The Goderich Signal-Star, 1977-11-17, Page 1Lowest of five
members of the Goderich senior
Football team were escorted around
owing their 18-0 victory over the Exeter
Panthers to win the Huron -Perth senior football
championship. The win capped a perfect season
for the Vikings who won nine straight games ,
oderich
while giving up only seven points to the op-
position. Story and pictures on page 8. (staff
photo)
SIGNAL -STAR
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 1977
30 CENTS PER COPY
k first NIP fun
ion for the funds to support the second
the Neighborhood Improvement
NIP) will be made by town council on
the municipality. A copy of the ap-
or approval and contributions will be
to the Ministry of Housing including a
legal description of the NIP area in
st corner of Goderich. _
uest is for $32,000 from the federal
t representing 50 percent of the total
cost of carrying out the second stage
am and $16,000 or 25 percent from the
government. The remaining $16,000
om municipal coffers:
ey includes $49,280 for planning' and
tion of the work to be undertaken in
ated area and $14,720 for resident
n, an important aspect of the
o of the NIP program is expected to
five months. The final submission of a
atement of neighborhood planning
to be completed by May 14, 1978. The
is implementation and it is at this
he municipality will have to decide
to what extent it will become com-
Dave Barber, a representative of Municipal
Planning Consultants, told council that in the
event decision was reached not to implement the
program developed in the second stage of NIP,
the funds from federal and provincial sources
already received by the town would not have to
be returned.
Barber also said that if the full $64,000 was not
used up during the second stage, it was his un-
derstanding the remainder of the money could be
applied to the third stage, implementation.
According to the Community Renewal Branch
of the Ministry of Housing, Barber added, the
town would not have to make the first stage
application which is the selection of the neigh-
borhood. However, Deputy Clerk Larry
MacCabe said he'd forwarded the necessary first
stage forms to the Ministry of Housing.
"There's certainly no harm in that," agreed
Barber.
Although Barber also presented a flow chart
for the work program to be undertaken during
stage two, town council made it clear that
Barber's firm, Municipal Planning Consultants
had not yet been retained by the municipality to
do the planning portion of the work.
Barber estimated his company would charge
between -$10,000 and $15,000,for• its services to
Goderich during stage two. I -1e said he could not
be more specific about the price since it would
not be known until the work was actually begun
just what would be necessary.
"But previous experiences have shown that it
will be between $10,000 and $15,000," said Bar-
ber.
Later in the meeting, council learned that
Sally Hannon of the Ministry of Housing will be
in Goderich today(Thursday) to discuss the NIP
project with members of town council. Coun-
cillors also agreed to meet with Jean Monteith of
Jean Monteith and Associates Limited (plan-
ners) regarding the cost of her firm's services
during stage two of the NIP project.
The NIP area, according to the submission to
be made to the Ministry, contains 416 homes on
135 acres and 1,460 people. The average income
in the area is $6,400 per annum. It shows that
while water hydro and gas services are
adequate, sewage, street lighting, roads and
boulevards are inadequate.
niors' housing more possible
town promises financial aid
recorded vote - 5 to 4 - Goderich town
agreed to co-operate with Goderich
d Colborne Township to raise $25,000
pita basis to subsidize the cost of a
d at the corner of West Street and
reet to facilitate the construction of
izens' housing complex.
was born in the Housing Action
where representatives from
oderich Township and Colborne
ve been working for two years
establishment of a senior citizen
ilding in the core area of Goderich.
r such a facility had been clearly
ed long ago and has been
dbythe Ontario government.
sistent problem has been land
said Roman Dzus, chairman of the
on Committee who appeared before
'ay evening. He said a core area
oderich was favored by the senior
the committee. Limited land
lus the high cost of real estate
e committee's efforts to acquire
ble for the project.
referred by the committee is the
P property and some adjoining
>st of the land is $205,000, in excess
of Housing "bench marks It has
that the tri -municipal councils
and the cost of buying the land,
ng the actual dollar cost to the
more acceptable $180,000. While
Grantee that the Ministry will
rid purchase even in the lesser
nistry has pledged its support to
oderich and area senior citizens'
Dzus said the project has
ith the Ministry of Housing.
the fixed financial contribution
the three municipal councils,
uncal has agreed to waive the
impost fees which would have been applicable to
the project, and to approve the necessary
rezoning to permit the construction of a four -
storey 70 -unit complex.
