Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Exeter Times, 1878-9-12, Page 1Vol VI, • TIT -;yim } er IISDAY,Stun' '.,+1Il3ER 1'.x,188., when' tante' that tt•arri t the (."t ti,u ss 'e E3 PAYS THE DUTY I House i¢, the Sten, ee, .I lviil be obliged ONTARIO, TI . UISD X, S 'PT :iti BR 12, 178. No won't do, That ho •se is worth $40 In t 3 �` ' morethan the nitarealld if the tiara is ��.•++ i� Yr,t'+�, "I IMO 06. that. your horse hs worth mere :hy 140, but ate you aware that worth $200 the Imre is worth $2411. OF TRADE. C. Cameron, Esq., Q.0.," as he d Wilts to style himself, has fallen, uuv:itciu ly, of centre, hitt the frame error that all older free Trade orators with siugula.r autl remarkable ttnsaui ;idly hive fallen iuto, uam)mtely, that, the to testier, and not the producer, pays the ditty. Now this is a queritisn of l e1E; utinast ire port lame to the people— .. t;kta ferment especiaIiy mn)crttt . ;1T--lt'r'. c'Ts T1fl:.Ill POCIiETS. email it is their ithteer4 t to l c it ee L4r ON IT 1L t��1ii'.l'S, tvitlk#nmt fur . 1 rile noel:eat allowing Dulitieal bits tan 1•,1 warp their uainde. :Anyone if he is re- als; ;treea:rtnl to li,ten unprejudiced to tuts a leetion, wire tterta•.l C.:ailt.•ron at ;sir. l'AL1t IL"tl 1t.al on 'L.'hmlrssL y after- team fter team beet calmed Velli throning, ! * Mea• ;r':t rr arifel er, ,.ret it or ra'.t, that the i rse- :1ratio Cludid att} rias Itittmtieif l aapelee:1,y etted.lit• 1 over it. If he t rmcceradttel in tua,°teing, it was in coarupletely' oh'cur. ` stmt; the toted of these present to: to I the ceneht fans of hie own argnuient. e 1l wt ver, COMMON SYNSE applied , t. to pay $4.0 duty on tlt , horse, , tv Eh1le I can take 1111 limns in duty free. 1 a;.L➢t't give yen amort) thee 6'I60 for yo'1r horse, ;title n;tl] Le is tier better ;rice mlttal. Bili I'it t..0 yrrl .that I'll a:,. I you pad half the slaty. I li give yott th s eeie aieuDalmut f. r hole," Theft tto:d,t have auV'ltrattetl ta) tl) ettme thong t„t the fvrurer. Ile wummlt have been merely teatime Ont. of tate p+)';lit t :tiutl puttee's ht 11tH ft! mt+'r, So hc' lt+eliurel to :lieve tiny hilts; to de Mill the dety, esti feel tit tee.' the: at➢1m:)nnt 01r0:ed, time luti:ne deer 16v the 01lr PIi.4r.'l/CA it 1'.1 1)l1r�l'Is/'Ti0A'. ITS BENEFITS TO THEM, t The atervatiotmiet (:'atndiaates glint• e tell tho people of Caanatle that , they would be foo114 to Lnil•ohte a duty en tattericeu produce, as that would drive 1 riil idene of Ileciproeity from the winds of our Yankee mleigk bora, AVe fancy, however, that their expet•ir.•ncee of free. mole with Canada, and their & ttee- qno: t and presermt experience of protee- lion, have already driven milt ideas far away front their ; fur do not the ' people remember that .lir, George Broil° :vent to W'tshingt In said offer - the Yaukee G.)vernnmeut privile:*ee which would have entailed an expense • of THIRTY MILLION 1)OLLL ARS • on Cltrudaa, if they would only arrant nelleciprneity ? But tiery rt.iemed the rarer wit hscoria TilEY.PRE .'ErJARED 4, PROTECTION.:\eafurther iamdic:t t tmm > .t6 to bete they took Nem the eltlretion :vet setbjt►in a few maracas front tlz' _Iwai+w,t ,!liner, 1►trhliehed in Chicago. We have h ill the Alice, and will show ` l it to any one woo double the anthem- '. deity of the article. Ther c Lotion of taro V aulte tariff, That is 'erft'etly' tret". (tau aal\'ahim be nol', traattvilaeiii :) Titre 1`kb.1m•mhu farmer ',al that duly, for IT WAS 'T.ltii','N FROM "1:.111: 1,.111E t.>1' III:. !1t )1tt•:.I'� !/tit"still in spite or these f.attta, ,tg, {1.41 thlnke the Win rti Itx9 a,e.l t '' 11 ast,�to tla'li.'\,, t11t'y d !'tt ttai�' tta:' lthmty. X.t :t, ta1'?t1., tllti !t el...tr orretttell. 11 at s••1sL„ may yet evyt loath% stmt .t % "11. C. t..