The Goderich Signal-Star, 1972-02-17, Page 3forsakef b z7
. .for
,,
" . ,
BY W. Ea°ELL10T, • Proudfoot's course in, the The convention chose Hartley H.
After Passcniendaele, with -its Legislature" and approved his Uewart, K. C.
terrific casualities, the Canadian action in connection with the At the Centre Huron Liberal
1st Division encountered only . charges.
"routine warfare" until well on in The . scene changes. 1n Seaforth, Mr. Proudfoot made his
February, 1918.. Then, February, 1918, the executive sof defence,- but offered no apology
• "liveliness" increased all along
• the Corpsfront "!
froThus, apt. :s: ,,._'
William Proudfoot, of the '15th
Battalion (48th !highlanders) ,'
experienced only Ai. routine of
shellfire, rnud and coldfor part of
February, Presumablyhe Was in
ands- aur4-4tUeughtt -Ii
could better serve Canada on the'
front line than ih a Toronto .law'
office. He would not know at the'
time 'that his father, a former
president of his riding Liberal '
Association, had been censured
.by it for doing what. in his
.circumstances he thought would
best serve Canada. The action
lost William Proudfoot, K.C., his
seat in the Legislature and also
whatever his chances' may have
been to' gain the provincial
-leadership.
William Proudfoot, Junior,
survived the war and returned to
. practise law in Toronto in the _..
firm whin still bears the u Senator Wim Proudfoot
Proudfoot name. He died in 1964," a
This narrative is concerned Centre Huron ' Liberal for his course . .
solely with the • .Hon. William 'Association passed a resolution "The Conservative and Liberal
Proudfoot and what happened to of censure uppn the same Mr. parties •-• had not, rip to the
him for sticking to a principle. • • Proudfoot; took it to the riding formation of Union Government,
,1.tis:eonvsnient4o-.r-eproduce-at - • association--;. ,where it vias done -a11: .that- _t -hey -•-.-could in
this point a sentence or two front endorsed. His offence•was that he prosecuting the war•," he said,
his obituary, as published in 022 ., had co-operated with 'the Ontario and in' many quarters party
in the Clinton New Era (now the ., government of Sir William Hearst " feeling had been bitter. A change
News Record). . " During his .. in measures designed to. further was absolutely necessary if we
sv political career, Mr. Proudfoot . the war. Specifically, he had hoped to give adequate
had won a reputation of being approved prolonging the assistance. Like many others, I
Invariably - •a fighter for Legislature until ' the .soldiei; , desired to see Union Government m
progressive measures. Once voters returned, and he had . accomplished without friction arid, Robert Borden, head of. the Union Association
convinced of the •.rightness .of ,a faavoured Union Governmen at by the united effort of all parties, Government.;Iection campaigns proved Mr•.•
principle, he clung to his belief in . To a friend M Goderich, Hon.' Proudfoot a competent platform
Ottawa, anciwatha special. desire that the Mr. Proudfoot wrote: "little did performer,. hut' "not a
that principle with a • tenacity ' Let it be noted that the reason Liberal party should have , a Pr,eat
M which on more than one occasion Mr. Proudfoot was House leader prominent place in, the nation's getting
cents think that they were speaker," as recalled by .Hugh
caused his opponents, political or: of the Liberal party in the work. , getting me into the Senate. Hill, former Colborne reeve; like
pLegislature at this time was "Unfortunately for Liberalism ' Sinton. Proudfoot served only Graeme Cameron." He is
otherwtise., to wish theyhad a� Y •
more pliant personality to steal because Newton' Wesley Rowell and the country, the parties, did three years in the Upper House. remembered as a great upholder
• with." Stricken with,appendicitis, he was of his home •town "the good 'old
had relinquished the leadership to not fully unite and with a large admitted to Wellesley Ho sifal in tov,t.n on 1 ike.H o -n-', there"'s none
Read today, the passage veils Y P
go to Ottawa and become a n'urrrber of other Liberals I,found Toronto and `died after -one week, like her•, "' he said at a public
the real story, 50 years ago, but member of Union Government. myself advocating a • policy I °
everyone knew what it meant. It Mr, .Rowell became President of different from that of our leader, - on Sunday; Dec.'30 1922; He was in banquet.
