at will by a th . .. . , i 1.
!V"": . . . . scheme wMell withholds from the'pres. and the palilic tines to do so. . mushroom government that may in future.take office Let us face this question fairly. and squarely just . . . .1 . . . - . .L . .
*� . and in Ottawa, we shall, as a sister province, stand solidly. as if there were no war� us wds the condition at the I
?" vital information to which they are justly entitled. We have curtailed our capital expenditures beside Quebec if at any time her minority rights a . re. time of the appointment of,the commission', and not . ,
�, . � . .1 .
1,; I . I I We were not informed nor copsulted with regard to have delayed necessary works --works that would have -of national unity place those who believe that the proposals are of a L � . . 1, '. I .
,
k. ". I L the terms of reference contained L Ili the order in council been profitable and would have yielded additional threatened. On this sound foundation.
1�, . ., reve us. . I I Ive stand a& firm and resolute as the Rock of Gibraltar harmful character tinder -the Indictment that they are . I. .� " " ,
�1 . I . Passed by the dominion cabinet which gave life to the n .. t .
i�, I . - . . tself. . I I Ain�n� too, in 4n effort to encourage the incoming of itself. To Iny hands tal div -itile work of Sir Wilfrid hindering the war efferl. of !bjs doinla!an. � I . 0. . I . � . I � "",
rommission I le , . . . ,;�A, .
1� I . . n tourists who will bring with them mucl, Laurier and Sir John .1. Macdonald is nothing short . � _I . 4 .
I I I -ed for needed Americatf dollars, so )accessary to enable the of n . stion . .. I p Would Retard War Effort i 11`1 : i� . . 11
r,i, � . . W"a OntarWz presentation was inside we ask &I vandalism. I I 13A, , .
9.1* I . nothing. When the findings were agreed upon by the , . ,
111. . . dominion to save exchange and prosecute the war, the .
P? . . , nommissioners, Ontario had no ropresentative, Mr.' Do We Fiddle While London Burns? The comilli further states- . . . .
i.�'... . . health. province of Ontario has undertaken to expend on pub- I -, I , - � . I . . I ...
", I Rowell baving Iong beforo, r6fired becilase of ill ,Tile Immediate effect of Plan I on dominion finances -, . 6
;. . . But later on we were pro,sewted with a costly fire hun.. licity and advertising for to ' urists this year the surn In the post-war period we may have to open our I be a . I . - - .
, allars. That, according to gates to thousands, yes millions. oi European hoingless won d dverse, since 11
i,k.! , . I of three hundred thousand d me degree provincial fin I . ..
�
1 �,, . . . . dred thousand dollar repoTt-the product of -the minds u fficials of the dominion governinent, 'is cooperation, e British North unces would ,Idso he expense of those of
. I .., .. and destitute., If this eventuates. th have improve at t . �
gi . . . of three professors and a ,Winnipeg newspaper.man, not competitioil, I ... I
��,� - ' America Act iuit7� serve a usoful'pilfrIjose until the pro- the dominion.' I I- � .
. . . . I - none of whom had any governmental administrative And in'.respect to the 4porporadofis Tax, it will be cess of assimilation is completed. I , 'Inasmuch as the finances of the dominion, accord- I � I . I �', '1�
,,
..
ill� . . . . experience, and whose opinions all of us cannot share. within the memory of thei"iiipresentatives of the various Is tKis the time to s6nd' a courier to bomb-toru ing-to the comniission, are -not immediately to be I-- �". . I . . . .
11 I I � I , t that, in the report ,itself-, it is to . I . � �.
- � . � In view. of the fac provinces, here' that the authorities of thc dominion and and' -have him proved but the reverse, it does not seem logical 8119- .
.I, ... . � . . . � - . . stiated that Mr. Rowell )led nothing to do with it, his be presided over Uondou with a ,document in Ills It ohirtiond. tion . . � I t � .
i , I I . goverminent have appointed a, board to step into tile Hall of. Westminster sold aak-the British gest--that the implementation Of -this Yee -1 .
