HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Huron Expositor, 1979-08-16, Page 100:11.,, THE
HURON EXPOSITOR, AUGUST 16, 10/9
renaipiy
by ANC* Gibb
William Donnelly, the handsome 34 -year
cid survivor of the DImIlleitt PlassaCrewas
an unwanted reminder for the Biddulph:
Peace Society that they had failed in their
mission to rid the Lucan area of the 'wild
kish family.
Now a more cautious man than Will
would likely have immediately relocated
his family to safer territory following the
funerals; of his parents, brothers and
cousin, but Will Donnelly was never one to
back down from a fight-
An article in the Expositor reported
Donnelly "is possessed f an undaunted
courage, as is manifest from the cool
• carelessness with which he travels about
the locality filled with friends and relatives
of the men now awaiting trial in the London
ga01.##
For Seaford) and area residents, Will
Donnelly's story held a special fascination.
The man had lived in Zurich for some time
and ran a stage line between that town and
Seaforth for over a year. The young man,
according to the Expositor, often drove the
stage himself and was. "exceedingly
affable and obliging and was a general
&write along the road."
In the weeks following the Biddulph.
murders, Will Donnelly received a number
of threats warning him that his life was still
co the line. One letter warned, 'You know
well enough whom the slugs were 'intended
for that took effect in your brother John. It
was a slight miscarriage but it was as well
to get Jack out of the way. There may be a
slug or two left for you if you don't be
careful. . .I am not a man that does
anything by halves. My motto is "root and
hranch" when a family has to be
exterminated by reason of their
depredatory and incendiary acts and I
believe you are a member of such a famiky
.Yours warningly, One Who Knows
't,FOR•IMI••.41,•••••?!...,17.1. ,.1•77P•717aggli••77.M.7.77•••••T•i7••,,•.•• •
What He Knows."
The letter's author was suspected m. be *
london lawyer whose brother .served MI the
vigilante; Committee.
But ntany newspaper readers liked to
believe the letters were actually written by
Donnelly himself to win sympathy for the
survivors. A letter writer to the Globe went:
even further/he suggested Will PotIPCHY
bimself !had Oulu his family-
RRESTS.
The Man Who had to supervise the
investigation of the Donnelly murders was
William Thomas Trounce Williams, chief
of police of London. The men his officers
Arrested on suspicion of murder included
Incan. constable James •Carroll; John
Kennedy Jr., brother-in-law of Will
Donnelly; Martin McLaughlin; Thomas
Ryder; James. Maher Sr. and Jr.; John,
Darcey; Grouchy Ryder; Pat Ryder, Jr.,
Michael Hennan; William Carroll; John
Purtell; Mrs. James Maher and the
Maher's hired man, James Shea. At first,
several of the prisoners were lodged in the
Liman jail, and later moved to London.
James Shea proved a particular favorite
with the London policemen, since he was a
talkative British army veteran who
entertained with a string of war stories. As
the investigation continued, a number of
the original suspects were freed.
The men who finally came to.. trial
included James Carroll, Martin
McLaughlin, John Kennedy, Thomas and
James Ryder and John Purtell.
The first step in bringing the Biddulph
Peace Society to heel was a public inquest
held in Lucan shortly after the Donnelly
funerals.
The witnesses included the three
Whalens and young Johnny O'Connor.
The O'Connor evidence was the ritnst
damning he identified James. Z'..arroil,
It*e,r and Purteiiaswembers of the hand
Mat tbrolte int* the Donnelly home /end
mcd_ ered the familY.
IfrPAITIES UNKNOWN"
The 15 juirs at the inquest deliberated
all night, ably assisted by a pail of beer
sent up to their , quarters by a friendly
Lucan iperchant, and returned a verdict the
next - the'Donnelly family had
been killed by "sqm6; ,party oz parties
unknown", The general feeling noted by
reporters covering the trial Was still that
the Donnellys got "just what they
deserved."
When the Biddulph defendants were
brought to the preliminary hearing in the
Kddlesex courthpuse, London, on Feb..
21, there were so many of them they had M
sit in, the jurors' box. Their friends and
relatives kept them well supplied with gifts,.
of food throughout the trial, including fresh
fruit and candy, presented to them When
court was in session.
Again, the major testimony was de-
livered by young Johnny O'Connor but this
time, Will Donnelly was also called to the
stand. He identified John Kennedy, James
Carroll and John Ryder as the men who
shot his younger brother and testified he
also thought he recognized the voices of
Martin McLaughlin and James. Ryder in
the late night attack at Whalen's Corner,
Of the 13 people held on suspicion of the
vigilante murders, only eight were commit-
ted for trial. With Johnny O'Connor
considered the most valuable witness, he
was placed under the special protection of
London police constable Charles Pope. The
O'Connors however, proved to be a trying
family. They demanded special cash
allowances and better living conditions and
Mrs. O'Connor tried unsuccessfully to
claim a reward offered by the government
C,
for information on the :Biddulph murders.
le014111y Caistable Pope decided while
Johnny was a pleasant young man, he
could stand the antics of the family no
ionger.