•his 64th year, His business connections
•
will do, for a preamble. the Privy Council at Ottawa and a (Sir Wil. red. Laurier). Ba ieving• Y
Elected as member for Centre• William' Proudfoot was. born included directorates in Goderich
member •of Br-itain's War that the interests of my ountry
Huron in.1908 and again in 1911, • Cabins.,, r. l ut. o_f__-1JriiQn _Nate atstak.e.,..Ldid not hesitate) Feb. 1, 1859,, in ' Colborne Elevator & Transit Co., Dominion
-_---'71r: �—P765-41-661-6-a-11—.16-711-6—Government~ only when party lines follow the course dictated by my �� OyW filp' His .filth `; `�R6t1'e�fi--�R'pac3" M`ac InFi� el=y"'`C-0."`� O( erre
prominence toward close, of the were resumed after the war. conscience. Indoing so, I knew it Proudfoot, was a 'native of Organ Co.. Colonial Investment
Perthshire, Scotland, and his and Loan,
1913 session of the Legislature ' There is no record of the Ontario would cad'se trouble for me in the and Miller
when he launched what became Liberal 'party blasting Mr. 'filture, and that I was to a certain • mother, Margaret Darlington, Lithographing Co., Toronto.
e, known as the. "Proudfoot charges . Rowell, but it turned down Mr'. extent taking my political .life •in came from Wicklow, Ireland. a Senator Proudfoot was he'
' against the • Conservative Proudfoot when he offered for the my. hands." , • William Proudfoot, the Anglican and a member of the.
government headed by Sir James. Goderich lawyer and M. '. A. , was 1.0: 0. F . He wa _ a member _af. f he
permanent �-leader-sh-ip®at Re€er~r-ing to -the -`a ci-atron' �..--.• ' _
�,,, a ' n`epnew, (4., unief Ju Ontario; Victoria ,and
- --«-Whitney-Whitney,-These-sal-leged- -that_-a.-- - stice Rosedale. t
' business firm had paid Hon. W. J. P'ro"- uHfoot; of" ` Ice once o Scarboro' Clubs.
Hanna $500 for, political t"« William Proudfoot of the Ontario On Tuesday , afternoon,
�
t , t� .
purposes.. They 'Created ky:. "Court of Chancery, and of the Rev. Decembei 5,''the funeral service
0tl` �f i�tl : �_ , famed in St. George's chur•cha
�• wy
considerable stir at the time, and � �� Dr. William, Proudfootg
t °,t
Mr. Proudfoot demanded a royal" missionary who or anrzed conducted hy,the rector. Rev. S. S.
l Iix t' s I911? 1 „
commission.° In Huron, a -1ttofl"tbt R 1 Presbyterian congregations in Hardy, assisted by Rev. .Canon
big- ratio
Centren ,away heid-on__ I. �ondczn.,G.Qde. tch.,.and elsew-he..1T. .._111.11 and_Rev.,Cecil'tew:art,. Vi.ca.r:.._
in what is now Western of St. ,Thomas' ° chore .
June 5,. to endorse Mr. ° Ontario.Afterr' passingthrough Toronto .The choir was present.
Proudfoot's stand,- the Goderich.�, `` . I '
Signal said. Two special trains . ,. -r.... - 4 `i, 4., 4 public. and .high schools of and the edifice was filled. The
were run, and a gathering in the — < j .' . Goderich, he began to study law county council attended in a body. g
a.>wa. r�>, * ^ & ,under Mr.- Justice Garrow•, According to the. .Clinton
�• West st. rink gave an ovation to ,� g
" subsequently enteric Osgoode
• the member, accompanied by Mr.Y~'� q Y g, g .paper's report: "A number of
.„ ., Hall. He was called to the Ontario rominerit Liberals of the 'county
N. W. Rowell, Liberal leader,. and P:.
Bar in 1880, and in .that year were also resent."
. Mr. Thomas McMillan (a future
Y P
,MP for South Huron) who was _ r commenced practice as a Honorary pallbeareres mere
chairman.' membr of thefirm of Garrow and Hon. N. W: Rod ell. F. W.
e
"'Huron' admires a s uar , Proudfoot. !Upon the -death of his Hai court Law Society treasurer.
q „ g F. Well'in
fighter," one banner. proclarnred. � rt 4�� � d.� '�•' ��*� '"#r�'� � <h �� ��`��� � partner, in 1916, he sou ht new gton Hay. MLA, Thomas
-Another: "Centre Huron stands x,�a, " , • affiliations and eventual ,
Marshall, MLA. Bearers were
by Mr . • Proudfoot." i . :x�". Xy became senior partner in the firm 1✓.J. B. Duncan and ,I. P. Ti.sd�i'141.,K
Centre Huron • ' of Proudfoot, Killoran and ' Toronto; Wm: W. Hutchinson and
'
On the same day, As .. r: x
Liberals °held their an al • Holmes, of Goderich. In 1902 he W.L.. Elliott, London; .I L.
