Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Clinton News Record, 1927-06-30, Page 4Can Musical Appreciation be Taught? REIMS RESTORED piovislon.liahis these -hero an'd there A CollegiateT� Authority DCis to?vialor teachers and •.to;egtitl them amoizs kgrene,t Cathedral CL19st:9 the Present State: of 'with eotnetlttng more than a know- Raises "Again 'from its' Stildie.s in Tnder ous' 9',,rnL 1edgeof hew t o certain books and7recitirg. ing and HistOry 'couimprcially produced materials, , y Books and mechanical recordings will ROCKEFELLER HELPS not mitigate the lack' or tnuslcianship - , By Roy Dickinson Welch, in teachers. Thousands of 'Canadian treope stool Togetherwith tits growth�of studies aghacL at the destruction caused by Musicians who give the matter •a thought regard the steady growth of caries appreciation (t[nfoi•tunatr, carman iI:L, 'spoils, to, Ptench such studios as are called the Ap word, with its sentimental connote 1ceurehes and cathedrals, Ypres, Arras, predasuchtion of, Music with mixed feel- tion of bland praise and pretty corn- Amiens,• were ,all familiar to ,the lugs: The advocates seem more act- plimont) there has developed .a study GS.1 , RR.nts to a few, enly, . except; of 1 'History of MU,iic, Fiero we are dent' than judicious :the critics more on solid ground. Wo lurow what IS prejudiced than, constructive. meant by history. It Is like "Ap- An impressive literature bias a1- predation" a blank -check word, to be ready grown' up around this subject filled out by the' neer as his intense - with more .to follow. We have de- tiler c19dit permits. "History" 1a bated long and the argument is .still • sped so specific indeed that one Par from areae'. is surprised to discover liow often. it The sanest of the champions say, is misconstrued. Tho "History of in effect, ' We are Lrying to do some- Music is,' as Horatio Parker put it, thing that needs to l e done. We ase written in notes, not in words." It is riot bent upon reaching the musically a enbject to be studied from scores sifted student. We are. not teaching and 'performances and only incident - the technic of inusioal performance nor are 'We training composers. Wo'ialY from 001- ,this biographies and essays. By $ave in mind such students as ,poi• its nature, this is a subject for spa sees the equipment .specified by Mr; oialleta, and when it is given to un- leadow, 'Ear enough to perceive one trained .students ands when it deals tune from another and wit enough to' with tabloid biography and categori- preter ,order to incoherence:' These` cal second-hand opinions, it isn't the students may acquire the -useful ca- history of Music; Such courses Wast pacity to distinguleh,Bach from Verdi be an offence against musical°echolat- and a fugue from a hole in the wall," shNow scholarship to tris arta may Thin le modest enough, and 'would seem to many sincere persons a seem 'both possible and worth doing, weariness• of the flesh, but is not But, the critics view the whole under• honestly to be faked. If we'assume taking .with grave suspicion. to teach the Hlatory of Music we are t'Musir.; ' they contend, Js an ex.in some measure, and inevitably, con- ,erionce which eaaontially- cannot be milted to the scholar's point of view. taught, Information „bout music We moat SWAY' the documents first; may appear `impressive, but the all other relevant material then Palle chances are.heavily against the stu- into its proper place. •l0' we do' not dent's being ,able to make any nae of wish to- do this, let us not call the sub- ject ject the "History of 14lusic" "You are superficial," say the critics Progress in nruslcal scholarship to, the teachers of this subject, "You makes haste fiery slowly, and 1f we deal iz, talk about oasis and 111 ver- have but little -of it in this country we bal interpretations, and you do your have at least come to' know An the beat to' keep students from under- last few years what it is. Professor standing what Tagore meant by his Pratt's -books, The, Musical Quarter - maxim, Appreciation is not eaeily nor ly, a growing taste for such concerts Quarter - cheaply acquired but must be slowly as those which are- provided by The sought and wona" English