The URL can be used to link to this page

Huron Expositor, 2002-08-28, Page 1News TME HURON EXPOSITOR, September 5, 1001-/ Conservation authority loses appeal in Terpstra manure tank case By scorch Caldwell Goderich Signal -Star staff The Maitland Valley Conservation Authority lost its appeal, on August 30, to retry a case against Charles Terpstra and Cranbrook Swine Inc. for charges laid in relation to the Conservation Act, for not seeking proper permission to build a liquid manure storage tank on alleged swampland. The original trial, which lasted three days, was heard in Ontario Superior Court in July 2000. The Justice of the Peace ruled at that time that the Maitland Valley Conservation Authority did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the land under the manure storage was indeed swamp land. This decision was overturned at the appeal and Judge Hunter agreed with the MVCA that the land was swampland. MVCA lawyer Darryl Hawreliak said under the Conservation Act buildings cannot be built on a pond, swamp or floodplain without the approval of the local conservation authority. The permit has not been revoked from Terpstra and Cranbrook Swine but there was a stop work order issued since September 2000. Terpstra's defence lawyer, • David Thompson, said the trial was just over a year ago and was dismissed. The original appeal was to be heard in January and it was agreed that ,it be adjourned to April. It was finally heard in August, 13 months later. "The building permit was issued of pure faith, now we are being told we can't rely on the building permit," said the defence. "What authority is there that says they (Terpstra and Cranbrook Swine) have to go looking for the MVCA?" said the defence. As for the land being swamp land, the defence said it was circumstantial evidence and even the experts said that there are other explanations for the findings. "There is absolutely no doubt through the prosecution's own case that this is officially -induced error." The MVCA could have appealed under the Building Code Act to appeal the building permit order within 20 days. That is the procedure the conservation authority should have followed instead of "swinging widely," said Thompson. • The MVCA to date has not appealed the building official's decision. The judge in his ruling, after a brief recess, said, "there is no suggestion that the respondents at any time acted in an other than responsible manner and in good faith went to proper authorities and gained a building permit to construct the holding tank." After construction commenced it came to the notice of the MVCA that the holding tank was possibly being constructed on a swamp. Tests were done and this added to the belief of the MVCA that the area was a swamp. Therefore charges were laid. "I'm satisfied the respondents can rely on 'officially -induced error,' " said Hunter. "There was no obligation on them to consult with other authorities and there was nothing to suggest that they are not entitled to rely on the building permit," said Hunter. "The MVCA can not now expect to find favour in this case for breach of the Conservation Act," said Hunter. "The respondents did all they could have done possible. The error was committed by the Building Official. "All charges are dismissed by tt respondents," concluded Hunter. The MVCA were also ordered to pay the respondents, Charles Terpstra and Cranbrook Swine Inc., $1,000 each for costs incurred with the appeal process. MVCA general manager Phil Beard said after the ruling on Thursday, that overall he was disappointed with the ruling. "We won on the part of it being built on swamp land but we lost on the part that we figured we didn't have to fight about," he said. Beard said it is now entirely up to the Township of Morris-Turnberry and its building inspector, to decide whether or not to revoke the stop work order that was put in place last September. They had been waiting on the outcome of the appeal to make their decision. The board of directors for the MVCA, will meet on September 19, with its lawyer to find out what other options can be explored or whether the judge has made an error an judgement, he said. Beard said after the judgement Thursday morning that he was "disappointed." "I don't feel manure storage tanks should be built on swampland that drains into the watercourse," said Beard. In this case if there was a leak it would draip into the Middle Maitland river, he said. small TALK t1p016111.1,941410 r..o.w Your child's first words are important Are you concerned about the wiry your child's speech and language skil/s are developing.? For information or a speech assessment call 273-2222 or 1-800-269-3683 visit our website at www,sma/ltalkinfo.ca smaIITALK services are funded by the Ministry of Health and Long -Term Care BUSINESS DIRECTORY To Place YourAd Call -527-0240 MARION'S PAINTING