HomeMy WebLinkAboutZurich Herald, 1928-10-11, Page 7Germany Should Have Won
Germany Should Have WQn the War—That Opinion Will
Probably Surprise You, Coming As It Does Frorn
• the Ex -Generalissimo of the Allied Armies
By MARSHAL FACH
Germany ;could have won the war; general retreat on the whole German
not only at the beginning, but in the front,
epring of 1918. She could have won A psychological explanation is
if her plans, which were very good, given us by the letters of General
had been carried out with More abili. Moltke, Chief of the Great Staff, to
tY.
1 his wife—letters in which the pessi-
, To -day, I still wonder how it was mistic nature and the very advanced
possible that Germany, after having sickness of the General are clearlY
prepared so long for the war, failed revealed,
so lamentably in the execution of her It can consequently be affirmed
strategic schemes, that on the Marne the Central Staff
I wonder, for instance how it was of our adversaries completely failed;
possible that the German General it proved very inferior to its task.
staff neglected its right wing. I Ought the Germans to have follow -
,sed the other seheme—that which ad -
know that Geneeal Count Schlieffen,
who planned the march against vised the defensive on the Western
France through Belgiumfront and an overwhelming offensive, unceasingly against Russia?
insisted on the decisive part which
should have been played by the right, ' A Shorter Line
wing, which had to beselge Antwerp ! I have already mentioned that in
and to occupy the coast of the British the spring of 1918 the Germans could
Channel at least up to Boulogne. still have won. If they had arrived
But the right wing, extending from at Amiens the English Army would
Belgium to the North of France in have been cut off from the French
the shape of a fan, had to be con- Army, and even after the offensive
tinually reinforced, and on bis death.- of General Mangin on July 18, 1918,
bed Count Schlieffen exclaimed: the position of the Germans was not
"Provided that the right wing may be desperate.
strong enough." I I confess that, from the military
ipoint of view, I do not very well un -
Unaccountable Mistake i derstand why, towards the 20th Au -
The German General Staff commit-
ted the great and unaccountable mise
take of weakening the right wing at
the most decisive moment in favor of
the link wing situated in Alsace•Lor-
raine, and in removing from it three
divisions to send against the Russians
in Eastern Prussia, where the battle
between Hindenburg and Rennen-
kampf had, however, already been
won.
The German right wing consequ-
ently, remained too weak and too
small to extend itself up to the sea.
It failed to secure support, aud could
thus be turned.
That is what happened to the army
of Von Kluck when it arrived close
to Paris. Some months later the
Germans endeavored to repair their
error and occupied the coasts, but at
Ypres they were defeated. 1
Ypres was the direct consequence
gust, General Ludendorff did not re.
treat to the line Metz -Meuse -Brussels -
Antwerp. My preparations were
to attack the "Hindenburg Line," and
if the German Army could have retir-
ed to the straight, short line men-
tioned I should have had to recom-
mence everything.
This strategic retreat might have
prolonged the war by one year—and
in critical times many. unexpected
things can happeu in the course of a
year.
On the other hand, I understand
that Ludendorff could not persuade
himself to order this strategic retreat,
but it would have meant the confes-
sion of aa evident inferiority and the
abandonment of very important war
materials which'could not have been
easily replaced.
I will even go so far as to say that
in November, 1918, ' Germanycould
have resisted behind the Rhine. If
of their initial error. The right wing the German people had had a Gam -
was too weak. 1 betta the war would have been pro -
Von Kluck's Retreat 1 langed—and who knows?
1 believe that a people which does
As to whether the German retreat not want to be vanquished need not
in the first battle of the Marne was be. • Of course, in November, 1918,
necessary or too hasty, I consider Germany bad no thrther chance of
that it was both. From the strategic success, but if her army had resisted
point of view (on account of the behind the Rhine many things would
faults that I have mentioned) the have been changed.
German army Pound itself before I speak, of course, from an entirely
for we bad turned its right wing, and t military point ot view. On the oatthaenr.