Singers are giving us a sense One cauatically-minded opponent of of what is to be learned -and how. these studies pleads through the length ot many satirical pages to,.be - Students Like to Think. delivered -from the "appreciationist Ona last word, and a, purely per. and .declares that a student would know more . about the. tugue from learning to play any one of the Bach fugues than from hearing and analyz- ing and discussing -many of them. Value In the Controversy. Thia controversy, and the heat is it an llluaton—that our students do whale it engeuders, is the most satle- like to think. We have given them so factory development that the teach much to learn, - and made them so ing` of Appreciation has brought'to anxious lest they should fail, to re- light to light i ma last severe.' decades. For the moment we are not concerned 'with who 15 right - and who is wrong. In this matter, as in many others, the wish 10 often father to the thought. `00 may be that we shall have to work another fifty` yeara before we shall agree either to dump the apprecia- tionist and all hfa works overboard, or so to instruct and cultivate him that he shall becqme ;a harmless mem- ber of incisal society. But the con. trovers' ,itself is all pure gain. It is being argued with the determination of earnest men. We are aware oY a challenge, and we are. prepared not to funk it. • American School and college life bas, in these last fifty yearn, steadily matte a place for some kind of musi- cal instruction, We see this opening as. a chance too good to be squander' ed. The day of pioneering for mu- sic's place in the academic sun is past, The important issue now is: 'what shall we db with that place? Able men and women are convinced that school children; and college stn-' dente can learn of the existence of great mesio as they learn of great literature. They know, these men and women, that literature is Often hopelessly ruined. by the ill-advised offorta of teachers. They can hardly hope that. music will alwaya escape the same deplorable, fate. But what- ever 111 -Judged and superficial meth- ods may flourish here and there, they are being exposed' to a pitiless crit1- Giem aimed to' supplant ignorance 'with training and incompetence with, ability. through picture and •tory. In a recant "Literary Digest" the rebuild ing'et' Reims Is described' ands to they telling, thoughts -return- toother magnificent edifies and we wonder ".why war." On Ascension Day, May 26, the Arch- bishop -Cardinal Imeon rch-bishop-Cardinal_Lucou celebrated high. mass in the nave of the Cattle-6rd of Reims forthe tirst time since the war. Tee'•leat time such a ceremony took place was September 19, 1914, when Monsignor Landrieuy, then Vicar -Gear eral'of the Cathedral, said mass before one single worshiper. Bombardment of the town was'inprogress, and shells bursting overhead Interrupted his read- ing of the liturgy. That night the woodwork of the Cathedral took fire and the whole edifice was gutted. Since that Clue the building has been in disuse, save for one chapel and part of the ambulatory on the north side of the choir, walled off from the rest. Now eight years of patient work in re- storation of the interior are crowned by the ceteniony noted. A new altar stands in the Mast Pay of the nave, backed by a temporary wale which separates it from the trausepte, and a ditinnutive choir is formed by thefew choir-etalla which escaped destruction. What le done has come in part from the bene'ftcienoe of outsiders. Mr. John D. Rockefeller, Jr„ grave 6,000,000 trance, only one-third of which has yet been spent. Denmark's gift autount9 to 1,200,000 francs, Norway's to 200,000 francs, white double ;the latter amount has been guaranteed by Great Britain. The French Government has advanced' about 1,000,000 francs a year, so that so tar,. 