HomeMy WebLinkAboutHuron Expositor, 2001-10-17, Page 4Letters
Opinion
6
Your Community Newspaper Since 1860
Tom Williscralt - Publisher Scott Hilgendorff - Editor
Dianne McGrek - Subxriplions/(lassilieds Bernie Pugh Office/Sales
Susan Hundertmark - Reporter Anne Roden - Distribution
ill°SJn/a.14Sx. Adam Corjw.ewe - A QueIrcor Gnpa.i
F-,rsnil lit est srar,irtahehnwocnwt earn
Visit our home poge at www.seaforthhuronexpositor.com
SUBSCRIP ON RATES: LOCAL - 32.50 a year, in advance, plus 2.28 G.S.T.
,SENIORS: - 30.00 a year, in advance, plus 2.10 G.S.T.
USA & Foreign. 28.44 a year in advance, plus $78.00 postage, G.S.T. exempt
*t1BSCRIPTON RATES:
Published weekly by Sngnol-Star Publishing at 11 Main St., Seaforth. Publication
mail registration No. 0696 held at Seaforth, Ontario. Advertising is accepted on
condition Cot in the event of a typographical error, the advertising space occupied
by the erroneous item, together with a reasonable allowance kr signature, will not
be charged, but the balance of the advertisement will be paid for at the applicable
rale. In the event of a typographical error, odvertising goods or services at o
wrong price, goods or services may not be sold. Advertising is merely an offer to
sell and may be withdrawn at ony time. The Huron Expositor is not responsible for
the loss or damage of unsolicited manuscripts, photos or other materials used for
reproduction purposes. Changes of address, orders for subscriptions and
undeliverable copies are to be sent to The Huron Expositor.
Publication Mail Registration No. 07605
Wednesday, October 17, 2001
•dlterial end Mshess Offices - 11 Mala atreet.,foafortii
Allophone (519) 537-0340 Fax (519) 537-2S511
Mailiry Address - P.O. Sox 69,
foaiorli�, Ontario, NOK 1 WO
Bowes Publishers Limited
Member of the Canadian Community
Newspaper Association, Ontario Community
Newspapers Association
"We the financial support of the Government of
Canada, through the Publications Assistance Program (PAP),
toward our mailing costs."
Editorial
Fight to save
schools may
have beenlost
two years ago
Next week, the community will be one step
closer to again knowing the fate of its high school.
Slated for closure once before, the community
fought and, through court, managed to overturn
the Avon Maitland District School Board's plans to
close the high school.
Board members and staff have been careful
now for months not to refer to the process as part
of one that will close schools. You can label it or
call it whatever you want but one woman at a
past community study committee meeting was
right when she came to the sudden realization
they were already fighting for their schools
through a series of meetings held this summer.
Those meetings were held in response to the
court ruling of more than a year ago to help make
the process more fair to the individual
communities by seeking input and asking for
recommendations about how the board should
handle dropping enrolment to ensure proper
government funding.
But the intent of the meetings feels hollow when
they followed the receipt of a report this spring
from consultants that the board immediately
downplayed that listed Seaforth District High
School and several other schools for possible
closure.
The' meetings help ensure the board has
crossed more "T"s and dotted more "1"s in
ensuring the courts, should there be another
challenge of any future board decisions, that it
truly was fair to the communities this time by
including them in the decision-making process.
But it remains to be seen whether or not the
board truly listens to a recommendation from the
local committee to move the Grade 7s and 8s into
both Seaforth District High School and Central
Huron Secondary School in Clinton.
Meanwhile, some of the other area committees
outside the Seaforth area, seem to be pushing for
superschools taking in students from `pwns
outside their area.
The odds appear to be stacking against the high
school again with community members who are
growing weary of the fight to keep the high
school.
While board members and staff may say they
have the students at heart in their decisions, it
remains a dollars and cents issue that outweighs
the logical needs of keeping a high school in a
community.
Whether a community has a right to a high
school no longer matters. Only the dollars and
cents count.
The real fight may have been lost two years
ago. That's when communities and school boards
failed to come together and look past their
individual school closure issues to collectively fight
the provincial government and its messed up
funding formula that applies best to Toronto
schools but leaves smaller communities faced
with losing theirs.
Scott Hilgendorff
Curling club
seeks historical
information
To the Editor:
In 1876 the "Seaforth Curling
Club" was formed and on
November 17, 2001 the club is
celebrating its 125th anniversary.
Is there anyone out there that can
help put together a bit of history for
our celebration? I would appreciate
any information you may have.
if so, please contact Irma Pryce at
527-0917.
Irma Pryce
Trustee upset board downplaying issue
surrounding how students are counted
The Board is already at
the 24.5 maximum average
elementary class size. There
is little room to absorb the
1,017 students into other
chives. The foregoing is
why' I brought a "notice of
motion" before the Board
this past Sept. 25 to set the
Board's system
accommodation loading
target at 85 per cent to 90
per cent, a loading level that
was not long ago referred to
by the Ministry of
Education as "optimum"
Our board is currently at
about 85 per cent.