Paris in a rather precarious position;
hand, I know that Germany,
a gap had formed between the first doned by her Allies and cut off from
army (Kluck) and the second army
(BuloW). the rest of the world, had not enough
Ifood to maintain herself, and that the
On the other hand, the Germans German people, who had suffered se -
could still have recovered, instead of verely, called loudly for peace, imme-
retreating with so much haste. To- diate peace.
day, one may clearly see that the in-! There we must let matters remain.
telligence service of our opponents These retrospectiv'Q considerations of
was very defective, Only thus can history do not serve much purpose,
be explained the part played by although they may often be very in -
Lieutenant -Colonel Hensch, whose teresting. But what would have hap -
pessimistic reports determined the pened if . . .?—Montreal Standard.
Onloom1.111•1101•110•11111
Dinner for Five eggs and 1 cupful of BOUT buttermilk
• •
Beef loaf
Creamed onions
Baked sweet potatoes
Fruit salad Hot Rolls
Devil's food cake
Ice cream
in which 1 teaspoonful of soda has
been dissolved, and 3 cupful of water.
Sift together three times: 2 cupfuls
of sifted flour, 2 tablespoonfuls of
cocoa and 1 teaspoonful of baking
powder. Dredge 1 cupful of raisins
with part of the flour. Stir the liquid
mixture slowly into the rest of the
flour, add the raisins, 1 teaspoonful
Beef Loaf -ot vanilla and last, the stiffly beaten
whites of the 2 eggs. Bake M a
' Put through. the food -chopper 2
moderate oven about 25 minutes if hi
pounds of fresh pork, and 1 slice of
layers; 45 minutes if in a loaf.
onion. Add 1 cupful of bread crumbs
An icing especially good with this
and a well -beaten egg, also a dash of 1
cake is made by peeling and crushing
pepper and 1 teaspoonful of salt. Mix 'a ripe peach and mixing with it about
well together and form into a loaf.
1 cupful of sifted powdered sugar, or
Lay on a greased baking dish and
sufficient to make the frosting spread
bake in a hot oven. Leave uncovered
the first 10 minutes, or until the loaf is well'
To Save Time
, • nicelyseared, to keep the Juices in.
Simmer together for 10 minutes, I. Prepare in the morning the beef
quart of canned tomatoes, ei of a ba l loaf and the sauce to be used ,with
leafeet bruised sprig of parsley, 1 table- it, and leave them in the refrigerator.
spoonful of minced sweet pepper and Potatoes may also be made ready for
baking end the onions cooked. Make
a stalk of celery cut into small pieees.
Strain and pour the liquid over thee the cake and the salad dreesing,
loaf, then reduce the heat and bake in Au hour and a quarter before serv-
ing time, start baking the meat loaf.
a moderate oven„ basting frequently
Half an hour later put the potatoes
until the mea is done. Tothe liquor
in the oven 'and put the salad together,
in thd pan add enough water to make
Set the latter M the refrigerator/ to
1 cupful. It gravy is desired, and
remain until the last thing before
thicken with flour paste as mind.
serving the meal. Set the table and
Fruit Salad order the ice cream. Fifteen minutes
• Cut into dice: 2 bananas, 3 sliees befbre serving time put the rolls into
of pineapple and the pulp from 2 the oven to reheat, With the opening
eranges; add lecupful of grapes halved of the bag, twisted to retain the moist
,
.and seeded-, a, dozen each of dates and ere he rdlls Will taste as if -freehlY
marshmallows cut •into small pieces, baked. Cream the onions and set
and lie of tr' cupful, of blenched. ale ' then' on tap of the oven to keep - hot
monde. e Whip in enough fruit salad when meat and potatoes are done, the
dressitig to give the salad the- right diluter is ready to be served.
consistency and serve ice cold on let-
• uce leaves or in apple cups.
Fruit Salad Dressing taxis and Telephones
Beat the yolks bf two eggs and add A girl from a little village in
slowly the juice frota 2 lenions, then mote country' district took a situation
1/2 of a cupful of maple syrup. Mix as a housemaid in a big city. In her
together well: 1 teaspoonful each of first letter home she Wrote;
cornstarch and sugar, and a pinch "There are many wonderful things
of salt Pour the liquid slowly into here, Mother, None of the cabs has
the dry ingredients, Stirring slowly Itorees, and often 1 lave seen the lady
all the while, and eook over boiling of the house talking to herself
Water mail the mixture is thielt though a candlestick in the hall,"
When, the drossing Is cold, add 1 cup.
fu l of whipped create.