The fliddulph murder trial, came up first
ott the spring assizes of Middlesex County
court, and the defence lawyers pleaded for
a change of venue due to feeling in the
area. Their appeal was denied but the case ,
was held over to the fall session of court,
The defendants remained in jail where
some complained of gaining weight and the
jack of exercise. When John Kennedy's
mother died, he was refused leave to
attend her funeral.
The court decided to try former Lucan,
constable James Carroll first, and charged
hirr, with the murder of Johanna},
Donnelly. Again, Johnny O'Connor offered
the key testimony, but this time defence
law produced a couple who swore that
both the Carroll brothers spent the entire
night of the murder in their home. When
the :jury went out on Saturday morning,
spectators and reporters expected a guilty
verdict. Late Saturday the jury returned to
the courtroom and announced to the judge
they were unable to reach a consensus.
Will Donnelly continued his campaign to
hunt tip incriminating evidence against the
defendants, and the police tried to
persuade John Purtell, considered the
weakest of the' conspirators, to confess.
Purtell resisted.
THE LAST TRIAL
On Jan. 28, 1881, the Expositor reported
the second trial of James Carroll was
underway in London and "the witnesses
are as reticent as ever, and the evidence
has to be dragged from them." When
-Johnny O'Connors described 'the beating
death of Bridget Donnelly to the crowded
courtroom, Carroll became ill and had to be
The Sound of Music provides a
harmonious finish to season Tattoo featured at CNE
The nuron Country Play- singing than doing her
house winds up a most assigned chores. She is sent
successful season with a off to become governess to
family favourite, The Sound the seven children of wealthy
of Music. The Rodgers and widower, Captain von Trapp,
Hammerstein musical tells played by Peter J. McColl -
the true story of the von nell.. Eventually, the Captain
Trapp family, who fled from and Maria marry and escape
Germany during Hitler's re- from war torn Germany over
gime to the safety of the mountains to
America, where they became Switzerland.
famous folk singers.. 4t ' Cast in the roles of the
begins in the abbey of 'children are seven local
Nonnberg, Austria, where a. youngsters, Douglas Wood -
young postulant Maria, burn, Lisa Cain, Jeff Green -
played by Deirdre Van wood, Mary Margaret
Winkle, is more intersted in Murphy, Jennifer
Canadian Fiadio-television Conseil de la radiodinusio
and Tilecommunications et des telecommunications
Commission canadiennes
Notice of Public Heaeing
HULL/OTTAWA
2 OCTOBER 1979, 09:00
: The Canadian Radio -television and Tele-
communications Commission will hold a
Public Hearing beginning on October 2, 1979
at the Conference Center, Phase '141,, 140
Promenade du Portage, Hull, Quebec to
consider the following:
ONTARIO REGION
JOHN C. WARD, GOWANSTOWN,
ONTARIO
Mitchell, Seaforth, Ontario and surrounding:
ares. [790759500]
Application for renewal of its cable
television broadcasting licence serving
Mitchell, Seaforth, Ontario and surrounding
area, expiring March 31, 1980.
Locations where the applicatian may be
examined:
Town Hall,
Mitchell, Ontario.
Town' Hall, '
Seaforth, Ontario. -
GENERAL INFORMATION.
How to intervene—Anyone wishing to
comment on an application must Submit a
written intervention, stating clearly and
''concisely the relevant facts and the reasons
for the intervener's support for, opposition
to, or proposed modification of, the appli-
cation - also whether or not the,intervener
wishes to appear at, the hearing.
Deadline for receipt of interventions at the
Commission and with the Applicant:
September 12, 1979. - to be sent by
registered mail or personal delivery to
Applicant and CRTC Ottawa, Ontario, K1A
0N2 with proof of service. Must be actually
received on specified date, not merely posted
on this date.
Examination of Applications and Documents
—At local address given in this notice and at
the Commission, Central Building, Les
Terrasses de la Chaudlere, 1 Promenade du
Portage, Room 561, Hull, Quebec.
Further information Is outlined in Rules of
Procedure available for the sum of 35 Cents
from: The Publishing Centre, Printing
Centre, Printing and Publishing, Department
of Supply and Services, 270 Albert Street,
Ottawa, Ontario. Information: Write to CRTC
or phone 819-997-1027 or 997-1328.
Ottawa J.G. Patenaudo,
August '7,1979 Acting Secretary Genoial.
CRTC - Public Notice 1979-97
McCrindle, Myvonney God-
win and Cathenne lnculet.