:�, .� .. name, which has been tagged on for purposes of proP&: by the Hon, Charles P.- Me'r-figne, Justice of th parliament to pause in its consideration of questions of . the commission is essential to our war effort. Rather . . .
: . . �. ' su� . .
i . 11
. - __ � . . . . . I . . . � . I I . Vanda, cdn: very weir b6 diditted Ili future, � prome Court of Ontario, Which- board has been fermed determining the very life of the British Empire in order does it suggest that during ,the period of the war the '., . . . � I
1�. , , . . . I . � I Those of tr� Nvho believe in democracy abhor the very to tictermine the amount of obsolescence and deprecia- to debate the question of a new constitution for implementation of the plan, will be a burden on the , . .
�*'�� '. . . I . . . word propaganda be�ause the circulation of ready- lien that may be allowed taxpayer& as a write-off against dominion's war effort, not, alone through the e.qsllmP- . , I
I. . . made opinions by any cen trally-con trolled power is the profits 'which will be. s�ibject to war taxation. The 9 . . i
:, .. . - in of the . To me it is unthinkable that we should be fiddlin ti6n of additional f1wincilil obligations .but through
. Z ost dangerous enemy of civilization. From this per- government province of Ontario has nnnouticed hile Loudon is burning. In the henrrof the Empire the time and effort which must necessarily beexpended
spective wo s�-e the evil working of such a vicioua that it will accept without question the findings of this w tion go proposed . . � , - 11
. the citizenry -men, women, boys and giT:ls-Nvith their in the settifig lip of the new oi�ganiza � �
.". . . . � " system in Europe, leaving in its wake misery and dominion -created board. . I ,bare hands are beating out --the flames spread by ruth- by the commission. It would therefore adem the part I I
I I . � I � suffering w�ich shakes one's faith in humanity itself. . . . . less vandals upon the housetops and the roofs of their' of wisdom to get on with the.war and pbapone so . .
�1'1. y . ' . . Ontario Not Competing homes. Britons, on the shores of the sea and in the far-rencbing and contentious problem until after I I 1, ''
i . . . . Both Win? - war."
I . . Can Provinces and Dominion ,Time does nof permit a lengthy recital of other acts streets of their cities, will resist the invader foot by the I I I. .. -to I I
I I Let its guard carefully for fear a similar franken- of cooperation on the part of the government of theL fiedt with their very lives, as their great leader said # �i
I'll I o -
� I ilteip does n t appv'ar in our midst. In the first flush province of Ontario, but I challenge anyone to snecessl they would. Instantly concerned with their struggle I - I . 1. I
of public reaction the propaganda machine made it. fully charge the government ,of Ontario or, for that to survive .and to save us throughout this .Empire.and RON. WILLIAM ABERRART, ' rAimx-mlNisTzR .
.1 I . appear that to implement this document would make matter, any other province, with competition for with *nothing else� they are -waging a winning fight� OF ALBERTA, (VOL 1, page 6.�)-i I . 11 . Q . I ., I
I � � � the provinces richer and at the same time, make the rvvenue in.fields that do not exclusively belong to the to -day, the remembrance of which will never ills. while "Our people will ask, 'Why are thqy so anxiiiiiiii to -
I 1. '.. . dominion richer by the Wimple process of transferring provinces, or with any lack of cooperation whatsoever. freedorn lives. Thdy have no other concern. raine no issue ' like this when we all- have our handa I .. I . . i .
: I 'central government. To -day, while these brave people are shielding theiv fall with the job of the war?' Mid the whisper has . .
. debts and reveiiues*tb the On the othor side of the picture, even although the �es gone around, 'it is -the money p6wers.'
. . organization of Rerourdes Committee, patterned after homes with their bodf and braving, the bursting . -
Inasmuch as there are only two parties toAe deal, ' cad . .1
. .
