The Lucknow Sentinel, 1985-03-20, Page 31Farmers react cautiously
to federal white paper
By Randy Thiendyle
local farmers are taking a cautious reaction
to Finance Minister Michael Wilson's recent-
ly released federal: white paper called Tax
Issues in Agriculture.
When the " report was released in late
February, it ,caused a stir in the farming
community and the media. Figures from the
report suggested farmers were nine times
more wealthy than the average Canadian,
earned twice as much per year, and paid only
one quarter the income tax of the average.
Canadian.
The major concern expressed by most local
fanners revolves around those statistics and
how they were interpreted.
The report was prepared by the finance
department at the request of the finance
minister' in order to help create new tax
policies for fanners. The• concern expressed
by many fanners and, by the minister in
published newspaper accounts is that the
statistics'in the report are out of date and do
not accurately represent the state of farming
income today.
Most of the figures used in the report were
taken from'a Farm Credit Corporation Survey
completed last fall. The most recent figures in
that survey were taken., in 1981 when the
inflation rate was high and land was more
expensive than it is today.
The report suggests that the average farm
was worth $508,000 of which $417,000 or 82
per cent is debt free. It compares that figure
to the net wealth of the average Canadian
which is pegged at $47,000.
Wayne Robinson, a Port Elgin area farmer
and president of the Bruce County Fiederation
of Agriculture, says the report makes a
mistake when it attempts to compare the net
wealth of fanners to individuals. .
Robertson suggests that farms should be
compared to small or medium sized business-
es. He also took exception to the equity.
figures.
"Equity isn't true wealth unless you sell
the farm"
Gary Gurbin, Bruce -Grey MP says the
paper is not a statement of government
policy, but is designed to provide a basis for
discussion.
"Recent newspaper reports have created a
controversy by misinterpreting the statistics
and the purpose of the paper Unfortunately
the most recent statistics available in many
instances were from 1981," he says.
Gurbin says there have been significant
changes in land values and equity in farm
operations in the last three years. '
He says Finance Minister Wilson, "has no
illusions about the figures in the report,' but in
many cases they were the most up to date
figures available."
The finance department intends to get
more information from farmers and farm
groups before any recommendations are
made in the federal budget expected
sometime this spring, says Gurbin.
The finance department is considering,
several proposals for the budget but wants to
know which ones farmers consider to be "top
priority", before Making a decision, says
Gurbin.
"We can't do everything'at once."
Of the proposals now before the finance:
department, a reduction in farm capital gains
tax appeared to be the most likely tax reform.
Robertson says the federation is taking a
cautious, approach to the white paper and
plans to make a written response to. it some
time this month.
He stresses the need for storage comodity
prices to solve the long term problems in
agriculture.
"One thing the report does point out is the
constant and continual decline in farm
income," says Robertson.
Interpretation of paper shocking
The interpretation of the frgines in -the
federal govenunent's white paper on tax
issues in farming, and further misinterpre-
ations in the news media are shocking and
appalling, according to the Ontario Federa-
tion of Agriculture (OFA).
From an emergency executive meeting
held in Toronto on Flebruary 25, OFA
president Hang Plelissero said, "While
figures don't lie, interpretations may vary."
He said the white paper, prepared at the
request of Finance Minister Michael Wilson,
is "one sided and not current."
"Fbr instance, in discussing the decline in
land values, the white paper stops at 1981.
Since then, land values have plummeted,
especially in western Canada where they
were hit by drought."
"Some of the comparisons used in the,
study and reported in the media are
illogical," Perlissero said. "To compare the
worth of the average farm to the worth of the
average Canadian family is comparing apples
and oranges. It would he more credible to
show a business to bus h ess comparison."
The white paper's figures on the rate of
return on equity may look good on paper, if
it's interpreted to be 19.3 per cent for the
years between 1975 and 1983, "But farm
groups aren't talking about the golden days of
the seventies. According to the tables in the
white paper, for 1982 and 1983, fanners have
been losing on their equity. The crisis has
been in recent years, Pelisser° said.
Another illogical comparison, Pelisseo
said, is between the value of farm land and
trading stocks: "The fact that the"value of
rural real estate has increased means noth-
Mg. A farmer can't dump his business as
easily as he could shares on the Toronto Stock
Exchange. Equity, or paper value, doesn't
put the kids through school or put shoes on
their feet,". Pelissem said.
In addition, Plelissero said, the white paper
shows that in 1982 and 1983, the nominal
value of lands- and buildings / declined
significantly. "Once again, these are the
crisis years, and the severity of the problems
is diffused when the interpretations inoorpor-
ate figures from 1972.
The white paper's interpretations should
not be read in isolation, and the contents of
the 64 page document cannot accurately be
summarized in a brief news story, Pelissero
said."The Farm Credit Corporation did a
thorough study on Canadian farmers which
showed that 17 per cent are in severe.
financial stress; 'seven per cent` are in
moderate distress and the. remaining 76 per
cent are more stable because they have the
minimum equity needed' to give them a
reasonable chance to survive in agriculture.",
"This is a far cry from the white paper's
interpretation that only 3.2 per cent are in the
distress category. The • contradiction in
figures, both. from government departments,
proves Only that there is no definitive
statement on what his happening in the farm
sector. As president of an organization that
represents over 24,000 farm, families, I can
only say that there is more than/enough cause
turn to page 27
HERMAN
AUCTIONS
Give Us A Try
HOME AND FARM
CONSIGNMENT AND
ESTATE SALES
Competitive Prices!.
Herman Herbrink
Dial 881-3763
WALKERTON
The Farm Edition, Week of March 20, 1985 - 11
524-2177
ALEXANDER 8 CHAPMAN
REALTY LIMITED
10 The Square - GoderIch
25 ACRES near Holmesville on Highway
No. 8. House, born, driving shed and
garage.
72 ACRES - Highway 21. EXCEPTIONAL
HOUSE, born & shed. Close to lake.
100 ACRES with buildings, near
Lucknow.
100 ACRES cash crop, near Lucknow.
Member of the Huron Real Estate Board
A.J. Alexander 524-7836
Gus Chisholm
Murray Rourke
J. Roger 1urcotte
524-8554
524-2569
524-7298
PIONEER
SEED CORN
•3906 3803 3925
,3950 •3949
PAND•SOYBEAIONEN SEEDER®
BR
SOYBEANS
1282 •0877 ..
PIONEER
BRAND•ALFALFA SEED
ALFALFA
•532 .524 •526
- Farriers calland checkout the good prices
on Alfalfa this year.
Ray Brown
R. R. 6, GoderIch 529-7260
(Otk
PIONEER.
BRAND • SEED CORN
Pioneer Is a brand name; numbers Identity
varieties. a Registered trademark licensed to
Pioneer H1 -Bred Limited Chatham, Ontario
LOOKS
EXPENSIVE.
LOOK AGAIN.
LIST OFDUAL
STANDARD
FEATURES
PRICE
5SPEED
OVERDRIVE
STEELBELTED
RADIALS
TINTED
GLASS
INTERMITTENT
WIPEN5
DOOR
MIRRORS
RADIO
AADIO
SVEAN
arawcE
PROTECTION
PLAN
1986 MAZDA
62000
$7675*
STD
a
STD
STD
STD
STD =
STD
STD
1985 TOYOTA
$7998'
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
OPT
OPT
1985 NISSAN
$7694•
STD
STD'
NA
NA
OPT
OPT
OPT
1986 MAZDA 82000
57675*
M -VV MOTORS LTD.
184 East St coa..mn 5242113