-':,inr•ra' ,Ian, tZ.0.," wenfit e1\' "...eh' bring iota Ceuta tiltaleett that Reformer,: 11111 mut re'trialieto. 9��e' i :tar. tt rho tl l•A.. :+urt•ly it tta:;;'t he." Then they tvtl •t v, ).171,1' t,.t •lt�ltnt.' ➢t'( >.1err4t'+. 11mt enita➢ute•et'iel e'iuinna a.f that viper ar fres? horn li'lttmcee, as t11t-y a.ht+tmltl bt+, Sere ie whit the (teas stud iti ,limo (ilei when elleeeeeiag the pride of w at, u its o#mlmmluarchel, not eu itle4l, cal must- -Thee. 1'- tee Il et°atria 11 ea. thewest wilk- t i ••.aa. 1"m 1�:a.e•ei•; v.:.'r)t ,•anaaaalr^t .egt'l to the /1ue+e,ti+lu, cannot fail to m,b. w• I !PA it is tl: t. prays the they. `The first i ,klr tnmecei tvc Z 1 Tall take is the helret' rlmteetien which Mr. Porter mien so ef- fechvely. It is plain c•tauuttlm fur any t 1 farmer or a borer) dealer talion a /torte. beet Exeter to Detroit, taut! sully hl' luta for $120. A Y#rupee talker; tau two ri itusi of the eaeato value front fort Hur*- 1 L•)I tilt Detroit and receives also i121m. he:t`Crt.titLutal, line had to $'2(.t y itduty pity 1 .� o:I his Itorse before he could eros the iota Atmmtatican territory, but tl-e 'Yankee .halo had to pay no duty. Thou i which paid that date, the horse buyer 2vit1➢1. MAD 'run Iet)LLOWL)..t. rA91s. 8,411 a,6t'Rda.:'" a -t•.bps. were' .:Hien at 2:1 v ➢tm�. - �t 1� 11 -.tial Fit tlt'• a+•tt;U3*-3adetllelmt of 1.1'... have Ilia 1' ,•..131:11.4aka, 031'1 , ,lttrt not a..t tt, t a iti:-,,..,Ctk it t t p3V. I..ls. 1.$11 -rales t➢1 lt„••tr,.a. it w.,.iltl aat.;•ea#r that 21 = 3tta i ) tl'na7 1.Ytin. .11.0^i t.i ChUtt•littft tie the horde eviler :) Ia not that plain :" Could anything be plltinor ? 'Dan aL aaiu Mary is another Must ation whi. h '51.1. Porter mitts. el toll gate has re- ceutly been erected in tho neighboring `.:township of 131aushaard, on the graves reed leading to 8t. Ma1•ys, just a few !•oils .vest of the corporation limits:. There is no toll gate ou the east. A. t.trtuer on the west side takes et load of woad into the towu, arid has to pay ten omits toll upon it. When he has ar- rived on tate market, he finds another farmer, one from the eastern side of the town. Both must sell their woad at the some. prie,.., say $2 per cord, admit- ting time qualL'jj to be equal. Now, tho tresterll farmer has paid out ten cents. Theo he only in fact receives fur hie load $1.00. The eastern farmer has paid no toll, having uo toll gate to pass through, and receives $2 for his load. Is not tins as clear as the sun at noonday mei that the producer and not the paroles her of that wood pays the duty p Now, against—WE have no market fees in Ex- frter.'hay that the farmer receives $1 per bushel for his wheat. For a hun- dred bushels he then has $1100. Sup- pose we establish market fees. Do the farmers thiuk the buyers would give their price and pay the fees too ? Not at all, That fee would come out of the farther himself, and the putting on of those fees would take the amount of the fee from each load. Now we shall give a case which al- most.every farmnerin this neighborhood is !acquainted with. They know it to be true. There is no theory about it. It is practical, and cannot be got around by sophistry. Two years ago am farmer, a Iteforuier too, in Usborue,, a mile or two from Ex ter, had one of the best heavy draught teams iu the Connty of Huron. They attracted the fancy of a Yankee horse dealer. He went to, buy them. One of theme atni-` mals, by the way, was a rnare,,the'oth• er a gelding, the latter being worth in • the owner's estimation, w40 snore than than the mare. After l'oohing at the team and satisfying himeelf that they were what he wanted, the Yankee' saki: "I'll give you 6180 for your horse, and $200 for our mare.. Will ;that do ?" -"Why, no,*";eaid the farmer. .."That +811111" are r'pet8.t G1.14 that Matter l01 111,1; 1i•e4lttttl t'h,:ti2w leer l•atnl-t thrt41AI e.:•ttlra' ..i.41 holt a . T•o t :tt th.t V,' 1,1' E t' lt, .