Times-Advocate, 1981-01-21, Page 221
Page 22
Times -Advocate, January 21, 1981
By JACK RIDDELL
Jack's Jottings
The Krever report
The report of the Ontario
Hoyal Commission ap-
pointed to investigate abuses
in the disclosure of personal
health records was released
at the end of last year.
After nearly three years of
enquiry. Mr. Justice Horace
Krever of the Ontario
Supreme Court proposed
some 170 legislative changes
aimed at enhancing the con -
Obituaries
FLORELEANOR CLEAVE
At the Bluewater Rest
Home, Zurich, on Saturday,
January 17, 1981, Mrs.
Floreleanor Elizabeth
Watson i Cleave, in her 90th
year. Widow of the late Paul
Cleave (1975). Dear mother
of Logan and James, both of
Bayfield, Eric of Wingham
and Ann (Mrs. Edward
Twentyman) of Waukegan,
Ilinois. Dear sister of Mrs.
Bessie Gillard of Union.
Predeceased by four
brothers and four sisters.
Also survived by 17 grand-
children, 18 great-
grandchildren and two
great -great-grandchildren.
Rested at the Westlake
Chapel of Michael P.
O'Connor Funeral Homes, 49
Goshen Street. North, Zurich
where the funeral and
committal service was
conducted on Tuesday,
January 20 at 2 p.m. with
Pastor Ross Smith of-
ficiating. Temporary en-
tombment with interment
later in Bayfield Cemetery.
MARY ELLEN GLAVIN
At Marian Villa, London,
Ontario, .on Saturday,
January 17. 1981. Mary Ellen
Sullivan, widow of the late
Charles Glavin of Mt.
Carmel, in her 91st year.
Dear mother of (Helen) Mrs.
Hanlon McDonald of RR 5
Parkhill (Bornish), (Mary)
Mrs. Charles Dietrich of
Mt. Carmel and Father
Basil Glavin of C.S.B.
Saskatoon, Joseph, John,
Patrick and Ray, all of RR 2,
Crediton and predeceased by
one daughter Madeline.
Dear sister of Father B.F.
Sullivan C.S.B. St. Michael's
College, Toronto. Also
survived by 45 grandchildren
and 42 great-grandchildren.
Rested at the T. Harry
Hoffman and Sons Funeral
Home, Dashwood where
prayers were said on
Monday at 8:30 p.m. led by
Father Joseph Nelligan.
Funeral mass on Tuesday,
January 20th at 10:30
a.m. at Our Lady of Mt.
Carmel Church with in-
terment in the adjoining
cemetery.
DR. J.GRANT MILLS
Dr. J. Grant Mills of 526
Crescent Road, N.W.
Calgary. Alberta passed
.away December 24, 1980 in
Calgary. General Hospital in
his 53rd year.
Born in Woodham,
Ontario. he was the son of
Mrs. Mildred Mills, St.
Marys. and the late Ray
Mills ( 1967). He received his
elementary education there
and his high school education
at St Marys Collegiate. He
received his ARCT in music
in Toronto in 1948, his Q.A. at
University of Western
Ontario in 1951 and his M.P.
in 1954 at U.W.O. He
received his C.C.F.P.in 1971
in Calgary. It,. Mills served
with the Canadian Armed
Forces from 1952-1959 at
Cargary. Wainwright,
Whitehorse and Egypt. He
was in private practice in
Calgary from 1960-1969 after
which tirne he joined the
Faculty of Medicine
University of Calgary.
Division of Family Practice.
Since 1973 he has been semi-
retired. working summers at
Lake Louise for five years.
and various locums during
the winter months Dr
Mills was an active member
of the Medical Community
He served on many com-
mittees for the local Calgary
lic>spitals and also headed
the C M A committee on
the delivery of Health ('are
He had several scientific
papers published. and
presented in relation to
provision of Health Care Itis
most recent concern was to
develop provision of better
health care for the native
and white people in Northern
Alberts. Surviving are his
wife, the former Rhoda
Kirkby, daughters Judy
(Mrs. Bill Brunette,, Nancy,
both of Calgary. sons Jay. of
Fox Lake, Alberta, and
Douglas of Calgary', Alberta
also his mother. Mrs
Mildred Mills and sister,
Mrs. Harold Levy, both of St.