Differences of culture do not neces.
Mnnack Tvenrohy
Bringing out with them
the first moose shot in Quebee
the 1928 hunting season,' Mr. • „
of Miami, Florida, reached
que, Que., at the conclusion of
Vermillion River section with out -
Tile moose secured by Mr. Hock
inches and while far from being the
serve, was a splendid trophy and was
the day on which the hunting opened.
Apron Strings
what was prObably
since the opening of
and Mrs. Oscar Hock,
Montreal from La Tu -
a successful hunt in the
fitter Armand Tremblay.
had an antler spread of 74
largest secured in the pre -
shot in the early morning of
day in and day out. And when "Little
Ben" came, matters only became in-
tensified.
"My Dear," said Sybil to me when And now? Well, people just ask
we were discussing life -in -general, "I Ben out without Jeannie whenever
distinctly foresee the shipwreck of they can, and both Ben and Jeannie
Jeannie's marriage—she flourishes the are puzzled and resentful,
apron -strings too much!" "Anyhow, what could Ben
When fluffy little Jeannie got en- done?" asked Sybil.
gaged to "Big Ben" Travers there had "It's a great pity that he couldn't
been quite a sensation. Frankly—we put her over his knee and spank her
were all of as in love with Ben; but hard. . . ." I believe I replied—for,
we all of us imagined he'd marry didn't I say in the beginning that we
somebody statuesque and frightfully were all a little fond of "Big Ben"?
nice—"accomplished," too, as grand -
mamma might have said! Then sud- Hunters Are Too Old
denly he fell very much in love with
Jeannie. Says Canadian Guide
I think the Whole business rather I
I Take it from one who knows them,
turned Jeannie's head; you see, she an experienced hunting guide, the
had just been one of our set, dancing sporting fellows are a bit ancient.
and playing games all together, and i "Curly" Phillips is one of the best -
then suddenly she became a 'Real P.O- known guides in. the Jasper National
mance and Big Ben Travers' fiancee.
There is no accounting for the peo-
ple who fall in love with each other;
but you can nearly always account for
those who fall out of love!
Keeping Him on a String
It was dreadful, truly. Though at
first Ben did not see how dreadful. It
was "Ben this"—and. "Ben that" (you
know how maddening that can be),
and then. she began to make Ben
fetch and carry; she "cut" her dances
with him.; she flirted round and let
him trapse after her, and, and great
booby that he was, he followed—so
very much did he love her.
But all this was only the prelude
to the more serious business of apron -
strings. After they were married
Jeannie set to work to make a real • guide and the country and go home
"married man" of "Big .Ben." Nearly
!fed up. The young husky fellows svho
every night she fetched him from should be out after game are busier
the office; he felt rather a fool but
than blazes making things go at home.
couldn't bear to hurt her feelings by Thaven't time for hunting until
hey
telling her not to do it too often—she
they get to be sixty or so and then—
well, it's almost too late.
"But the majority of men, oven the
command him to hurry home as Mum oldest, are pretty good. I remember Art stuedrmenetus: tourists,
dial); he was well over fifty but
he was long and lanky and he sure Elbow each other; motors warily
and Dad and Betty and Billy and
Dodge horse-drawn carts; great
buses, thundering
From distant towns, keep wallters
wondering.
A daring and delightful thing to be
A stroller here—one always conies
again!
—Roselle Mercier Montgomery.
have
Park district. He is an experienced
hunter of big horn sheep. In an article
on the Alberta Big Horns in the cur-
rent issue of "Forest and Stream" he
reveals some entertaining knowledge
af human nature.
"The averagessportsman is too old,"
is the guide's verdict. "That's the
trouble. Office men wait until they
are sixty before they take time off to
go on a hunt. That's at the bottom of
nine -tenths of the trouble on the trail.