•,rc• t a ;w"i>"I l;:u"'i front t"usArit the lel 1 t► 'f :.1:i t s, ti <e tlaf. at ri'S;a•.' Dll effiTt•Ifey.,11 t• D' , 11 ,1" 8,1 Val .rem of ' a 1ntt 1001 11 1,8i11 38111'* r103 f'. a l.* 0131 ilk. f e.30-e*1.8a 0111' e ,* , av 1'1 tl "wri.:Lx t r:N rs "11 the trtstme#et wlaich tau' wool Ts"itz 1,'33 ree.•kttsi .at tlu' lt,i:nla ,•i t.:+,.•art•-s daring rt -1:3,t se>»i'ak 1. :nk tu.i.:: ¢ , I 'l' lI::r ek¢a• .u'imt. it will lir a 1..ng thin„ lean•':'• tial• ane PI oltly tikruty a m sz the *bate u4 cnitu,t Tee u• I,arell.',nt nations. s r ` It is •'tic the mnomti tenveifed anti t+rn o.'rath eotet- . 'i.'•t that can atf r•,l to 1)1 rah •I to. se:ti in:en. i itiaG, t' 't • 'i• imltd .' it: 'he Fol,f.Y OP r1.1:I TitADV. with Mir rival': tCi..,i.l #.t the maw!): Wow reed: th'•.i�.'um s1v a,n ti:a m'm tu- t kt•••+ of tato• teele'1:''t," re the four yearn ending, June 130th. 18t15, we sent 3i,7Okleil,8 bushtels of wheat into the United Shies. Tide was under free trade or ra't•.it•rYtetty,llut u the trine years eteliea•r .TtiDlYt ail, 1877, we nulysent thea, 1t..t.•17:3.784 bumt'is. P hi.a was ender fa birth 'Mei''. In the out years we rout them 7,8:18,(195 ushels a year, but under the prntt-crive Tett v ,till raid ➢eweth, a,• her, b r t a elua i . lieett,v 21e., hat it la..,tl.l #a + t.•uhrlit- b. ri ,i that only rent .'f l.v,'.11 t'n this 13'.310 t n�l twit t.`llt, of 81111r:48$ 1., .s .111 Ili.' .LYIt rit•tall, are r, ltd 1'4,8,4..11.1111y e \h. #'ti•tt, ;ate.! %haswe rind tiaatt the prim tviue 1a might ,1rki1 l b. t• ti,i in 'i+nowt;t, hs not tam' Wli\ 1'1 •C)\I; C 1,X Di a pound," Now, in the Lee of this, will Reform - ere venture to say that the mast who buys pays tho duty ? I Every vote cast for the Re- form {roveriiiuent is a vote in favor of legislative incolupet- aloe, extravagance and indif- ference to vital national re- quirements., Tome is only 10 per cent. duty on American fruit trees. As a result, Yaukee fruit trees flood the conutry There is a duty in the United States on Canadian trees of 20 per cent. Re salt ; no Canadian treed caa be sent there, and our nurseries are crushed out of existence. We have a small nursery on the Thames Road. Under protection, that nursery, with the ex- cellent trees it produces, could be mad, to do a very extensive business. We'11 bet a new hat that " C. Cameron, E -q., Q. C., would not for $100 lose that printed sheet containing false figures of the expenditure sent him by the Reform Assoeiatiou of the Province. He'd be stuck fur his figurer, since he fails to carry the pure, un - 'adulterated documents. Stafne upon the man who would that stoop to ads - teed the people. Why don't he take the Blue Books ? Aye, that's the rub. They tell the true tale. His printed sheet tells' a false one, In 1873 he had Blue Books, but they are not convene• out now. But he is the same as every other candidate of the party in the Dominion. ttivl. C. CAMERON, Este, 411.0.,".ns he in his effusive self-conceit styles him. self, is working alight and main helping the Yankee farmers to send the pro- duce of their soil into Canada free of duty. But he doesn't favor allowing Yankee lew_vei•e to comp€to with him m Go,lerich. Don't 'make filth of one and fowl of the other. The farmers themselves should see to it. LI\SVILLII, or Rat hole, as 31. C. Cameron," Q. C., sneeringly alluded to that place at Crediton, will give IVIr. Porter as uandsome nejority.. •Why tariff we Rent them only 1,135:1.131 bashels, a Mims off a. mmily of 11,5 52,- 141 b rebels. No wonder they clew to peote'etrnn 1 The Miller very perti- nently says in We ,:o1nU:ctit111, t '•It welts to IN 111;a1 tilDSO fi;rias lra'#'cnt as wry good 3t !len why there <Ltmed ile ,lutw 011 W1110t