Free Estimates •Interior/Exterior Painting •Drywall Repair Call Mike Marion 527-0707 (Evenings) RALPH LiKa WOOD, ELECTRIC 'Agricultural • Commercial • Residential CALL SEAFORTH 527-0448 7 Huron 6 RON/l� C_,®ASSHWAY 198 Main St. Phone 527-0770 Seaforth Fax 527-2600 SEE US TODAY FOR YOUR RENTAL EQUIPMENT! SI LC HOME HARDWARE SUPPLIES FOR THE HANDYMAN Bottled Water Refill Station • Plumbing • Heating • Electrical • Paint CARPET CLEANER RENTAL FIRE EXTINGUISHER Service & Re -Charge Depot GLASS & SCREEN REPAIR For All Your Hardware Needs Main St., SEAFORTH 527-1620 Visa, NC, Noma Card, AM Express, Interact McKILLOP MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 91 Main St. South, Seaforth Office 527-0400 1-800-463-9204 Fax 527-2777 HOME, COMMERCIAL FARM, AUTO COVERAGES Bob McNaughton 527-1571 Gratme Craig 887-9381 Donald Taylor 482-9976 Banter. MacEwan & Feagan Insurance Brokers Ltd. 524-8376 Gaiser Kneale Insurance Brokers Inc. 482-3401 Thames Ins. Brokers Cockwell Insurance Brokers Ltd. 235-2211 356-2216 ADVERTISING is not an expense IT'S AN INVESTMENT [ ��$:�,3S3Tit:d4.3X3Ct+2.•-.• -.• ..'teg6i', JANSEN MASONRY Pete 522-0614 Harry 527-2691 Pete Sr. 522-0206 Brick • Block • Stone Rleti►rokomon WORK ServUy The Area Pb, Over 33 "here Seaforth, Ontario Advertise 365 Days a Year Coll .527-0240 HAY'S AUTOMOBILE RECONDITIONING •Interior Shampooing •Vinyl and Fabric Protector •Exterior Buffing and Hand Wax *Engine Shampooing •3 Year Shine Guarantee Bill Hay Hensen, Ont. Pion: 2823342 BOX & SMITH FUNERAL CHAPEL "We are dedicated to your confidence" at 47 High St. Seaforth 527-1142 - Office 522-0360 - Res. CHRISTOPHER M. SMITH Funeral Director Seaforth Agricultural Society • BANQUET & MEETING FACILITIES • 10,000 sq. feet of indoor show area See what we have to offer Call 527-1321 Today! EACH R RENTAL 3 Units apacity 22 PEAK FOUR SEASONS REALTY LTD. , REALTOR www.peakrealestate.com Thinking of Buying a Home or Cottage? Thinking of Selling a Home or Cottage? Call us...(519) 565-5951 1 Highway #21, Bayfield (next 'to Harbour Restaurant) Independently Owned and Operated Bill MacLennan Broker DAVITS ACCOUNTING SERVICES ACCOUNTING & TAX PREPARATION Farm,Business, Personal & Corporate 527-1063 '1'11OMPSON URETHANE SPRAY .'' FIBREGLASS 1 N SITi./I'1'iON Cally Ron At 519-263-2319 Dr. LJ. Laplante OPTOMETRIST 527.1240 87 Main St., Seaforth HOURS Monday CLOSED Tuesday 9:00 - 12:00 1:00 - 5:30 Wednesday 9:00 - 12:00 1:00 - 5:30 Thursday 9:00 - 12:00 1:00 - 5:30 6:30 - 9:00 Friday 9:00 - 12:00 1:00 - 5:30 Sat. & Sun. CLOSED B.W. SEAMLESS EAVESTROUGHING Siding, Soffit, Fascia Leaf Screening BARRY WILLERT ZURICH • 236-7741 "9tee � ,,t .era ea rr Elli�sen ELECTRIC LIMITED FARM • NOME • COMMERCIAL • POLE LINES • STANDBY SYSTEMS (519)345.2447 R.R#4 WALTON, ONT. KKN BUILDERS INC. ALL KINDS OF SITE WORK & CONCRETE WORK •Excavator Complete Foundations •6 -way Dozer •Slatted or solid floors •Trucking •Bunk silos •Float Service •Sandwich Walls •Demolition •Farm Work Renovations •Concrete Driveways Fritz Klaver Dublin 345-2042 WHITNEY•RIBEY FUNERAL HOME CEMETERY MONUMENTS ROSS W. RIBEY DIRECTOR 87 Goderich St., Seaforth 527-1390 Pre -planned and Pre -Arranged Funeral Services Available Sincere and Courteous Service CCM CUCUITI DL Ltd. R.1t. 1ti`3MUNI 348-8901 'Quality ready mix •Rod's dispatched unit •6 day delivery Porn. corn Fndoy for Even.ngs Cali LUKE 348-8303 or CLEM 348-9658 HURON -PERTH Refrigeration and Appliance Service eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee mines oTo advertise o BUSflo S v DIRECTORY... E Call Bernie or Tom v o at 527-0240 v OGooGGGflGOGOGGOGoODDffi HILDEBRAND PAINT & PAPER Expert. Interior and Exterior Decorators PAINTS & WALLCOVERINGS 527-1880 1111 Main St Seaforth REM glkip q,,,, * Agricultural * Residential * Commercial * Pole Line Construction Pcsoddt k/s1son L. MC.GRATH PLUMBING and HEATING Inc. SEAFORTH 522-0493 Larry McGrath Licenced Plumber & Licenced Gas Fitter Call Today! Installation Service Repairs ELECTRIC R.R. #4 Seaforth, Ont. NOK 1WO 519 .522-1556 W.D. HOP ER & SOSN"'gnat • FARMS • RESIDENTIAL • INDUSTRIAL • COTTAGES • 5 MODERN ROTARY RIGS • LICENCED BY MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT. FREE ESTIMATES CALL COLLECT NEIL 522-1737 DURL 271-7860 "Where hopper goes the water flows" KEECON-PLUS DRYWALL SERVICES Drywalling - Taping - Texturing - Restorations MARK MELADY 527-2799 SEW AND SAVE CENTRE LIMITED Sewing Machine and Serger Specialists Repairs to all makes •FREE ESTIMATES •ALL WORK GUARANTEED SALES Janome, Juki, Babylock, Omega Machines LOTS OF USED MACHINES Z 149 Downie St. 1113 (Beside Hudson's Dept Store) STRATFORD 271.9660 Seaforth Veterinary Clinic Open Thursday Evenings by Appointment Only! Dr. Brian Nuhn 527-1760 Main St. North, Seaforth Office Hours MON. TO FRI. 8 AM to 5:30 PM THURS. EVENING BY APPT. ONLY SAT. 8 AM to 12 NOON