Liberals
at w is on otron of. Proudfoot M e''1r1or' •- ' ng, Killoran wird Judge 1 N. Lewis,
h
f..y« .. ...... �..� _,......« r •+M,r-«r r •r°. r«...r.•,...,-....---,..,,,„..—,:,..„--.-....--r.- , _-b :r_ ,"• -. :Y+ - , ". D. - - en?++lT ,!•••«+—Mme,+.r.-.r:.. n.�
was made a s Counsel.
J.J. Robertson and John Fingland - :' ° ` " saw.: y a fie-"`tr rtsferfeti'"-h'M "doderich:' ; ' .
it gave "warm endorsation to Mr. Provincial convention in, 1919: resolution of censure upon him . 'major activities to Toronto, , Mr. Proudfoot married, in
- • , establishing the firm later known 1886, Marion F. Dickson,
rinciple
a r
convention'of Oct. 6, 1919, `field in
„ eo
for voting for extension of the
Legislature and favouring Udell
Gpvernm ent., Mr. Proudfoot said:
"On both questions; I believed 1'
was .exercising my judgment
strictly in accordance with tree
Liberalism, which means, if it
means anything, that a man hasa,
right to exercise his opinion
.aceoroir)g to the dictates' of his,
conscience."
He (leclded, ''at the sglicitaaiOn •
of many' Iriends'•," to jun as. an
• • election. That was the year of the
U.F.Q. sweep, and there was ;a.
third candidate in Centre Huron,
R. Livingstone, ofGrey ,township.
The Liberals nominated • J. M.,
Govenlock, of 'McKillop, and that
township came up with 397,votes
for. him. Centre - Huron
Conservatives, approving Mr.
Proudfoot's Unionist '•stand, did
not put up -a candidate to oppose
him. In Goderich he received 1126
votes; nearly twice as many as In
1914. Even in Seaforth he gained
120 votes. His total in the riding
was nearly 50 per gent greater
thanin 1914, but was 163 short of
"Mr. Govenlock's 3193. The UFO °
candidate received 2039. Thus the
Liberal candidate. won the seat,
but held ,in only until the next
election, when Centre Huron sent
Ebon R. ' Wigle, Goderich
druggist, -to stand among Howard -
FerguTon's 75 Conserva xves. •
few weeks after the 1919 years he .was County Crown
election, • Mr. Proudfoot was Attorney. The Huron ' . Bar
appointed to the Senate of :Canada. Association honored him. -with its
He was given the Territorial Title, presidency over a period of 25
of Senator from Huron. The years, and for many years he was,
appointment was made by Sir president of West Huron Liberal
.40
Marathon 99 participants unload their machines at the Sunset Golfe
and Sports Center north of Goderich Sunday in preparation for a 99
mile trek to raiseefnnds for the Goderich Kinsmen Club's Cystic
F ibrosis Campaign. Despite pooh• weather- the snowrmob.i lers raised
funds that il is hoped wi I l total $1600 when -all the returns are in: The
Marathon 99 was originally set for ,two weeks .ago but due to poor
weather that weekend was cancelled.—staff photo
Home Dressed Select Meat
PILLYOVR' FREEZER-
WHOLESAIE
PRICES
We Buy Direct From The Producer — Save the Cost Of
The Micicife Man - all our him' Is Goveirrroent inspected
as Proudfoot, Duncan, Gilday and daughter of William Dickson,
Tisdall, but now Proudfoot, Goderich. Their residence in
Tisdall and Logan. , ate Goderich was at the Waterloo -
At the ' provincial election of Elgin corner where the
1908, Mr. Proudfoot received the Pentecostal 'Tabernacle now
-Liberal nomination and stands. They had one son.
succeeded in breasting the sweep
for
for the' Conservatives which left
-only 19 Liberals In the House. He
was elected in 1911 and again in
1914. On January 3,1918, after N":'
W. Rowell's elevation to the
Dominion cabinet ^ under Sir
Robert Borden, the Centre Huron
.member was called to the.
temporary - leadership of the
Liberal party in the Legislature.
"During the 1918 session,"
says the New Era obituary
article, "his general policy was
one of co-operation with the
Conservative government for the
facilitation of -wartime activities.
