The Citizen, 1991-09-11, Page 21There should be rejoicing
instead there's frustration
It's that time of year when we should be rejoicing at the bountiful
harvest. In this area, we were lucky this year that all the right ingredients
of everything came together and, with a few exceptions, we'll have near
record-breaking crops. There was just the right amount of rain when we
needed it, and the weather, which was sunnier and warmer than usual, after
that cold backward spring, made it almost feel like the garden of Eden.
Anyone driving around central Huron in the middle of July would surely
rejoice that this was the best place in the world in which to live. At our
home, we had one of the best gardens in decades, from platter-sized
cabbages to grapefruit-sized peppers. Even the late tomatoes, which
weren't seeded until the first week of May on the gamble that we'd get a
couple before the first frost, have already yielded bushels of juicy, ripe
fruit that have found themselves in the freezer as sauce or whole bagged
tomatoes.
That's why it seems almost sacrilegious for this writer to join farmers in
complaining that things are not very well on the concession roads. Cash
crop farmers in particular — that is those who grow winter wheat, spring
grain, com and soy beans and then sell them the same year (or hold them
to be sold when prices improve the following spring) are facing returns for
those crops that are the lowest in about 15 years, in real dollars. But costs
to put those crops in the ground have continued to escalate at about five
per cent a year and so many farmers are facing a cash crunch, they may not
survive the winter. Now anyone in business knows that to stay in business,
you have to have slightly more coming in the door every year than is going
out. In the past decade, because of an international grain war, that hasn't
been happening in Canadian agriculture, and as a result, we've lost a third
of our farmers in the last 10 years, while the debt level has remained the
same — some $20 billion worth here in Ontario.
So why are our farmers going out of business in record numbers? And
what does that say about the future food supply of Canada if those food
producers are not around and we have to depend on foreign countries for
our food supply? Already Ontario imports more food than it exports,
mainly because of fresh fruits and vegetables, but can you have an
independent nation if you're not self-subsistent in food?
The United States doesn't think so. In fact the gap between U.S. and
Canadian agricultural policy is rapidly widening. American food policy is
carefully defined and implemented under the U.S. Farm Bill which tells
their farmers (and the whole world) what farm policy will be five years
ahead of time. Americans tell their consumers how important agriculture
is to the well being of America. As the world's largest exporter of farm
products, the U.S. know that each dollar earned from agricultural exports
stimulates another $1.52 of output in the U.S. economy — about $100
billion in 1989. In fact, most people are surprised when told that
agriculture gives the U.S.'s greatest competitive advantage in trade, ahead
of high tech, finished capital (cars and manufactured goods) intermediate
manufacturing, mining, and fish and forestry.
It's no wonder then, that American agricultural policies are structured to
encourage, promote, protect, and gain access to markets for its farm
products.
However in Canada, the media, academics, and politicians talk of how
much farm subsidies "cost" the treasury and that protection of markets
"costs" consumers and leads to inefficiency, as well as telling Canadian
farmers they must learn to be more competitive in the trading world. Even
the Federal Progressive Conservative party, — traditionally looked upon in
rural Canada as strong supporters of farmers — voted at their recent policy
convention on resolutions to undermine the Canadian Wheat Board, as
well as get the Farm Credit Corporation out of direct farm lending. Both
were Tory creations. Delegates even refused to confirm support for supply
management, and instead called for a study of the impact of the farm
products marketing system on consumer prices. Now if George Bush's
Republican Party even suggested those resolutions in the U.S., he'd be a
footnote in the history books as the only president to put both feet in his
mouth and swallow his shoes whole!
It's time that Canada and our politicians got behind their farmers as
strongly as the Americans do because our farmers contribute just as much
to this country's prosperity as the U.S. farmers do to their country's. This
latest farm crisis dramatically points out that Canadians need to have an
attitude change if our farmers are to survive on a world market. And we
need to implement solid government assistance programs to back them up.