Marys.
f
ELIZABETH VOLLAND
At The Queensway Manor,
Hensall on Tuesday,
January 13, 1981, Mrs.
Elizabeth (Albrecht)
Volland, in her 98th year.
Widow of the lateJohn Henry
Volland (1968). Dear mother
of Clarence of Hensall,
Bruce of Sudbury, Mrs. Vera
Johnston, Brucefield, Mrs.
Irene Finlayson of Hensall,
Beatrice (Mrs. Louis
Taylor), Varna. Also sur-
vived by 16 grandchildren, 35
great-grandchildren and
four great -great-grandch-
ildren. Rested at the Bon-
thron Chapel of Michael P.
O'Connor Funeral Home, 118
King Street, Hensall, where
the funeral and committal
services were conducted on
Friday, January 16th at 2
p.m. with Rev. Lockhart
Royal officiating. Tem-
porary entombment with
interment later in Hensall
Union Cemetery.
JACOB HABERER
At St. Joseph's Hospital,
London on Friday, January
16th, 1981, Jacob William
Haberer, of 21 Goshen Street
South, Zurich, in his 77th
year. Beloved husband of
Vera Clara Kalbfleisch.
Dear father of Jchn,Toronto.
Dear brother of Ferdinand of
Zurich. Predeceased by four
brothers and three sisters.
Also survived by three
grandchildren, Sarah,
Stephen and Beth. Rested at
the Westlake Chapel of
MichaelP. O'ConnorFuneral
Homes, 49 Goshen Street
North, Zurich, then to St.
Peter's Lutheran Church,
Zurich for funeral service on
Sunday, January 18th at 2
p.m. with Pastor Jack
Dressler officiating. Tem-
porary entombment with
interment later in St. Peter's
Lutheran Cemetery.
MARGARET HAMILTON
At St. Joseph's Hospital,
London on Wednesday,
January 14, 1981, Margaret
(Elliott) Hamilton of Exeter.
Beloved wife of the late
Gordon Hamilton and dear
mother of Laverne of
Exeter, James of St. Thomas
and Beverly of RR 1,
Hensall. Dear grandmother
of Ray, John, Marilyn,
Robbie, Tasha, David,
Dianne and Gordon. Sister of
Mrs. Elizabeth Karadiss of
California, Mrs. Jean Henry
of Lucknow, Gordon Elliott
of Kitchener and Edith (Mrs.
Morley Kiteley) of Maxville.
Rested at the R. C.Dinney
Funeral Home, Main Street,
Exeter. Funeral and com-
mital service at the funeral
home on Saturday, January
17th at 2 p.m. with Rev.
James Forsythe officiating.
Interment in Exeter
Cemetery.
ROBERT IRELAND
Robert Herman Ireland
passed away January 14,
1981 at Brantford General
Hospital, in his 78th year.
Beloved husband of Ruby
(Munn), father of Douglas,
and Elizabeth Stanley both
of Brantford. Brother of Mrs. C
Fergus Turnbull (Hilda), C
Dashwood and Leslie
Arkona. Predeceased by
sister Mrs. William Jennison
(Myren and Simm. Also
surviving are five grand-
children.
SAMUEL ROLLINS
At. St. Joseph's Hospital,
London, on Saturday,
January 17. 1981, Samuel
James Rollins of 1106 Sunset
Avenue. in his 68th year.
Beloved husband of Violet
"Vicki" (Ernest) Rollins
and dear brother of William
L Rollins of London; John W.
Rollins late of London
(1977). Dear stepfather of
Mrs. Robert (Carol) Vyse
and Mrs. Thomas (Debbie)
MaGee both of London; Mrs.
Tim (Judy) Richter of
Edmonton. Also loved by six
nieces and nephews. Rested
at the Jas. A. Harris Funeral
Home, London, where the
funeral service will be
conducted on Wednesday,
January 21 at 1 p.m., by
Reverend Bruce J. Small of
Robinson Memorial United
Church. Interment Exeter
Cemetery.