11,000,0.00 thanes have been ex- pended -on the restoration, In a de- tailed article in the London Threes one sees what the war did to thin glorious - Isonal elle for which l ought. to feel heritage of the Middle Ages; one, how- ever, only of the ruined Canes in that had reached a stage at which the on the outside had been comjlletely materiel, and fastened with oak pegs. some embarrassment- Some of us much suffering fact.g country. Old days fabric wee stencetth to disintegrate. on the With these means rte,; has produced. a have discovered an 'tmnalno. inloti whose memories are perhaps fading At a lJttte distance ilia building retain It was two years before the firs. structure which is hght, strong, proof about the American school and col- - Contrary e ilia cctiven to 1 P are here recalled: ed all its old grandeur and appeared 'stage of restoration could be begun. both, to fire and changes of temps a student we have discovered-ar MuaM�4ccom lisped tc' Ue intact, but its actual state was• A tsmporaiy •roof of corrugated • iron lure, and which has the advantage that lege p desperate, Pillars and buttresses had was spread, some cracks filled with any part of it canbereplaced at any "To any 009 who has not 'men the begun 'to crumble under the pounding1 cement, loosened blocks secured with tithe without touching the rest, It has Cathedral in its ruined atate the 're- which they had received; walls were: Iron hitches, and arches supported the simplicity oY a boy's. set of 'Nies conditioning oaf the nave may not beginning to sag. Arehee had had their with brlcitworlt. When work really cane,' and its clean, exact lines when seem, at the first thought; a great deal thrust distorted so that they no longer commenced— seen from the inside of the roof are Peat our bent stoat phrases back to show. for eight years' work, Whin `gave to the wet It which they; a joy to the eye. The same system us, that they have had no time and out having visited the building in de- were built to bear. The vaulting of "The whole of the floor had to be is being used for the churches of St, no courage to think, The application tail and traced the course of the de - or roof was broken through in eight'" repave'. IOach• pillar and arch had to Remi and St,Jacquea at Reims, and it of titin discovery—if it is 0119-15 aim• ytruetlon to which It was exposed for ar nine different places, three of rte bo separately doctored before the roof seems singularly wall adapted for the pre.. Leave the student alone with ex- four- years it is difficult to realize to."keystones had been smashed to bats:. could he touched. Under the constant purpnse `Viten once the slabs are music; it needs no explanatlolo no µhat extent rte masonry Suss shatter -yin the center of ilio church the Iran-thannnering of the bombardment the cast in quantity; construction Is ex- missionary persuasion,, no' ap g!a ed and dislocated, or to estimate at 'sept crossing looked as if a giant, Mites • arches had sagged away, Prom the ceedingly rapid and economical, The Those who like music do pot do so its proper worth the work which has Sanson at Gaza, had tried to pull down 1 vaulting, leaving in some instances a roof of the cave has taken only thir- luto its they areepeager es or cajns the .den aoeomplished. In September, th epillars on top of hint.- One of the gap or foul- or five. ruches. In these loan months to build. into it. Our very eagerness rune the 1014 after the dist bombardment and four master pillars had been itit by a eases each stone had to be separately danger of defeating its own end. Ain the fire which CollOwed it, people evoke heaviest caliber, and its A Sad tore. Y i e re E th ] t d Th REIMS CATHEDRAL Appreciation An '�Educaffonal industry, That la the case as it stands to -day. $tatistica and questionnaires, : which are: daily; multiplied without number, only prove what most of, us already know. They make the cse no better •and no worse than we feel it to be. Schools and colleges are everywhere taking 'up this, as yet ill-defined, sub - jest, and taking lt, up for reasons that. many. musician consider question- able. Nev books on the subject ap-, pear every year. Phonograph records, and reproductions for mechanical pianos add rapidly to;the material available for teaching. Indeed, these several aids to'teachers.and students of the subject are obviously becoming one of the chief educational indtts- tries. All, this is interesting and a de- velopment that cannot be ignored'as oue,-reviews the changes in musical education in the last fifty years. But ea- what