Farmers plan emergency
meeting at Lucknow tonight
Canadian farmers need help to
get them through 1991 or they will
eventually be forced to give up
their farms, the Canadian Federa
tion of Agriculture says.
Appearing before the House of
Commons Standing Committee on
Agriculture Aug 29, the Federation
stated that without help this year,
many farmers will enter 1992 in
such a weak financial state that
they will be unable to prevent the
failures of their operations in the
future.
“In April, then Agriculture Min
ister Don Mazankowski and Prime
Minister Brian Mulroney promised
to support the agriculture industry.
This has not yet been done,” First
Vice-President Jacques Proulx told
the committee.
“Farmers want to obtain their
incomes from the agriculture indus
try but they haven't been able to do
this in recent years. Farmers are,
therefore, forced to turn to govern
ment for assistance,” he said.
Mr. Proulx, appearing with repre
sentatives from CFA's member
Continued from page 1
blank, as U.S. president George
Bush did with Iraq last January,
"the line had been drawn in the
dirt".
Organizers are hoping that 500
farmers will turn out to tell their
politicians their concerns. Expected
to attend are Huron MPP Paul
Klopp, who is parliamentary assis
tant to Ontario's minister of agricul
ture; Huron-Bruce MP Murray
Cardiff, who is parliamentary assis
tant to the federal minister of agri
culture, and Bruce MPP Murray
Elston, who is interim leader of of
the official opposition Liberal
party.
Farmers are looking for assis
tance to cover depressed prices on
winter wheat, spring grain, corn
and soybeans grown in 1990. A
new stabilization plan kicks in next
year, but many fanners are fearful
they won't be around next spring to
benefit from the new program.
Yju can lose a lot
more than your licence
drinking and driving.
THE CITIZEN, WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11,1991. PAGE 21.
Farmers need help now
Federation tells MP’s
organizations, noted the single
most important reason for dimin
ishing returns in agriculture is the
internal subsidy war being played
out by the European Community
and the United States, especially in
the grains and oilseeds sector.
Declining incomes have forced
members of farm families to seek
off-farm jobs. Even with off-farm
income, Canadian farm families
make less than other Canadians.
Recent data show that the average
farm family makes only 91.88 per
cent of what is made be the average
Canadian family.
While income figures forecast for
this year are particularly low, farm
ers have also come through a diffi
cult decade. “Total net farm income
forecasted for 1991 will decline by
22.35 per cent compared to the
1990 level after a drop of 12.35 per
cent from the 1989 level,” Proulx
said. “Most important of all is that
in real terms the total net farm
income has never been as low for at
least the past two decades," the
Quebec dairy and sheep farmer
added.
The Federation noted that the
increased food prices paid by con
sumers have not been passed onto
farmers. For example, the retail
price of cereal flakes made from
100 per cent com increased 94.5
per cent from 1980 to 1989 with
the price of corn to the farmer
decreasing 8.8 per cent. The price
of a box of soda biscuits increased
235 per cent and the price of sweet
cookies containing 25 per cent
flour increased 135 per cent. At the
same time, the final realized price
for wheat increased only 0.4 per
cent. Beef prices increased 8.8 per
cent from 1983 to 1990. to the
farmer and 24.6 per cent to the con
sumer.
Mr. Proulx also told the commit
tee that the price of hogs dropped
25.3 per cent from 1982 to 1989.
While small increases were experi
enced in the price to farmers of
fruits and vegetables excluding
potatoes, these increases were far
below the increase in the General
Consumer Price Index.
LONDESBORO CO-OP
LONDESBORO
Elevator 523-4470 Office 523-9606
• Fast Efficient Service!
• Wagon Dumpers!!
• Trucking Available!!!
• Fair Grades & Prices!!!!
/ co-op 'r Londesboro Co-op is
pleased to provide farmer-
/^^^^owned grain & bean elevator facilities in
/W|_ondesboro. By working together, farmers can
build their own successful agri-business!
WHITE
BEANS