1
fidentiality of health records
while legalizing certain
forms of disclosure.
Terms of reference of the
commisssion, established in
December 1977, called for a
review of pertinent legisla-
tion to ascertain whether
confidentiality of patients'
records was being properly
protected. and an investiga-
tion into any improper ac-
tivities or violations of the
laws.
The commission's report
confirmed the existence of
widespread abuses, but ad-
vised against prosecution of
offenders, suggesting the
real fault lies in the system.
Judge Krever said that his
review of 77 statutes and
regulations showed "no con-
sistent treatment or
coherent policy regarding
the confidentiality of health
information". that he had
found little in the way of
restrictions on access to
health records except,
ironically. for the patients
themselves.
"In Ontario. patients have
very limited rights of access
to health information about
themselves. Only six
statutes and regulations ex-
pressly confer such rights,
and the information to which
access is granted is
restricted in scope."
The Krever Report
proposes that patients be
given a qualified right of
access to their own health
records and a means of hav-
ing errors in those records
corrected. A provincially ap-
pointed health com-
missioner could hear
appeals for denial of such
access on grounds it would
harm the patients, and
would also hear appeals
against refusals to correct
patients' records.
Confidentiality could be
protected by a host of new
Ambulance
firm sold
The ownership of the area
ambulance service in Zurich
has recently changed hands
Mr. Michael O'Connor
assumed the operational
responsibility of the service
from Keith Westlake a few
days before Christmas and
has been busy in the com-
munity ensuring a smooth
transition.
Ambulance service
throughout the province of
Ontario is funded directly
by the Ministry of Health,
and Mr. O'Connor stated that
increased funding for the
O'Connor Ambulance Ser-
vice will enable the
acquisition of a new am-
bulance and radio com-
munication system and will
also allow additional staff to
be hired as part of the
overall planned im-
provement which will benefit
the area citizens.
Mr. O'Connor stated that
the area which will be served
by O'Connor Ambulance
covers portions of: Goderich
Township, Stanley Town-
ship, Hay Township,
Tuckersmith Township,
Usborne Township, Hibbert
Township and includes
Zurich, Hensall and
Bayfield.
There is no change in
telephone numbers and
anyone who requires an
ambulance in the area is
reminded that O'Connor
Ambulance Service can be
reached at 236-4364 or Zenith
90.000.
BE A + BLOOD DONOR
Huron County
Family Planning Project
Invites You To Attend
FAMILY
PLANNING
''CLINIC
Every Tuesday
from 6:30 - 9 p.m.
HURON COUNTY
HEALTH UNIT
Ann St., Exeter
For Information
CaII 235-1014
Weehdoys or Tuesday evenings
• Everyone welcome ,
r
laws and rules to be followed
by hospitals. government
agencies, health-care per-
sonnel, employers and
others who possess health
records.
Recognizing that conflicts
may develop between the
needs for privacy and public
protection. the report does
not actually ban disclosure.
"There will be seen
throughout the eternal con-
flict
on-
flict between the obligation
to. and the rights of, patients
and the public's need for, or
interest in. protection".
Only one sanction is por-
posed for breaches of con-
fidentiality and that is resort
to the courts in the form of a
lawsuit. The Report
recommends that any
patient whose health infor-
mation has been disclosed be
given the right to sue for
a minimum of $10,000 both
the person "who un-
justifiably discloses" the in-
formation and anyone who.
induced that person to make
the disclosure.
The main innovation
would be the $10,000
minimum and the absence of
a time limit for launching
the lawsuit. At present, a
suit for breach of a provin-
cial statute is limited to ac-
tual damages suffered, and
must be initiated within six -
months.
Introducing his Report,
Judge Krever says his en-
quiry began as a modest
study of provincial legisla-
tion and administrative
processes. but it soon
became much more am-
bitious due to disclosures in-
dicating the magniture of
abuses taking place.
Although the Report in-
cludes sharp criticism of
people and institutions,
Judge Krever gives two
reasons for recommending
against, any prosecutions.