Also in the cast are Trudy
Mason, Sister Barbara Ianni,
Lynda Maxwell, Nancy Kerr,
Philip Street, lOmberley
McCaffrey, Mark Bolton,
Patty Gail', John Heath,
Mark Flear, Joseph Vayda,
Celia Punter, Elaine Allen,
Jillian Brown and Kathy
Kaszas.
The Sound of Music, is
directed by James Murphy,
musical direction is by Erna
Van Daele with
choreography by Jillian
Brown. The show opens on
August 22 and plays through
September 1, except August.
28. Two preview perform-
ances will be held on
Tuesday, August 21 and
Wednesday, August 22
The glory and pageantry of
Scotland's colourful heritage
will echo throughout Tor-
onto's Canadian National
Exhibition from August 16 to
19 with the staging of the
1979 Scottish World Festival
Tattoo at Exhibition Stad-
ium.
Featuring the Scots
Guards and the Royal High-
land Fusiliers from Britain
and Australia's Scots College .
the Tattoo is a two -and -a -half
hour spectacle unmatched
anywhere in the World.
The '79 Tattoo, with an
international cast of •over
1,200 performers, also will
feature bagpipe bands from
Scotland, Australia, North
ern Ireland, England and
Canada, plus some of the
world's finest military bands
from the British Isles and the
Blyth to hold benefit
Patrons will have one last
chance to see This Foreign.
Land at the Blyth Summer.
Festival this year. A benefit
performance of the play has
been scheduled for Saturday,
August 18 at 2 p.m. All
proceeds from the per-
formance will be donated to
the Actors' Fund of the
Canadian Actors Equity
Association.
Actors, technicians and
administrative staff will be
volunteering their time and
services, over and above
their regular duties, in order
to make this performance a
success. The total
of all admissions paid to the
performance will be used to
aid those actors who,
through, illness or misfor-
tune,' have become unable to
practise their craft.
Admissionto this perform-
ance is at regular Festival
prices -- S4.25 for adults,
$3.50 for senior citizens, and
S2.50 for children. Re-
servations for the perform-
ance must be made through
the Festival's main box office
(phone 523-9300).
The final performance of
This 'Foreign Land will be
that evening, August 18, at
030 p.m.
ATTEIV11ION
QUIL'TERS
A Quilting at Bethel
s • Bible Church
Aug. 21-24
for
WOODSTOCK AREA
TORNADO VICTIMS
Donations of qullt tops
linings and baths.
apprecbited
Phone
527-0119 527-0952'
toestit itai*****
Huron 4
.co ca*
,0 Tavern
e e
#'4
N.°
Wed.—Sat.
& Sat.
Matinee IP.
•
•
read Et Buttert
11111
Conthmous Entertainment from 8 p.m. to 1 a.m. lilt
III HIGHWAY /08 DUBLIN 345.2820 1111/
$11i4.0.44Vipas
Next Weekend
Applause
Dining Room
Open Daily from 12 Noon
Good Old -Fashioned
Home -Cooked Meals
United States.
Also included in the '79
Tattoo will be the grace and
beauty of 80 champion High-
land Dancers...the daredevil
of acrobatics of the Royal
Engineers Gymnastic Team,
one of Britain's best the
colourful Musical Ride to the
Pipes by the. Metro
Toronto Police equestrian
unit...and the Stirring High-
land songs of Glasgow's Jack.
Whyte. .
SUMMER T1MES'79
SCHEDULE OF EVENTS
Monday, August 20th
- a.m. tennis instruction, 9-11:30 SDHS. No fee.
- 1 p.m. craft afternoon (pavillion)
Tuesday, August 2Ist
- 9-11:30 a.m, tennis instruction
- 1 p.m. water afternoon
Wednesday, August 22nd
- 9-11:30 a.m. tennis instruction
- 1 p.m. Basketball skills competition
Thursday, August 23rd
- Mini Golf *Please register, fee to cover costs
Friday, August 24th
- Mini tennis tourney (for those taking lessons)
COMMERCIAL
HOTEL
SEAFORT)-1
This week & Sat. Matinee
-,j1NETTEHPpRTER-$.1101N-r:
Next week & Saturday Matinee
Deacon York and the
Fire "n" Brimstone Band
FIN F. FOOD
FINE F,\'FFH'1'1'\1F"I
s
Thursday, August 16
, 8:30 p.m.
Ethel Community Hall
PURPOSE: TO discuss the Grey
township secondary plan
Grey tovOnShip Counell •
temporarily excused, since, according, to
his doctor, he was suffering from
rheumatism of the heart.
In the end, after hearing over 90,
witnesses, the jury returned a verdict of
"not guilty" and James Carroll and the
other defendants were discharged, carried
out of the courtroom on the shoulder of
their exuberant supporters.