, ., . ', Barely one need only to have an elementary knowledge the one that functioned so effectively in the last war, bombs and tile hail of machine gun bullets, do we r I am g . Oing to speak frankly. I believe that the L I
.. . I of economics to appreciate the fact that both can -not was set up by our Ontario LegisIntu're-and by tin- that the Lord Mayor of London has paused in his perilous situation which is facing Our, nation and the . .
I - efforte to save the nation and has called. a meeting of
1� win. Unless there are transferred with the debts suffl- animous vote -the nucleus, with power to add; consist- the aldermen to consider a readiustment� I I, empire demands sincerity of epej�ch and boldness of . . , - "
. . I ing provincial revenues, the dominion will in His Honour Lientenant-Governor Matthews, ,r a. rev s!on .
... . . itient existi ,i of 'of the librough system of the great met opolis which acton. I maintain that it would be mobt unfortunate I.-
'
,
I I . I I . ilkave to increase taxes or debt or probably both, This Ca onel Drew and myself -and even although well ov is now a beleaguered fortress? � .. if i3he idea gains popular'credence that there is a con- .1.. ,
I- . . does, however, offer an opportunity to explore every a year ago we journeyed to Ottawa and person. ril I listen to Mr. Churchill, to Mr. Roosevelt, the two certei and deliberate attempt being,ma.de by the money . I . I 0
. . . 1. �. - I possibility of reducing all governmental costs in Canada pledged, on behalf of the organization, the fullest inea-. great democratic leaders who stand out as beacon lights poweq3. to increase centralized control of our national -
..1., .. . . ... aio�'d, to this end. Ontario is prepared to cooperate to $ure of cooperation ginz every possible war effort the in,tbis bewildered world to' -day. I believe in tbeir sin- life while our. attention is fully occupied with the I
� - . the limit at the right time. That is a domestic problem secretary of the org ni ation now advises me 'thai not . ty. Only an all-out effort �vill save civilizntion and proaccution of Our war effort, and that theineby there . . I �
. m .1 - to which we can devote time and effort as a Post-war a singl� request or communication has been received pert I is developing an endeavour to obtain an unfair �ad I .
I � A and much better be it. so too, because the I christianity. Our centrAl government now, under the vantage ever the people by means of imposing upon � � �
1. from the federal government. .
. I . . . "em, y' , have very little rels- Any just criticism that may be. levelled agai If there is -anything soecific that the' dominion govern- . a
! . 9r.o.tii, problems of to -day ma not the War Measures Act, has extr�.mc, even dictatorial, pow�ir. them a crushing debt steucture tinder which they will . f .
tionship with those of a year henco. . . government of Ontario for- its considered .judgment on ment wants to help in its war effort. say so, and I am be further enslaved. I am sure thnt etery man in thisi . .
.
L. . I I am convinced that the commissioners were genu- this issue my colleagues and, I accept without com- sure every province'will assist by passing immediately gathering must be aware that conFlideriLble suspicion . . . . I 1
.. . I . . I inely sincere, and others. also, when months ago they plaint. But if the propagandisto believe for a moment the necesgiry enabling logiAlation. Thin can be Accorn. has been aroused in the minds of many because of the,
-,_.' stated that by assuming the cost of employables on,relief that., because of our attitude, we will remain ilent plisbed without controversy and without upretting our intensity of'the propaganda campaign and the great I I . I
�. 1, . I the dominion would render a financial favour to the ,while. insinuations are broadcast deliberately ter" the reasonably well -organized system of government. - expenditure of -money and the frantic and'unwarranted I I I - . I
I
, � , I ..., I. I . provinces and the municipalities. But anyone who purpose of branding us its unpatriotic, unneighbourly . I I haste that has boon urged in connection with the I , .1 . I . . .
I says so to-da.v, if conversant with the true,facts, is with ot;r sister provinces, or guilty of doing finythipl; Ontario Shall Continue to Help adoption of the Rowell-Sirois'recommendationg. I * I
11,; I .. .