First of all, he wants
attention focused "on the
need for future protection
rather than on past
behaviour" and secondly
prosecution would be seen as
discriminatory, because "it
is reasonably clear that
those offenders whose ac-
tivities came to our atten-
tion during the enquiry com-
prise only a fraction of those
engaged in conduct of the
same type."
For example, certain
lawyers were identified as
involved in obtaining health
information without patients
consent. "It is known,
however. that the practices
illustrated were not confined
to the named lawyers but, on
the contrary. extended
throughout that part of the
legal profession par-
ticipating in personal injury
litigation."
The second volume of the
three volume, 1626 -page
report. examines the role of
police. both as occasional
applications for health infor-
mation and as regulators of
private investigators. It in-
cludes sharp criticism of the
role played. by the Royal
Canadian Mounted Police
during the investigative
hearings and a portrayal of
the private investigation in-
dustry in Ontario as "out of
control".
In this connection, the
report states that respon-
sibility for regulating
private eyes and security
guards should stay with the
registration branch of the
Ontario Provincial Police
but recommends the branch
be given more powers and
personnel to carry out its
mandate more effectively.
Most of the recommen-
dations relating to the police
deal with procedures to be
followed in providing health
information to law enforce-
ment agencies.
The over-all effect would
be to allow the police con-
tinued access on presenta-
tion of search warrants and
to permit, although not re development of 1 4!e year-old
quire hospitals to disclose deer ( yearlings) in the
some types of information to harvest, gives the manager a
police without patients' con- good indication of the sur -
sent. vival of the deer herd,
CREDITON SKATERS — A Targe number of Crediton area youngsters and some not so
young took advantage of Sunday's free skating in the pavilion provided by the Crediton
firemen. T -A photo
March of Dimes
Campaign
e
Monday
training. funds medical
research and co-ordinates
medical clinics. In addition,
it provides items such as
wheelchairs, braces, elec-
tronicaids and other devices
and camping holidays in
summer and winter for dis-
abled people who . seldom
have the chance to enjoy out-
door activities.
Assistance is also provid-
ed to groups of disabled peo-
ple on ways to better repre-
sent themselves with issues
of importance to them. The
wide range of services
offered by the March of
Dimes help physically dis-
abled people to help
themselves.
Sooner or later, every
family is touched by disabili-
ty to some degree. Your gift
to the Ontario March of
Dimes could offer help that
is very close to home.
When the March of Dimes'
volunteers knock on your
door. or when campaign
letters arrive in the mail,
please give generously.
Remember, the Ontario
March of Dimes - Can't Help
Without Your Help."
If you would like. to
volunteer to be a Marching
Mother and help those less
fortunate than yourself
please contact Dorothy
Pfaff. 235-2013
The 'Week of January 26 is Year of Disabled Person.
the kick-off date for the 1981 A team of more than 45
campaign by the Ontario march of Dimes volunteers
March of Dimes. This year, will be calling on homes In
the organization will also be this area. Please make them
welcome and give as
generously as you can to the
Ability Fund.
The Ontario March of
Dimes slogan - We Can't
Help Without Your Help - is
so true.
Each year, hundreds of
people become disabled
through accidents or dis-
eases - people who are
building careers or raising
young families, people who
face disability for the first
time when they reach old
age. And there are also peo-
ple who were born with dis-
abilities, who are now grown
up and need jobs. In general,
men and women who want to
become integrated and in-
volved in our society.
When disability strikes,
the Ontario March of Dimes
is there to provide oppor-
tunities. The organization
celebrating its 30th anniver-
sary.
The Ability Fund cam-
paign raises funds annually
forservicesand programs on
behalf of over 750,000
physically disabled men and
women in Ontario. The Cam-
paign Chairman for this dis-
trict is Doroth Pfaff. Tony
Gabriel of the Ottawa
Roughriders will be the
Honourary Campaign Chair-
man Provincially.
The Ontario March of
Dimes has successfully
provided unique and in-
novative services for the
past three decades to meet
the ever changing needs and
abilities of this Province's
disabled population. This
year provides an excellent
opportunity to do something
special for many han-
dicapped people as the
United Nations International offers employment and job
Huron hunting
results analysed
During the three days
November 3 to 5, a gun
hunting season for deer was
established in Huron County
for the first time since 1974.