dour e,1uin3. Ir'01n Caauialla1." If there should be It duty (10 Calan- dra wheat al't1 flour surely there elionld be duty on Yankee wheat and flour. Then a Kain the Miller says „We are acquainted VC 311 s*'v ran Ciauadiah Millers who favor a high tariff 013 American flour; and teras we renin the signs of the times aqui::;, it will not In, long 3'10 Canada, will be obliged to protect her .killers and musn- nfaetnrel:s from outside competition. We have mastered the lesson taught by rtciproeity, and found that the benefits were all on ono side. American millers, at least, will not care to seat ' the sentimental experiment of free trade re- neated. In the course of events onr Canadian - friends will learn the same lesson, and await will be our earn to solicit neighborly courtesies." Here is more evidence from the New York Sana of September 3. .' mmeoiproct`•y wi''h Canaria. Why, yes, certain- ly; we are all ready for it. Only, it would be con- venient for the BeVer'1 I'rovineea of the 1)o'ninion to ho a.dtnitted among the United St.tes as a eon- rhitio•a precedent.' There is another idea in the last ex- tract than that they will not grant Re- ciprocity. It is this, and it stands out boldly and plainly in view. 'The Am- ericans desire to drive us into annexa- tion with they., and they are taking the most certain means of securing that end if the people of Canada unwisely persist in allowing them to central our markets. In fact, a leading commer- cial paper only the other day, referring to the fact that onr markets are tribut- ary to the Yaukoee, said : will not be lc,ng before Canada be- comes part and parcel of they United States. '1'lle work of assimilation is rapidly anal steadi- ly going on, and will ere loug,be cothplete." Will the people persist in the policy that the Yankees know will drive ne into annexetinu?lt'eannot'helpihut have such a result. I,nt. the electors he warned in time to prevent such a nation- al hunt illation. We would warm nr friends to be particularly cantions in all their trans' sactiona. ;Do not commit one act which could be construed ageinet the spirit of the election law. '. What we want is r purity. of election. Though we already r know of several occurrences on C•trner- o11's aide which will beau ran- .sly look if i cannot Cameron keep this tongue from he sllould•by .accident ev •r be cal led slandering the people ? uponto explain them before a, Cs irt.' MLSSRS, PORTER AND CAGJERON AT EXETER. Ou Tbnrsday afternoon hast Messrs. Robert Potter and M. C. Cameron met at 1'4ralper's Hotel, in Exeter North, for the purpose of diectlseir-g the pr)- IiticrLl cln.:stotlus of the day. The at- tendenee Was very good, the I;t form. ere from. portions of l:,dbormie and flay turning out in ,eao3 tlnlnhere. The meeting was hola in the rlitaium; room tf 3Ir. S�'atl;er'e ht)tt-L Jr. J. Teel• patrick occupied the ctm.air. Mr. Cs;mi- eron first addreseed the analmt�Iu e, and for half nn hour der. till himself to wearieome and stale 111aalittele'1 1111 free traria, `Tho remaitld,;t of nil time tint;+ mostly (eeulhiC;l In delivering the the lulhmtest land tweet impotent .defence of the trade poliey of the Coverameat we ever heard from the lipe of aur man of professed lability, Ile entered Neon the subject vvi'th evident fear, and had not gone far before Ime had irrepaar- •Lbly tone:ee l bL own mute fly raying that if we imposed a duty on American )eller time A mmomicarts would rotaliatte 8y putting on An inerertgltl tltlty. '!.'bat soultf it::tap 011r barley umtto ether out of their market*. Nave it he evident that they, the c•'usumlm;`re, do not pay the duty, else they would not inereaso their uwu harden* fir the tttmrpsee of retaliating noon C'anrdat, They would not cut oft their own nista to shite our faced. He caught lmitn'elf in as many as a de,xeit places, mud gatve vent to the ally idea that if we 1tretected otuselvee a;;ain'•t England her states. .men wtuihi also shut ud out. This it': will he seen,, at a glance, is edemrd.