is even more striking is the shell of the J put hack into place; until the correct that the 'siuceteSt advocates o calve p e arch .vas restored. on "The most grievous and most irre- aireadyof the Cathedral as ruined. The drains so shattered that th y ba ly predation hope for, all. that its sever• damage slue waa indeed immense. Mulct together, .A great gash in the tmnrense'stru0turea of scaffolding had !parable loss is that of the precious est oritics �, as might prove often roof had brought down tons upon tons to he erected to enable the masons to Istaineci glass which formerly listed the The fire started with the scaffoling, deal with the vaulting of the roof, ' which at that date still surrounded of masonry, Completely burying the _which was open to the illy in several' stain rose window above the .vest door, the Whole of• the northwest angle of higli altar. Severe' great shell graters the windows- ot the clearstory, and tate building, testifying to the work of yawned 1n the floor of the nave. Lit- •places' those of the apse. Much 0t its perish patient- restoration whiclt had been Ole was left of trill• magnificent tltir- Clever Work. ed in the fire; the rest was mostly carried out duritg. the previous forty teenth-century stained glass which bad I "The restoration of the outer roof brought down - by the bombardment, years, all in vain, as it proved, The filled tate windows of the 'clearstory : was a problem In itself, which bas been and could only be collected.in tiny flames were ted by the masses of straw 'and the apse, and rant and frost were ' solved by the ingenuity of the archi- fragments from the floor of the which had been laid in the nave as a fast -completing the ruin, test, M. Banana. The roll which had Cathedral. The pleetng of it together bed for 200 German wounded who had been destroyed in the conflagration of has bean the work of M, Jacques f been collected there, by the Chairs cud' ,"Outsit�e tee Catiterrad notch of the , September, 1914, was made of oak Siruon, whose family has had the care stonewoelt of the towers hung totter- ;`beams and covered with lead. At the or the stained glass of the Cathedral ise oak beams , ]est but not least, by ing and ready to fall, The facade was ` end of the war 11. Dinette made in. tor 200 years. He has succeeded after the oak beams of the .roof, For htwo long and patient work in reconstitut days the great church beaked, white gashed and splititereu. Of the thirty gUlries as to the possibility of replao- the melted lead from the root poured flee great statues •or the main porch ing it. Ile was told that It would take' nig, Partly with the original glass Jaid down in streams from the mouths of Ave. Including the Qtleenn or Sheba and at least five years to collect the neces- Partly ivith facsimiles, the rose win - the gargayles. When the fire died one or @he famouB smiling angels, were sail' timber;; the cost would have been sow and eight at those In the, clear- dovvu the outer roof was gone, leaving decapitated and most 'of them were prohibitive. An aiteftiat[ve which story- I,lnough of the original glass the senile vaulting bare to the sky, the sadly mitttlated. The smaller groups presented itself was to use Cast iron, remains to ilii. three of those,3n the beltr3 P the north tower with its eight and statuettes had fared likewise. as was done at the Ctithedral at apse when the time comes." i bells hadecrashed to the ground, the Havoc had been played with the light- Chartres, but in this case the roof When attention is turned to the out. thirteenth -center • stained glass of the er stonework of the eider or, +inch ee would hive had to be covered with cop- side of the church, the means are at conies quite 'naturally to Its finest flower when teachers can persuade themselves to stop talltieg' and , can cease to iurude 'bew,een music and the listener. WEAF Shows Lass. "The National Broadcasting Co, will show a deficit of $800,000 in first year's operation," said President Aylesworth at hearing before Federal Radio Com- mtSstOn. "The National Broadcasting Go. Is owned 60 per .cent, by Rario Corp, of America, ,30' per cent. by Gen- eral Electric Co. 