The results have now been
analysed and are as follows:
In total, 885 validation
stickers were issued to in-
terested hunters throughout
the three zones in Huron
County. -4n .estimated 728
(82.2 percent) sportsmely
participated in the hunt and
14.8 percent were successful
in harvesting 103 deer.
Residents of Huron County
comprised 70 percent of
those participating in the
hunt. A total of 1222 hunter -
days were spent in the
pursuit of deer.
Deer check stations were
operated throughout the
district at four locations plus
a mobile unit manned by
district staff to collect
biological data. This :in-
formation is needed as a
basis for determining health
of the deer herd in Huron
County and is a necessary
requirement to determine
management direction for .
the future.
Deer were brought to our
check stations by co-
operative and interested
hunters. Ministry of Natural
Resources wildlife staff
examined 73 deer, or nearly
three-quarters of the
animals harvested. The
largest deer was an 8 point
116.4 kg. (dressed weight)
buck from the Bayfield
River area.
This year, hunters could
use either a shotgun or
muzzle -loader for hunting.
Most hunters chose shotguns
(96.8 percent) but a few did
use muzzle -loading weapons
(3.2 percent).
Long, cold winters with
deep snow are killers of deer
in Ontario. The number,
weights and antler
JOHN TINNEY
APPRECIATION
NIGHT
at the
PINERIDGE CHALET
Friday, January 30
9 p.m.
Orchestra: Joe Overholt
EVERYONE WELCOME
especially fawns, through
the previous winter.
This year's harvest was
comprised of 35.6 percent
fawns, 28.8 percent
yearlings, (1 1/2 years) and
35.6 percent adults • (2 1/2.
years and older). Fawn to
yearling survival over the
1979-80 winter was good. A
mild winter and adequate
food supplies were important
factors in their survival.
During a telephone survey
conducted by our staff im-
mediately following the hunt
most hunters contacted
enjoyed the opportunity to be
able to hunt closer to home
for both social and economic
reasons.
There is a large, healthy
deer herd in Huron County
going iinto the winter of 1980-
81. The Ministry of Natural
Resources will continue to
monitor deer numbers and
develop management plans
for 1981.
Dance
Sat., Jan. 24
K -W
Community
Centre
Music by
Diane and
The Cavaliers
Sponsored by Kirkton-
Woodham Opitmist Club
$7.00 a coep1e
Lunch and door prize
included. Tickets available
from Opitimist Members
Queens Hotel
s.are„h
Hay it's
Urban Cowboy Week -end
Featuring Stoker
Put on your cowboy duds or come as you
are and join in the fun.
fAL L STAR HO KEY
� C Y
for
Oven
South Huron Hockey League
NORTH vs SOUTH
FRI. JAN. 23, 1981
8 p.m.
ZURICH ARENA
Proceeds 60% to Big Brothers
40% to S.H.H.L.
The Best In
ROCK and ROLL
tg
THIS WEEK Next Week
BUSKER TRACY KANE
illetaoI
vrecortife%
227-441
�rhe
neen %test
MOTOR HOTEL
GRAND BEND H'way 21 ',., Mile S. Traffic Light
For Reservations Phone 238-2365
DINING ROOM
OPEN DAILY
ENTERTAINMENT
except Sunday evening
Saturday only, January 24
Dwight James
Breadfast, lunch
and dinner
Schnitzel Night
Every Wednesday
We offer a Schnitzel dinner for only $495
IT'S A SMALL WORLD AT
WALT DISNEY WORLD AND IT'S
A SMALL WORLD IN EXETER TOO!
BOOK YOUR
FLORIDA
VACATION
NOW FOR
Christmas
1981-82
March Break
1982-83
Our Junior Travel Advisors Say "Everyone Should See Disneyworld”
Planning to visit Florida? call now and let us make your travel arrangements
- Hotel Accommodations
- Condominium Rentals
- Bus tour holidays
- Air flights •
- Package holidays
- Information on Florida Tourist Attractions
- Rent -a -car
- Maps & guides
1