He supported the bill to prolong
14th)" Legislature until the return
of the soldier voter, and spoke in
favor oft various other
government ' measures. His
pronounced stand. in favor or
Union Government arouSed some
opposition from within his own
party. He • stuck to his guns,
however, and in June, 1919, at the
provincial Liberal convention
was not successful in obtaining
election as perrtlanent leader.
"Mr. Proudfoot contested'
Centre Huron in 191,9 as an
independent. He was' defeated by
John M. Govenlock bythe narrow
margin of . 1S3._... votes— His
appointment to the Senate by the
n
Union Government~ was Announced
a few weeks later,
"Prior to coming to Toronto
Mr. Proudfoot had served for nine
years, (1889.1907inclusive) as
reeve of Goderich. For some
•4,.
William, and one daughter.
Isobel. William died in Toronto in .,
1964. Isobel was married to
Ernest Hastings Jordan. sort of
Francis Jordan. Ernest was a
chemical engineer at Sulphide and
Sudbury. He died in Toronto in
1951, - Mrs. Jordan in 1970.
Two memorj,a1 windows in St.
George's are dedicated to Hon.
William and Mrs. Proudfoot.
The body of the latesenator was
interred Maitland Cemetery..
Upon the memorial stone 'there
are carved certain words found in
the Gospel of St. Luke. This
passage, in part, as follows: -
"Behold, there was a man, a
counsellor, and he was a good man
and a just."
SERY10E
would like to call on you with
r
f
ousewar men
btifts"
td
information, about,
you're new
!citation. The Hostess will be
glad to arrange your subscription
to the SIGNAL -STAR.
Call her at 624-9620
b
Just before taking off on their 99 mile trip snowmobilers discuss last minute details with a "Marathon
99" organi,zer,t'egarding the route and snow conditions. Although the weather was far from ideal -for
snowmobil iling 16 of the 17 contesthnts to startfinishedthefu,Il'tht1eetircuits of the 33 mile route and
raised about $1600 for. Goderich Kinsmen Club's Cystic F ibrosis 'campaign.;—,staff photo •° °
M1
Keeping it clean
A western Ontario college
student wrote the. Department of
the Environment the other day
raving about --the wonderful
pollution study and control
system they have in Japan.
He wanted to know when Ontario
was going to do something about
pollution. He thought we should
follow Japan's lead
We Thought you knew. That's
what .-fhe Department of the
Environment is all about. We,run
Ontario's pollution cbntt'ol
system and it's probably the hest
in the world. At least that's what
all the touring government people
from the United States, Europe
arid Asia keep telling us.
Pollution, conservation, noise,
waste...these are the things that
worry us.
We're working on them • .
•We take F•ou-r, order%_ -from
George Kerr, the Minister of the
Environment -in Prime Minister
William Davis's s's Government.
Our Air Management Branch
tracks down funny smells in the
air and some things you can't
smell - and gets rid of- them if
r� 4
with Bill Dodds
they are dangerous. They even -do
things about the harmless odors
that just, make breathing
disagreeable.
As far as we know, air pollutio n
hasn't killed or injured anyone in
Ontario. And we are making sure
that it never does. `
It has happened in other places
— London, Tokyo and New York
--- and we're not going to let it
happen here. The Environmental
Protection Aet gives us the
authority to see that it doesn't.
OurWaste Management Brandi
worries about ea rb-ase—
industrial waste, farm waste,
radioactive waste, sewage sludge
and the cans you put out for' the
garbage collector every week.
Did you .-know• the average
person in Ontario's cities and
towns throws away half a ton of
---garbage a year?
Uwe .don't do something, we'll
be up to Our ears in the stuff.
That's what waste ntanagenient is
all about. The Branch controls
how waste is carried away and
disposed of( The Branch sets the
standards, with provincial
legislation to back them up -- and
the operators of disposal systems
follow the rules or else...
The c onservhtion Authorities,
Branch gives advice, money and
know-how to.local groups
interested in keeping green
places with trees and clean, clear
water for us and our children.
We're helping 37 local groups who
_fun Conservation Authorities in
their watersheds` and we are
always ready to help a new
authority get started,
The Ontario Water Resources
Commission, also a part of the
• Department of the Environment,
does the same thing for our rivers
and lakes that the Air
Management people do ;for our
air. And theytoo have the legal
muscle to keep things clean.
'two new services ret
entl
Y.
Ioibbd the-detiarttrl ft -One-deals
with pesticides and the other with
private sewage disposal. Well.
have MOO to, say about them
latera„ ,.•
That's what is °All -bout, Now
y• ou know..