'and '20 per cent, by Westing Electric Co. Mr. Aydesworth leas declared reads 'Barren's Weekly' that eventually tate company hopes to earn something 'and also plans to ex- tend its network :to Pacific Coast and Northwest. Ile estimated that on days clearstory and the great rose window the corbels and gargoyies and the per, and the lead available from the hand for the restoration of the muitf- that Colonel Lindbergh was'in Wash- over tate Wast door were pitifully sIiat moldings anti trareryof the windows. old roof would have been wasted. M. tude of sculptered,liguree that adorn ington a hookup arranged by the Na' -1 This was particularly the sena at the Merieux lilt upon a solution which was 1t, though 'a copy can never equal the stone - Lionel Brtadeas-ting Co, made It Ros wot-k,nd, and a great real of the stone east alis of the church, wistell had had more practical. simpler. - original. Plaster hear lime work, both Inside. and• out, including P p , and more (aeon gi 1, P to casts of- the most sills for 60,000,000 people toman of the ex Itis a r to bear the brunt of the sheitine, Con- apical than either timber or iron. .He famous figures, celebrated throughout This company pays Amerl,0n ?role y c rte avol-stone lig- stderable stretches of the garret'' hied^basil, of ie -cast ferroconcrete, the world as ewers of medieval art tires 'of ; the `facade, had cracked and S p ete,j phone Telegraph Co. fi1,600,00 yearly which toile round the root of the nave bola together by dowels of the same exist in the Art Museum of the Tto- Poi'. use oa eta land wires. Price paid Perished In -tee Beal of the lire. by Naticuai-Broadcastsnv Co. for sta. "It was a disaster fit to upper the Con WIOAF, New Yorlc,afortnerly own artistic sense.of the whole wood, but ed by American Telephone & Tele --it warn little competed with tvttat was. graphCo. was $i,o00;000.' to 'toimow. Untl; the very end of the war tate- Cathedralt•emained in the lire - _ zone, constantlyunder fire, and at thnss, as in eepril, 1917, exposed to a met- OJless b,,nibardment of guns OP heavy caliber deliberately directed at IL No fewer than 287 direct hits on the structure were counted, as tI many more must have escaped observation. -� The Cathedral conttiiusd to stand in spite or the rents . and gashes in its 'shell, 'a monument to the skill of the tlttt•teenth-century masons who built It, gut as the pitiless ltammeriag was She --"Surely - yet don't- think i'd, again and again renewed its stone - .Too Cheap. work began to loosen and break up. It " elo .bride for - me—they're too cheapt" • "How's that?" "Aren't they alwaya given away?" When zest departs labor becomes drudgery.—Owen D. Young, ramodneiemesoscejlermunssortraemensa REG'LAR FELLERS—' By. Gene Byrnes, YELL Os A. STORY LAIBBERMPUT949 00 00 could not much longer have withstood the • ordeal: • ,. Terribly Battered "By the titre the Germans withdraw and: Reimswasreleased-droit the ter- ror of bombardment the Cathedral BURIED 200b YEARS Pot pen excavations) ave now piaci/ AWRI&NTt tT, WAS: DOWN ON AFS ISLAND NEAR. THE 0QUATOR MY UNCLE; WAS AT WHEN IT BEGAN TO:SToRt.1' FIRST IT RAIN*O ROOT :60150. ''t'1aEN IT TH0ND5Ren ICt: CREAM CONES! THEN A NAILWTORM OF JELLYBEAlea AN' 8UMDROP8 FELLI' AN' VANILLA`PLAVSOSD SNOW FELL'ALL'OVER1SWEET at+ A5.s0vAR.1 •,e !lei 'GAJ �� 19\ BET NE E7 SD MUCH HE COULD I-IARDLY I BET -tit kILLED NigSGI.F EATleal sally comlrle,te. cadet() ht Parts; andi3ie Department of Fine Arts has in Its archlves a sertes of photogt•aplta of practically every retail In the sculpture of the Cathedral. . a " Dial' You? Anonymous% Did you even watch the camp fire When the wood has fallen low; And the ashes start to whiten . e Round the %tellers,' crimson glow; With the Tright north's all around you Malting silence doubly sweet; Anda ful•1 moon high above you hat the ttPell may ire complete? Toll tate, were you ever nearer To the lend ce heart's desire; Then whou you sat there 'thinking With your: race turned toward the' fire? CLINTON. E S - C EC R CLINTON, ONTARIO Terms of Suhs8i'Iption—b2-00 per year 'in advance, to Canadian addresses; $2,60 to the U:S:- pr other foreign countries. No ,taper discontinued Until all arrl•are are paid nut i. at the option