1�1 I .. I guilty of unsaulterated `humbag�. I to bl&-Ic Canada in achieving our maximum war effort, . � � . . " .1
1.141 I 1. I I then I say to thern,'Wo shall defend ourselves from that In our war effort we of Ontario believe we have been Make no misticke. about it. Not only the efforts to I i , I I . .
�. . �
,., . -1 . Unem, oyaples Major Problem kind of attack here, on the floor of the leiialature, and helpf . I
k, .,ul and shall continue to be so, even to the eitent gain the adoption of these recommendations, but the - I
, , . Pi i propaga - 4
� ,",',�� - I � � Hen. Mr. Howe said AOMM while ago that; since the on. thb public platform.' I . of n9t joining in the'elamour ^to unload over two barViLge of obviously inspired nda to win imp I .� . . I
. .� I . .billion dollars of delifs of other public bodies an the the "union now" proposals have been ,tansing I . .
, f . . ... . . � . report wasswritten, more than half the employables Fero I avail myself of the opportunity of warning dominion treasury in *or' time. The process of transfer P4or-t-Ir-o'g, uneasiness in the minds ol. inarty. Whether it ,
I ��� . . I I . have secured jobs and that the other half would be the purely filtancial press nnd.others that.4hey have is common knowledge or not, we In Alberta are fully C
.. . , . I I believe Mr. overplayed their hands by attetaptinj to cloak this itself would -be involved and upsetting to our whole informed on the actfairwbich wait taken in Anatir I .
- " . � absorbed in industry during this yca�r. er th& financial system. A transferof all tax collection activ- ,a_.ila . . I
i ".1 ., I . I Howe. In fact, if we are going full out in this war report with the garments of patriotism and und classes indicated th the report to the central reg,,rding. lilais sinister propaganda., In. that British . . ., I
� , �.; . a. , ities of the country I .. . ,
1. .1 1. .. I effort, it iFj a reflection on the government not to put exigencies of w. r r uld do irreparable damaie to both at they seem to have ,mucli -more direct'Itiqlheds, I I
. IN I lithority could only be made'after complicated and I
� d o i �
� 11 to work immediately the physically fit adult males of all national unity an confidence. . far reaching legiolatiolt could be enacted. The time tban we have to deal with Bitch matters. We note that . P
: ;,:�';' - I '. Canada. But the Vnd of employable relief pripblents I desire to quote one 'uthority as a ease i instead of allowing the use of rndlo facilities for its
� ,
�� I ?,�&L. . . a in point. and offort of the federal parliament would be devoted -
l". , . , . ., . does not by any means solve the issue. There is still The Toronto Star, a supporter of the present federal . dissemination, as was done here, they treated this' I
� left the army of une ' In thid direction when every ounce of-effortris required .!
.. ,.""... . . mployablea, who to -day make tip the government in Jts editorial of November 20th, 19401 in the once, ,union now'! proplagands, as being gubv'ersive to the � I I ;,",
I l� � � essful prosecution of the war, And while " I
� orm of protest that
�1. ,'4�: . I vast burden of relief and, genefally speaking, will c&n. says: British empire and raised such a at
, .. I ourselves to fight this war with
,� c.:.��` . tinue to do go. public addresses on the subject had to be abandoned. .
,,,�,;! , 'The Star believes that the general idea of the 'report the last drop of printer's Ink and to the last page of . I I I '. I . .
.
.. i
,�� I ,,:,. , . � Under present spKangements, the dominion contri- . ood one, the idea that the dominion' should be Hansarg, confusion, utter cofifusion, would prevail in Surely it must be. evident -to any loyal British Bub- . 11 k
�1' ;",�, I .1. butes forty per coni. towards the cost of food, clothing 113 11 9 . .
. �21e;i I Iledtor and, as an offset, assume eertain. all governments as existing tax machinery bogged .
11 71,- �., I and shelter. If this report in adopted. in its entirety, the the chief tax cb .. Ject that to sit calmly and indifferently by while -we .