` The English want our grain and other f ftL:cni products beeaus they do not pro-{ duet memoir for timau:rel'vee, and if they nevem. a duty on maty .article of whieh, they do not produce enough for their awn consuumptit)n they mm�st pay the ;toy. He, however. f1r of to tell the people that the L, elt,e1 til, tee, Austra- lia, L'ee.t,uu, z.111 ....1 .rt,.l otter t.Vt,a :riles protected themselves method Ise.; land, but &eland has not yet placed a tariff on their geode. But the most utterly mlritrutllful ,assertion he made was that there is no deprt's- tiou in Canada, none in the County of lluron�. Many an ineredmous smile flitted across the couutenancee of the people as he uttered this bush. He )ext attempted to prove that the pro- lneer pays the duty. but made a very had familure ; in fact he would have .lone butter not to have meutioued it. tlr. Greenway may not have been a very .acceptable mlan to the party, but at all events, he ttnderetood the trade lue:.tion better than the present candi- date. After a very feeble speech he took his seat. Mr. Porter's reply was masterly, lo- gical and convincing. He showed that the fatrmers were injured by the com- petition of Yankee farmers. and quoted from the Trade and Navigation Re- turns to prove that Canadian farmers received more for their grain sent to l�ngland than for that sent to the Uuited Crates. This proves their pro- tective duty injures us. He took three or four articles and the prices than were obtained in 1877, and showed that the amount of time Yankee duty over the Dost of transportation to Eng- land almost exactly measured the dif- ference in price. This also proves that the producer pays the ditty. IIis reply to Mr. Cameron's theory that the con- sumer pays the duty was clear and convincing, and only those who won't be convinced contend that he did not completely demolish the • very frail strnoture which Mr. Cameron had built up. He showed that the carry- ing trade would not be injured by the imposition of an increased duty, for all time grain could pass through Canada in bond on the way to the seaboard, and closed a speech of an hour and a quarter's duration amici lend applause. Mr. Cameron replied, but without ef- fent, and launched out into tlme,mazes of finances in -which he made several ghtt' lug misetatenieuts.. At every meeting hitherto held, he had refused Nr. Porter the right of speaking as often as. he aid, whichwasmanifestly' 'unfair, but the people of :Exeter demanded for Hr. Porter the right of reply, but when the' National 'Policy candidate'. ose to his"Peet, the Stervationists, ifraid of 1.1r. 0amnerou's misstatements about onr finances being ex,posed,,roso o a hotly and left tha;rooln,thns closing the lileotiug. Cheers were ,given for the Queen, Mr. Porter and the nmeetiug quietly dispersed. AT CitEDITOY the meeting was 10 elutes. every sense a ret: etition of Exeter. There was :a v •y large ttttelmdauee, the meeting be. nlF� bold in the Town Hall, which lovas tiled to suffocation, half el tha,se pree- ent hie nll•able to gaahm rsiuuttane,r, but althenAii aeked to epee!: front the door so that all could hear, Mr. Cam- eron refused to do so, Mr. Parses occupied the chair. Mr. C'ienmere'n lanitele out into the vileet Aimee of the Exeter TIui•.:t, �al idtf; ue 'ttlkat's,'• , ••e.)nitciencele•s;, and other iumptelite t mums. "Here, gentlemen," start ht', "a paper pubiiehed in the city of Exe- ter, eontaimiug seventeen urtielea a-➢t4i er ventt en lies. It'd a shame to fie l tithe patter scattered briaadcaet throw .11 the rating celntainieg *neh lie's just on the eve ttf an eleetinu, when it ktt,/ late to•c',nrtradie t there," evidently un- aware that lie wart at the time doia➢f :se to tee beet of his abiiity. Dot the c• ectora noticed that in c'antradietingr them he took the greatest pains to rta,l from a printed e#heut Ikeut him by the Reform A roeirttiun and not front they Blue Batiks, as he t'holmld have dote, if be desired the people t:) be'lie've than tL Ititnee'lf was :mut the falsifier. But EA uis llii bf:alutin about the "dirty, mire. erld& Tory sheet” and the ra+u;t o. d from Exeter fail flat upon the and.