They come out here from the city and
expect to jump right into the open air
life without noticing it. They avn't
in trim and it tells on them, They
lose their heads and their tempers;
can't adjust themselves; run into dis-
appointments; blame it all on the
'phoned him any and every old time;
sometimes just to tell him. not to for-
get to call at the fishmongers, or to
Bathing in
Polluted Waters
Watere eommoniy ebathing
in. the vicinity of lerle cities ore fre-
qUently so polluted that they consta
tut a danger to health. This is cer-
tainly the case in Nev York, accord -
leg to Dr. Louis 1, garris, health corn'
missiouer of that city, who, in an in-
terview printed in the New York
American, declares that some of Rs
encircling hays are so polluted that
they present a genuine menace.* 1s
adds that it would not be far-fetched
to say that death lurks in every
moutb.ful of their waters swallowed by
bathers, We read:
• "In a conference recently -between
Dr. Harris and Dr, Charles F. Pabst, it
was developed that in addition to the
many internal diseases which the
filthy waters carried, there were many
serious and painful skin diseases
against which the public should be
warned. Ds. Pabst, an authority on
this phase of the menace, is a city
physician and chief attending derma-
tologist of the Greenpoint Hospital.
"Following their talk it was said
that physicians and surgeons would
not be astonished to see an epidemic
of furuncles or boils, etbsceistes, and
other inflammatory diseases of the
skin and blood stream. It was said
that these are quite likely to be con-
tracted by bathers in the condemned
waters, where the subject has slight
cuts or abrasions.
"These abrasions, it was shown,
need not be pronounced, but might
merely be the result of chafing by a
woollen bathing suit in order to give
the bacilli a point of entry.
"Eye specialists have pointed out,
too, that these waters present the
constant peril of pink -eye and all
forms of conjunctivitus, some of
which could conceivably result in per-
manent injury to the eye, or even total
blindness.
"Perhaps the most prevalent after-
math of bathing M water containing
sewage, it was said at the Health
epattment, is that of middle -ear infec-
tion, often leading to mastoditis, alb-
scesses, ear -drum infections, and often
deafness, especially where the eusta-
chian tubes become involved.
"Respiratory diseases also play their
part in the lives of bathers who ignore
the Health Department warnings. At
the department it was said that 'colds,'
which bathers imagin they contract
from staying around too long in swira-
ming suits, really are contracted from
the organisms in the filthy waters.
"Many cases of pneumonia have
been traced directly to this source, as
have cases of tonsilitise bronchitis,
pharingitis, and all of the common
and throat ills.
"Swallowing these waters, it was
declared, might easily lead to disturb-
ances of the di; Itional tract, not
from the water itself, but from the'
dangerous bacilli they contain and
might easily be a predisposing factor
of appendicitis."
Commercial Street
Along the curving brightness of the
bay,
The hurried little street runs like
a song;
Way -up -along, around, and down -
It takeaslointge'lliting, winding vivid way
Between small shops and smaller
houses, gay
With zinnias, petunias, hollyhocks,
Hooked rugs, ships' models, figure-
' heads, old clocks
And modernistic paintings of to -day.
townsfolk, fish -
Bonny were all coming in to dance. could hike, and I have had a lot of
fellows like him, who couldn't go as
they used to but who went as far as
they could, liked it and never kicked."
Then, when he did arrive, she'd call
out as he came in: "Do hurry, Ben,
and changel—Billie's sleeping in your
dressing -room .so change iu the bed-
room, and oh! Ben, mind you put on
the socks I've put you out, and Ben!
do take off your muddy shoes down
sfairs. . . ."
Maddening!
Well, you can imagine how mad-
dening that sort of thing gets when
it's practised in public and private,
Two attorneys, one decidedly glum
of countenance, met on the street,
"Well, how's business?" the first ask-
ed of the diurnal one. "Rotten," the
pessimist replied. "I just chased an
ambulance 12 miles and found a law-
yer in
We may concede any man a right
without doing any man a wrong; but
we can favor no one without injuring
some one.—Colton,
Stratford -on -Avon Festival Conwani
Round-theMorki
Radio Goes Flying
As .Knowledge Crows Radio
Waves ,I3ecome More
Confusing—Signals
ieep_Moving
Where Stoppih Point?
Not once, but two and one-half times
do modern short radio waves circle
the globe, according to a study made
by Dr, A. Hoyt Taylor, superintendent
of the Bellevue Naval Research Lab-
oratory. An informative interview
with Dr. Taylor is reported in the
radio section of the New York Sun by
S. R. Winters. The strength of high
frequency signals, says Dr. Winters,
is suggested by their ability to encom.
pass the earth thus, with a 'kick' sun
ficient to be a disturbing factor in re-
ception, At the Bellevue Laboratory
the phenomenon of "echo" signals is
the subject of a special investigation.