70 UNITS
Dzus said the provision of specifically 70 units
is consistent with the known'demands for senior
citizen housing in Goderich and area. As well,
Dzus pointed out, more units had to be provided
in the complex to offset the higher land
acquisition costs. He said the design of the
building would still be compatible with the area.
The four -storey design, Dzus continued, could
he approved without further surveys and studies.
It would prevent further unnecessary delays, he
stated.
Dzus told council the Ministry would assume
the costs for the demolition of the present
buildings on the land, and would pay the total
cost of construction for the new facility. Once the
senior citizens' complex is built, the tri -
municipal councils wil assume their share of any
losses incurred up to 71/2 per cent.
Councillor Dave Gower spoke in opposition to
waiving the impost charges. He felt the financial
loss to the town of Goderich would be high,
especially when it was considered that Goderich
would also provide other services for the facility
- policing, fire protection, recreation facilities
etc.
"We're subsidizing the total project," argued
Gower.
TAXES
"We'll be collecting the taxes for 50 years,"
Councillor Bob Allen observed in rebuttal. "1
can't believe the wrangling we're going through
for minimal amounts of money."
Allen said it was time the community provided
adequate and accessible housing for settlor
citizens. He asked council to remember that the
senior citizens themselves had requested a
location in the core area.
"A project like this will revitalize the core
area," Allen added.
Deputy -reeve .Eileen Palmer also advised that
the senior citizens' complex will likely come
under the county housing scheme soon.
"Then the rural municipalities will subsidize
this to 71/2 -per cent as the urban municipalities
do," said Palmer.
Councillor Elsa Haydon asked if the motion
before council was lost, would the entire project
be lost. She said she was in favor of senior
citizens' housing in the core area and would
support whatever action was absolutely
necessary to see it accomplished. But she too,
was reluctant to waive the impost fees and
suggested that perhaps these fees could also be
shared by the three municipalities on a per
capita basis.
Haydon was told that on a per capita basis,
Goderich would be paying too much toward the
impost fees and that such a proposal would he
more costly than waiving the costs. Haydon
asked to see figures as proof, but none were
produced and her suggestion was disregarded.
Councillor Don Wheeler said council had set a
precedent when it agreed to waive the impost
�$ 'Turn to page 20 •
Index
Rockhounding Page 1A
Township crest Page 3
PUC Page 2
Sports Pages 8-11
Classified Pages 15-19
ingna:
to collect gar
For the first time since 1969, the contract for
garbage collection in Goderich has been ten-
dered and a new contractor, Don Carter of
Wingham, has been hired as of the first of
January, 1978.
The new three-year contract calls for payment
15y the town of 77 cents per capita per month in
1978; 83 cents per capita per month in 1979; and
89 cents per capita per month in 1980.
The Carter bid was the lowest of five received
representing $68,237.40 in 1978; $73,559.60 in 1979;
anti„ $78,871.80 in 1980 for a total value in three
years of $220,663.80.
The highest bid was submitted by the current
contractors, C&W Sanitation of Goderich. Their
bid was for $1.07 per capita . per month or
$94,823.40 in 1978; $1.18 per capita per month or
$104,571.60 in 1979; and $1.30 per capita per
month or $115,206 in 1980. The total value in three
years to C & W Sanitation would be $314,601 or
$93,937.20 more than the accepted bid for the
same three-year period.