The verdict was also greeted with cheers
when it was posted on the door of the
Lucan post office. The Expositor, in
announcing the decision, concluded "it is
now likely the perpetrators of the horrible
crime will forever remain hidden, unless
some providential occurrence will hereafter
disclose the mystery."
Will Donnelly left Lucan and operated a
hotel in the town of Appin, where he died'
at the age of 52 years, aged by the family
tragedy. Mysterious fires, and many ef tke
vigilante committee died either violent or
tragic deaths.
Bob Donnelly, another Of the family's
sundvors, did return toLIMO, and
operated the West End hotel for many
years, dying in 1911 in the Ontario Hospital
for the Insane.
The vigilantes did escape punishment
for their crime, but their descendants have
often been plagued by historians, writers
and just curiosity seekers, still trying to
solve the mystery of the Biddulph
murders.
The Biddulphites, by taking the law into
their own hands, have .assured James
Donnelly and his family an undying place
in the annals of Canadian folklore, which is,
perhaps the final irony of that night in
February, 1880.
See the
CANADIAN, NATIONAL EXHIBITION
Special .Buses leave Bus Depot in Daily Except
Sundays
GODERICH (Goderich Taxi) - 7:55 A.M.
CLINTON (Bartliff's Bakery) 8:20
SEAFORTH (United Trails) 8:35
MITCHELL (Cosy Grill) 8:50
STRATFORD (Gray Coach) 9:20
Daily August 15 - Sept. 3
For reservations ca
Goderich
Clinton
Seaforth
Mitchell
Sundays
9:55 A.M.
10:20
10:35
10:50
11:20
Stratford
Goderich Taxi Bartliff's Bakery United Trails Cosy Grill United Trails
43 West St. 46 Albert St, 100 Main St. -25 Ontario Rd. 9 Market P1.
524-2092 . , 482-9727 527-1222 348-8741 ' • 271-7741
Coach House Travel
59A Harnilton St. 2 •
or can United Trails 527-1'222.
524-2615
OPEN HOUSE
HYLAND SEEDS
invites you to join us for a tour of our
HYBRID CORN, SOYBEAN, WHITE- BEAN & COLOURED
• PERFORMANCE TRIAL PLOTS
TUESDAY, AUGUST 28, 1979
TIME: 2:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m.
LOCATION: THE BELL BROS. FARM ON No. 4 HIGHWAY,
1/2 MILE SOUTH OF HENSALL.
— Refreshments will be served —
NOTE: In case of rain the date will be Wednesday, August 29th.
W. G. THOMPSON & SONS LIMITED,
BEAN
.\
•
The Huron -Perth County
Roman Catholic Separate School Board
REGISTRATION
OF NEW STUDENTS
i(Kindergarten to Grade 8)
Parents of Kindergarten students who have not yet registered their children
or residents new to the Huron -Perth area may register their children at any
of the follosking schools on -
• TH'URS'PAY,,AP,,19V,S173017H..:;•:„.,,-..
. between the hours of 2 p.m. to 5:30 p.m
HURON COUNTY SCHOOLS
St. Joseph's School (KINGSBRIDGE)
Mr. David Zyluk. Principal
R.R.#3. GODERICH (529-7646)
St. Columban School (ST. COLUMBAN)
Mr. Ray Contois, Principal
R .R.#2. DUBLIN (345-2086)
Our Lady of Mount Carmel School
Mr. Gary Birmingham, Principal
R.R.3, (Mount Carmel) DASHWOOD
(237-3.3,7)
Ecole Ste. Marie
Mrs. Lilliane Laporte. Principal
R.R./2, ZURICH (236-4860)
St. Joseph's School
Mr. Donald Farwell. Principal
169 Beech St.. CLINTON (482-7035)
Precious Blood School
Mr. Laurie Kraftcheck. Principal
Saunders St., EXETER (235-1691)
St. Mary's School •
Miss4ietty Clark, Principal
70 Bennett St., E. GODERICH (524-9901)
Sacred :Heart School
Mrs. Mary O'Malley, Principal. •
Box 68. Corny,. St., WINGHAM
(357-1090)
St. James School
Sister Theresa Mader, Principal
Chalk St., SEAFORTH (527.0321)
St. Bonifate School
Mr. Gactan Blanchette, Principal
Box 128, ZURICH, (236.4335)
PERTH COUNTY SCHOOLS
St.. Patrick's School
Mr. Larry Cook, Principal
Mill St., DUBLIN (345-2033)
Kindergarten children need to be 5 years of ago on or before' Decembir
310, 1979. Where there are suffklent student spaces, a child, who,
attains the age of 5 yeart after the: 31sti of December but prior to the
31st of January, may wi the request Of the parent, be registered In
Kindergarten for the school yam:
Please bring Birth Certificate, Social insurance Numberkif available.
0.H.I.P. Number, Immunization Cards and any other pertinent health
records at the time of registraton.