.;; -i,�. dominion will contribute nothing and ita former share pyovincial responsibilities.' . dolwa. I ar being hoodwinked and inveigled intd i'Ifinantiall I . I _,
I i ��,;,, - lien friendly policy of that paper. We, in Ontario, I emphasize, have anxiously co- e . I .
,� �, 1. will have to be borne by the provinces and municipal That was the t dictatorship or a fascist state, at a time when We a"
a,�� , I . Itics after revenues, out of which these costa were for- What -did the Star any in its editorial of Saturday, operated with the dominion government in its war , th best of our manhood to the etipiris and ori . .
I & ,,�,- .I . e
��jo.'V!:-�o, . I morly met, have been surrendered to the dominion. I January 11, if)41 f I quote: Iffort and shall continue to do go. But this is a Igi- Ing our all to overcome that foull thing which has '
, I .1orm e .
1. 4.�,;W. , � ing out of,the system is quite 'The'report has, naturally enough, strong backing .peacetime document, and we- believe honestly and raised its head In the world in many. guisen-a totafi- ". I . . \
'N, " , "; . am sure the actual worki
,IA. ; sincerely that the time to discuss it is not now, bet,
11"V 0 T, .; different from that anticipated. WINon the report wag Gtleat financial concerns and wealthy individon,19 wh4 tarign -oider of centeallited control and rogimentntionn- . ...
��.- I only when the nifenacti to our domocrady, Christianity is 1pat onlyit-idiontloua but dangerously criminal. I have e - , . 1 4
X �d: . - . � written, on page 85, Book 11, it is said that the taxes arer, holders of provincial bondb support a project whicht ,
11 . ;i,&, , - , In Ontario; we %�oiild place the credit of the dominion behind provin;* 4iod freedom is temoved by the complpte defeat and no avology,to make for op , I I .
I i . left to the Provi i. c -
11'1��,,i rides are more. stabic Baking thing. . . -
. :i!� . Ahall have left the profits from the Liquor Control cial-. securities whose market vdlue had greatly de- vou annihilation of the ruthless Axis pbv�erg." : . � ... ... I
ji".;. , 6 . I I .
"I " k�', 1, I ,
. ��,';� I . : 7 . Board operations, vehicle licences and gasoline tax. terild'eated. A Toronto broker has patimated that adop- '
1, ,. . ,�,: .- tibn of the report might add as mlich-as $20,000 000, RON. A. S. MacMIL-LdN, PRIME MINISTER OF RON, L I. ,ILSLEY, DOMINION MINISTER L Opi ...
kzi,l ." I . Where Is the slabilityl - FINANCE, -(Vol."2, page 80): I � .. I
. ,��,�,, ,, NOVA SCOTIA, (Vol. T,.page 22); , . . . .
� 1, I. �1 �.�� �'.' � I Wa'rtima prohibition, an a dominion measure, has $411,000 000 and $6%000,00 bti'the value of the �ondg , L I
; I .., � , "i appreciate the cooperation that.we have so fall I I
, 15". . already been requested and,"If my memory' oerviia me � SaskatchewAn and Allieria TegplOdtiVely�' ' "If We *erS Asked to ViVe*ft "tegOVIC01 answer ,
�,i,�'�. "I , grlii�obg�
: , t ,' . , . , , ,�, hly _ 'Ore costly to favairring or' ,opposin&the repoir I I . I
) ,� � W,il�, � .. . pit to te provinces and I want to mention if
; �',,�, I r - \ . correctly, the Utnister of 'War Services stated, and Ontario than the bondholders wiiiiWd be I t as a whole, that roteived'froul 0 I& .
� ,�� ", -,;i " oreucilifing ova Sebtin Bit we ,do, would. the cooperation front the province
.. �,,)',,,. ,'� . I quite properly so, that the federal government has the any other province. Ontario's own bonds. answer, r4� pbeticulliff . I
� l , :_ I I , 1. -- . I
�� -,& measure. would not Ie Increased In value to any marked degree, baVe to be 'No,." . , ifin, & . � .
- 11 'o", ,,, I . . I. power to enact such , � Q's . I . - .