We read:
"Signals that race around the world
in reverse direction from the trans-
raitting station to the receiving set, or
encircle the globe more than once,
threaten to become a disruptive in-
fluence short-wave traffic. Mess-
ages are garbled, and the only remedy
thus far suggested is the use of direc-
tional receiving antennae.
"Dr, A. Hoyt Taylor, Superintendent
of Radio at the Bellevue Laboratory,
compares the effect of 'echo' signals,
to the results of two operators sending
the same message, one being slightly
lagged in keying. Echo signals are
pronounced in the 20,000 -kilocycle
band, but this disturbing factor has
been observed on various frequencies
between 8,700 and 28,000 kilocycles.
Dr. Taylor considers the possible dis-
astrous effect of echo signals of such
significance as to invite nation-wide
study. He diagnoses the condition,
and tells of the results in the follow-
ing interview:
"'It is amazing that these echo sig-
nals, which have been photographical.
ly recorded after having passed ap
proximately two and one-half times
around the world, are of sufficient in-
tensity to cause very serious interfer-
ences.
"'Echo signals once around the
world have been. observed on various
frequencies, but are usually restricted
on the lower frequencies to a very
limited time of day and time of year.
In the band between 12,000 and 22,000
they may be observed over a large
number of hours of the day and over a
wider interval in. the year. The pre-
dominant period for observation of
echo signals is in the spring or fall,
and the best periods of the day are in
the morning or late afternoon. hours.
They require that the great circle
route over which they travel shall be
more or less in a daylight or twilight
zone. Signals -which go more than
once around the world are still very
frequently of at least one-third to one-
half the intensity of the direct signal,
but are commonly obesrved over less -
ed time periods, and are restricted
morehto the bands around 20,000 kilo-
cycles.'Nt'hen the signal goes more than
once around the world it is generally
observed as coming from the same di-
rection as the direct signal. The time
differences do not correspond to a
ground wave, but they correspond to
the circumference of the Heaviside
layer, which is somewhat larger than
the circumference of the earth. When
more than one echo is observed the
time difference between the first and
second echo Iss appareutly almost al-
ways 0.137 second.
" `No method other than estimates
by ear have been used so far by this
laboratory for the accurate timing of
these signals, but the time intervals
are such as to throw the dots and
dashes of a message into complete
jumble.
"'It has recently been determined
during a period when any copy at all
received on a vertical antenna, was ab-
solutely impossible, that perfect copy
without echo could be obtained on a
directional long, low signal wire an-
tenna. In other words, the highly di-
rectional antenna pointed toward the
transmitter is not bothered by echoes
of the first type, which have gone
around the world in the reverse direc.
tion. It is only bothered by echoes of
the second type, which have gone
around the world once plus the dis-
tance from the transmitter to receiver
in the same sense as the direct signal.
Since these later type of echoes natun
ally require rather special conditions
in order not to strike a region where
the Heaviside layer is too high for
these frequencies, they are not any.
where near as bothersome in Inter.Tupting reception, and may, for the
present, at least, bp neglected, except
in so far as they refer to the operation
of beam stations, where it is under-
stood they still constitute a somewhat'
serious menace, owing to the very
great signal strength of these eta.
tions.'"
Painted Ceilings
A new idea whicb; may or may not
be a success is that or having your
tentage painted or distempered the
seine color as .your walla. . With
crean1 colored, yellow, or ivory walls effect is certalar charming
though with some colors it is apt not
only to be oppressive, but to give the
room a smaller, boxlike appearance.
"Now Hiratn the now waitressft
Members of the Stratford -on -Avon Feetleal Company photographed on board the Whtie Star liner Lamellae '
a tollege girl.' "What of it, lime?'
Cres,zn 1 cupful of :Sugar With CUp Witt Wig Sao -Xe Th coin will mak a tour of the rinelpal theatres In Canada
So u0Ti t kael) ileT tr) parsf
on which they arrived in Montreal recentlY, pa, e P
Devil's Food Oaks gardrtimatOte a relationship of super-
rul of shortettingi add the ygike ot last,
and the United States, I the butter, This ain't school."