- ten4a', and Lawry ehl.Ilreest'al their cite• satisfaction at the very unrefined toee of his ad:lresa, The trade ipte:,litln hFa.i a bothered him ere touch that �Ii let it l alttue in his lit+G .heath, and elevate 1 himself to the Northern Railier:et enw, the Boylan scandal, the Petit.. caudal. and sn31t ether delicate int).'. eele. But they too, malty no ilmpt•1°.s. sten, as tho tte'tple tlet -ett�t every fel ;. elate ne et be ]nude, especially lir,t where be said 3Lnylaan had ut't t1 u,:x one ce'nt's worth of printing 1'r the money be got. We will net insnit It' intellige'nco by saayraag he dill taut fillet" letter, but we do bay ho w:34 nl-al:t iti? • lltllte't 1.➢1 making snelm a staata''➢n''a:t. foe Mr. 3ltlyletii ret.Irued v:thty. f1r,•t- e3•. 0 '.e 1,. ..:. erect, e1 It"ate tithe J. dire In fact, he had into the renting lnting .e0- fore he was proud the mover, .tut Si: John, in order to secure the comities until they could eonritlar atlr. iLoylall`s claim, wrote on the orator for the money that it sthonld be paid in print. ing. That is tilt) extent of the eL'itmltlt:. which 313' Cameron rolled tinder hie tongue et It sweet morsel. lie forlt.a1 to tell atbont the steel rails, the N t 1143 ,z Hotel, the Iiruninitatitlua Wel Pureilal..v. the !'ort Fr'inous 100101, the tintierieli harbor job, the Irhgiuish harbor jet', the Anglin inadvertency, the Foster: contract, auti his own >zorruptiou. But perhaps it was to his interest to keep dark on these very shady traimsactions. This speech was even worse than the one at Exeter, and the wonder is that 31r. Porter could find it in hie heart to speak against hint. But 11e did, and carried the audience completely with him, and excited the iuterest of the farmers on the trade question. That theyare begiuning to realize their true position, std the injustice of the com- petition of the American farmers is evidenced by the very patient and at- tentive hearing they give 31r. Porter,. and the questions asked him by the farmers at the conclusion of his speech all of which he answered to their entire satisfaction. Itir. Cameron replied, but his speech was so contradictory, weak and ineffective, that Mr. Punter, although his supporters were vastly in the majority ; in the proportion pos- sibly of 3 to 1, did not deem an answer necessary. The meeting dis- persed about eleven o'clock, and if we are not very, very far astray in our cal- onlations, the people of that neighbor- hood will vote almost in a body for Mr. Porter. There were dozeus of farm- ers present who iutend to support Mr. Porter who never gave a Conservative vote in their lives. This is the case in every part of the riding. LIMERICK. . On Friday night the candidates attain met here. This chair was ably filled by i11r. Renry Doyle, who made a neat sheath in iutrodnciug the speakers. They each spoke forty miuutes,' when Mr. Greenway ;followed. The 1181161 abuse of the Exeter Trines character- ized Mr.. Cameron's oration. But the people of 111111 neigliberhood are too in- telligent to ntelligent'to bo led away from the real ieeties of the campaign by such ',clap- trap. beeides they world take the tvi.rd. of Tire 'hetes before Mr. Cameron's oath. In this Vicinity Mr. Porter Will be overwholhniuglyeusaWeed.