Other bids were received from McLellan
Disposals Services Limited of Mount Forest for
$225,006.18 over three years; C.A. Pergel and
Bob Lortie of Goderich for $243,582.84 over three
years and Wilson Enterprises for $263,201.40 over
three years.
Council also agreed that the population figures
for the town should be revised annually ac-
cording to the municipal census report at the
Huron -Perth Regional Assessment Office.
• WINTER
Councillor John Doherty asked if the out-of-
town .firm would have difficulty getting to
Goderich during the winter months. According to
Councillor Dave Gower, chairman of the works
and Engineering Committee which put together
the comprehensive report, getting to Goderich in
all kinds of weather will be the responsibility of
Carter.
"He's been made aware of the situation here,"
said Gower who also indicated that if the service
was found inadequate, the contract could be
hrDken.
Council was also advised that while Carter
intends to do the work in Goderich himself for a
while 'to get the feel of things here", there are
indications that once the service is operating
smoothly sanitation staff may be located in town.
This is not part of the contract, however.
Don Carter presently supplies sanitation
services for Wingham and Brussels, Gower told
council.
An added feature of the garbage service in
Goderich at the beginning of the year will he that
householders will be able to send anything ex-
cept building materials with the garbage pickup
each week. Furniture, appliances, garden refuse
etc. all will be removed anytime, Councillor
Gower said. The semi-annual garden refuse
pickup by the municipality will be discontinued.
The contract with C & W expired on July 31,
1977 but the firm has agreed to supply sanitation
Turn to page 20 •
Board, teachers
talk but don't listen
The Huron County secondary school teachers
and the county board of education agreed
recently to appoint a mediator to attempt to
settle the 1977-78 teacher -hoard collective
agreement.,, The county secondary school
teachers have been working without a contract
since September and negotiations for the new
pact have been fruitless.
A fact finder's report on the board -teacher
negotiations was released recently by the
Education Relations Commission of the province
and suggested that the main reason the parties
have not settled on an agreement was due to poor
communications. Professor J.W. Samuels of the
faculty of law of the University of Western
Ontario was appointed by the commission to
investigate the Huron negotiations. The com-
mission oversees all teacher -board agreements
in the province and usually demands a fact
finder report when negotiations bog down.
Samuels said in the report that he was con-
vinced that both parties are equally to blame for
the poor communications. He said it was the
"overall spirit" which was at fault, claiming the
board has not heard what the teachers are sure
they have said and the teachers have not heard
what the hoard is sure it has said.
"In my view each party is sincerely convinced
that it has explained its argument to the other
and that it is willing to negotiate in good faith if
only the other side would agree to do likewise,"
Samuels reported. He added that the
negotiations have been a "dialogue of the deaf".
Samuels recommended that both parties
should sit down with a third party chairman to
discuss their positions; For their part the
teachers asked that a mediator be appointed on
September 23 but claim that the board refused
the suggestion. The board didn't endorse the use
of a mediator until November 7. The fact finder's
report was submitted to both parties October 19.
STUMBLING BLOCK
The chairman of the teachers' negotiating
team, Ron Lane, said Tuesday that in the
teachers' opinion the fact finder will do nothing
to help negotiations and in fact might act as a
stumbling block. He said the report used con-
flicting arguments and ignored virtually all
teacher data regarding supportive material for
their proposals. Samuels also admits in the
report that he failed to check key figures, ac-
cording to Mr. Lane.
Lane said the teachers were disappointed with
the fact finder report but did agree with
Samuels' suggestion that a mediator be ap-
pointed. He said the actions of the school hoard
during negotiations make it difficult for teachers
to "resist the conclusion that they are a target of
a campaign designed to tear up their previous
Contract and to substitute in its place one that
includes not one single request of the Huron
teachers."
Herb Turkheim, who is chairman of the hoard
Turn to page 20 •
Silver cross mother Mrs. Lillian Summers
receives some assistance from Legion members
Bob Chapman and Roy Mugford in laying the
first wreath at the Remembrance Day services
held at the cenotaph. (staff photo)