of the publisher. Tho date to Whicb every euhscript1On 10 paid is denoted on the label. . Advarttsing. Cares=Transient adver• tions, 12c l,er count tine- for first insertion, 8e Por each eitbsequent Insertion, •Beading counts 2 cines, Small advertisements, not to exceed. one inch, yueh as "Wanted." "Loat," "Strayed," ofo„ Inserted once Fier 36c, each 'suhseguent insertion •1$c:: Advertisements sent !n without ani 1; etructlons • as to the "masher of ip.. sertions.wasted will run unt11 ordeib ed out and will be charged accord ingly,-. Rater for display advertising made known 01 'appskation: c Communications incudes for publE- cation must as o guarantee of good faith, ba accompanied by the name of the writer. G, E. HALL, M; R, CLAIIR,. Proprietor. Editor. G. D. 7vIcTAeGART-' M. D. MoTAGGART &TCC T EROS. BANKERS A general Banking Business transact- ed. Notes Discounted. Drafts Irene', tntereat Allowed on • Deposits. Sale Notes Purchased. H, T. RA NCE Notary Pobiio, Conveyancer, Financial, Real Estate and Fire In- eurance Agent, Representing 14 mire insurance Compnnlea. Dlvfslen Court Office. Clinton, A Wild Tale From the—Equator. aiee. 1 HE JOS'.LAFFED AN :NUN' EAT AMY -n-1040 ON. ecO^ogh�Nop'5� OR. HES A W. BRYT!ONE Barrister, Solicitor, Notary Public, eto. Officer SLOAN • BLOCK - CLINTON DR,. J. C. GA NDIER Office Hours: -1.30 to 3;30 m. 30 to 8,00 pm., Sundays, 12 30 to 1 .10 p,m, Other hours by appoto•ment 1uly, Office and Reside,,:. — Victoria St. DR. FRED G. TriOMPSON Office and Resicence; Ontario Street • Clinton, Out. One door west of Anglican Church, Phone 172 Eyes examined and glasses fitted. DR. PERCIVAL HEARN OJtice and Residence: Huron Street Clinton, Ont. Phone 69 (Formerly occupied • by the late Dr. 0. W. Thompson). Eyes Examined and Gleams Fitted, D. H. MCINNES' Chiropractor—Electrical Treatment, Uf ee Ingham, will be at the Commer- cial Inn, Clinton, on Monday, Wednes- day and Friday Corenoone of each week. Diseases of all kites/euccesafully handled, GEORGE ELUOTT Licensed Auctioneer for the t.oun;y of Huron. Correspondence prompt!` anewrrt.1. Immediate arrangements can be made for Sales Date at The News -Record, Clinton, or by calling Phone 203. Charges Moderato anti Satlatactlon Guaranteed. OSCAR KLOPP " Honor Graduate Carey Jones' National School of Auctloneering. Chicago, ape - tial course taken in lure Bred Live Stock, Real Estate, Merchandise and Farm Sales. Rates In keeptug with prevailing market. Satisfaction as- sured. Write or wire, Zurich, Ont. Phone 18.93 B. R. HIG INS Clinton, Ont. General Fire and Life tn,urance,'Agent for I-iartfdrd Windstorm, Live Stock, Automobile and Sickness and Accident insurance Huron and Erie and Cana- da Trust Bonds, Apectni.nents made to meet parties at la ecellald. Varna and Bayfield. 'Phone 117 TIME TABLE Trains will a:rive at and depart tram Clinton as follows: Buffalo and Godertch Div. Going East, depart 6.25 am, 2.62• pen. Going West, ar. 11,10 ala, It ar. 6.08- dp. 6.63 p.m, " ar. 10.04 pm London, Huron & Bruce Div, Going South. ar: 7,66 dp, 7.56 a,.m, " " 4.10• Going North, depart 6.60 pm. " ' - 11,05 11,16 am. The McKillop [ qua! Eire Insurance Company Head OfOce, Se'forth, Ont. 17IRECTOt•,Y: President, 'James Connolly; Coderlch; Vice, James Evans, Beechwood; Soon Treasurer, Thos. F3, Hays, Seat•orth. Directors: George IV1cCartney, sea„ forth; D. F. MoGregor, Sesforth; J. G. Grieve, Walton; Wnl. Ring, Seatorth; lv1, McEwen, Clinton; Robert Perrins, `ilartock; John Benirewetr, Brodbagen; Jas. Couuolly, Godertch. Agents: Ales Leitch, Clinton J. W. Teo, Goderich; Pd, tiineltray, Sea - forth; W. Chesney, te'gmondvills; IL' G, ,Isrmuth, 13r'odhagen. Any .money to be paid In may be paid to Mnorieh Clothing Co., Clinton, or at Cult's Grocery, Goderich; Parties desiring to afeet Ineurauce or transact other businese wilt be promptly attended to on applioation to any of the above o8'fears addreseed to their .respective' post office. Lessee Inspected by the Director who lives nearest the scene. For , ladles, WO understand, bine will again be the 'favorite color. As the old sergeant used to say on'par- ade, "Azure wear!" A Chinese 1'ozzle--Hca Chen tea off morn than be can Chew? 1