, i"".1.", ., . . � �, .
". Sl��Yi L_ � , . . . . I . I I
. 1�� I . I . . I ).
� I � I I I I . . I I . .. i,-� - I ' � � . .r
I , . .
N, �i�,.,,, �1 �'.. - I � �. B BY 'THE AUTHORITY OF THE GOVERNMENT OF THE PROVINCE :OF ONTAR'10 / . 11
.�-gl...�;.. ".1"', ... � " . . . . .. .- . I . I . I I .
,"';.1, �, �,�. ,,, . , _'. , . . � . I I . I
,�u '1,T � , , I.I. . I- . . ;� .
A , — - . -1 I � .
ii� ,,�`� , -, , , , , . . � . . . - . I I 11 .
.
L."'."_'.s_F'1 �,� 'o . . I - 1. ,1 11 1, - 1. 11- - - I � I - .. . I , � . _ il � - . )) ��
., � I . . 1. � .. .. I 11 ". I � . — . .
''
I ',._,:,,�.,,,T, I il�!. ,
�� � Nlli . '... 1�� ..., . , , r , I � . 11 1� ..1. - . I I . 1. . - I , . . I
,�,i.',�;�� i. , 1, - I I .1 I I I " I . . . I . .
,..,_''':_, 1, . . 1. . I I . 1. . �. . .. . t. , I . I '.' .'' .
,,, - "� . _�� i *%,.,
P X
,
I..:
� ;
�
I
, .
I.. �
,
,�Ti,,��_� 1:11
7,..:_, I "w"`ss""`1
' ' . E -�,,�, . ' A ,!!,� Wt I.
�L''I" ,
�P,
. I
.
I THES' A R Ew THE 'F CTS
I . ... .
Irlim. I
I
11
, V �, J,- '', . , ". k . - . .....,
.r'' ,,,, , ;�, �,�, , I . I . l �. � A I I & " ' �ft I -n I . � i I .
�� ", , .1 11 � 1. �
i, :1", ��;f",�_,. :.,. . '. . I I I I I I . . � . . f, 4
.1;;., I I:'' - u w -d n; .
��,�,11,,,,!�,�l,',,":j;,,'':"� .. _ - �
,
i, l', e-, , , .", ''", � . / I., bontin 0 Paad'; Iseve. . . I . f
'f,V", I-, ''. ', ��, ��,�': , !'': , I .
,,, '.;.,V , ";', , , . � . . .1 i -
-P, - ":�ll'.�,'-',,�r�l,,,;..",,r"I .11 I . 1. . . . \ I 1, ''. � . .. I � . . . . . .. I
��,f�,','4�o,�:i'! ,!: I -��, 1. .. . I . I . I .. . . . ., . I . � ,, .
-pe ,-'".r,1'-- " .".''. I " � I I I .1 . . . I . � 1. I I . :1 . .
�,-,:'4'.�,,.,.'�'...�,�,..,,�'..,-,�. � .. I I .1.1
.�.�..,.,tl"�.','�."..'�''."''��..:"��-,--;''�"'';,N'I �� .1 �, I . . I I... . I I I I . . : .., . I � � .
it;, ��'t,,,i.l��::!;"f,]",,���,4,11;��r:p."i�?lr,.,,.. � � I ��, 1, - I 1. � . . . I .1 . �_. I .. " ",
,','-,'�i�,%,,,Ii��it",�i",�;�!,,��,-��., . . .. . . �' . " � . . � � .. ... ".., . I . . - . I I
,,,, - �,'ir '' 4,4:, L'� V11",,"O''. , . , . ,�� I A I . . ".... ...... l. '..�., I . .1-4, ., '' '. '. I .... ,. . ,
�, - I . . . . . I -7 � ", I"
�� �."..""J'." "1�.'. ' ""�';)�';�,,,,r , , .:, .. . I. I I -, 1, I . I I ". ! : I - 1. . . ,� � . i'l
1. � ,;�,, , _:�'. . . I - . 1�.- . — ,!� . . I . . I
.11, 4", ,.�,;V."...','�"1:''..:":''�r'.,;.."I I � p - I I . I . I . I . . I ,� �.. I . I .1 I Q, I � , . I � I. . ..., "' 1_>�t
";j;,�'i6;;,,,� "�'',�' � 11 , " * � I .., ... . 1, ': I - I . _� . ... .. �� . d- . � , " I 4 -
1, "I 1�', 11�,,,;',' ", . I " .1- I I .11 .
", 1� 1 ! r -..;'! �.,.'; ' I . I j .. ,� I . I I I �;, . ''_�', . . . ... . " 11, ,`i,.---- ,.,
,,�,�,';;, �1��: �.'�V ,?,, '6"T:, . , , I- " ." �, '...."'.�; L.' ,1� .', � � '.'.".'ir' " - - ''. �' :'�,-' ��� .' �11 I - .. I � , ,. 1 ,�') . , tir,;,i,�'_� , ".;, %..; ", �.��.;, �," ?'. L. �' .�. . - �. - -.1'� :!j -':'��' - . .',, .t'.,�,:j:,', 4� ...,:,r, �j .
,,, , . - ,,,,; , . _ * , L . . , . .1 - ,. , � "'. , � . ," , ... �
�,�,f,`��t��I`q,61'4 ,�', ;�,`:'.,*
� �_, -�!,.ji,;,� -.�, ".., - .1 � - 'i., . � , � , , - A�O� ..::,;' ,', " Ir. . ;._.., : ". , .1, - , *11 " ", ,.. l:o , ,, ,,��;
," - i"i M." 1 *,;,.�t ��I;,.,,. 1�, ,,�, k,i� -, . 1%,�.i " � j�J, lll ".. " ,".,,I . .. ...... . j1.;-.,-%.'
" ,,, , A � il, "' -,� �, � ; N, .,_� ", , �-�.J-nt��!,-4!1�,, , " ,, v I 1'1'�11111.1_ _ �
�. �,,;�,uj. 4. ,� ' ','. -. ,.� .;.,.. .. ,:i�, ,.�_ , �, , ", 11,11"..ill, ,_-%i .11';` .
", � ,.- , , , 14 i# -,,, I 4; ; ,, �:' , �.
- Ii W 'Q
,
-a W , :,L_ -r11 , �� ,�,l!+�,,. i,'-4�% - I � ,;"i;.,.A " J�`ilni,h,� R -Ar . :11,
1. ,;.1�11 ! �.�X"' 14�1.1'1.� 1 _
'tV , !, ;.1111'.i,4,,i :� " I
"'i'�,sf,ni,::,;�y �', , , , I .1� , ..". �, , ,,� � k��ilkl �,,%:--, AzA� i-.*.,.,;�i�,r�ii',��!4.,.to"�,.,, I �, _ .. - . 411=11--.111�1'k .46-11, ". Y W, 4E%R in*",ii,,�,S! �,'[T "k. iftQ�E -,., -
I I,. 111". 11 � ,;!, ,�� , , _� ...... f ,,, - ��, � � - ... i.� !,.. , . ,�.!�:,i �:,. , ...� .,;,.�,�..,'�-y-��.,,-.:i..I.,�;.r!."",�.'.."!.!.r. v-,,.,;, . ,. , i�L, il _ �Fklv _ "'A.1i"
-,,�v'�:J _! 1. X�A� *,L.'_1'z,�i;,,;i,,,;. "m ;e ,,.. ,,,,,;;, " Ile, Ai.11i�1.11`iw -ii- � , " .
, �,, , `�t " I :' ,:" �2 �,`,,,, ,!�., � R�W,L. -0�, J�%i!'.� i i - 1 �
".
. : '. �.1,11,1%11 4:1 , ,� � ", �,,it , , 1, 11 , ti�,..,-, � i. go". ie:i, . . tv', . " ,li, t,1%-. � *11' * , ..1.11
, 1 , 0 ,