My notice of motion gave
trustees a full two weeks to
consult with me as to my
reasoning. This is far longer
than trustees are given on
Soo STUDENTS, Page 5
To the Editor:
For several months now
some of my fellow Avon
Maitland District School
Board trustees have had
regular appearances on the
editorial pages of local
newspapers. Following that
lead I am compelled to also
make my views known to
the public.
Speaking for myself and
not the board, it is clear that
the district -wide student
enrollment loading goal
should not be at or near 100
per cent full time equivalent
()•
Junior kindergarten and
senior kindergarten students
only count as one half FTE
each. This is because they
attend school for only half
days. This may very well be
an appropriate "counting"
for other purposes but
clearly should not be used in
any determination of how
full our schools are since,
while those youngest
students are in the schools,
entire children, not half
children need to be
accommodated.
There are about 2,033
kindergarten students across
the Avon Maitland system.
If the board chooses to fill
our schools to 100 per cent
on a FTE basis it would
mean that in the portion of
the day that kindergarten
students are in the schools
there would be half of that
number, ie: 1017 children
over capacity in those
schools.
I believe that because of
the differences in the
numbers of students from
grade to grade in all schools
that overcrowding in a 100
per cent loaded elementary
system would be even worse
than the overcrowding
created by kindergarten
students alone.
At the ministry -mandated
average maximum class size
of 24.5 the extra 1,017
students could mean up to
42 portables being added to
the system, since existing
permanent accommodation
must be eliminated from the'
system to achieve the 100
per cent loading.
The public is well -aware
of the many factors that
make portable classrooms
an undesirable form of
student accommodation.
Picky eating leads to lesson on life in Afghanistan
A joke that circulated my office last
week really disturbed me.
While I won't repeat the whole thing,
the gist of it was that following a genie -
granted wish made by Osama bin Laden
to enclose Afghanistan with an high
impenetrable wall, he was outsmarted
by "Uncle Sam's" wish that the
enclosed country then be filled with
water.
I guess it's human nature to lump
together groups of people you fear and
name them your enemies. I guess it's
human nature to then hate your
enemies. And, I guess it's human nature
to ridicule and ill -wish them.
But, what disturbed me most was the
idea that wiping out a whole country,
7.5 million of which are starving
refugees camping along their borders in
By Susan Hundertmark
hopes of escaping death by war,
disease, exposure or starvation, was
somehow funny or even desirable.
Westerners are justifiably filled with
grief, horror and outrage at the recent
terrorist attacks. But, the all -so -
predictable human response to react
with the desire to inflict more and
greater pain on someone else fills me
with a deep sadness.
And, the all -so -predictable Western
response of failing to appreciate that no
matter how bad we have it, the greater
percentage of the human population has
it worse, fills me with sadness and
anger.
The generosity of North Americans
raising money for disaster relief
following the terrorist attacks in New
York and Washington is laudable.
I watched American TV celebrities,
like Rosie O'Donnell, pledging $1
million out of her vast fortune for
disaster relief in the U.S. and
challenging other celebrities to do the
same out of their vast fortunes during
the days following the attack.
But, as a friend recently pointed out
to me, the Afghans need it more and her
family has sent a donation to an
international relief organization like
World Vision.
Along with bombs, the U.S.
government is also dropping relief
packages into the air space over
Soo DROPPED, Page 5
McLean recovers from attack of typhoid fever
October 20,1876
Our townsmen Messrs. A.
G. Dougall and J. C.
Laidlaw, returned home from
their summer trip.
The former visited
England and France, and the
latter, his home country,
Scotland.
The numerous readers of
this paper and the many
personal friends of M. Y.
McLean of the Expositor,
will be pleased to learn that
he is recovering from an
attack of typhoid fever,
which has confined him to
bed for the past four weeks.
The contractors of the
works at the Egmondville
bridge have now finished
and the business men are
rejoicing at the increased
business derived from the
resumption of the southern
trade.
Alex Wright of McKillop
has rented his farm of 112
acres on the 13th concession
to Edw. MacNamara for one
year. He pays a rental of
$300.
Mr. Alex McEwan of Hay
Twp., sold at the Seaforth
show last week, his one year
old colt to James Irvine of
Tuckersmith for $200.
October 18th, 1901
A young son of John G.
Grieve of McKillop had a
very close call a few days
ago. He was putting the•
horse in the stable, and while
passing one of them it
kicked, striking him in the
eye. No bones were broken
and the eye was not
permanently injured.
As a threshing machine
was at work on the farm of
Thomas Adams, in
McKillop, a sheaf f wheat
was going through the
machine, there was a loud
report, like the explosion of
a cartridge. The sheaf was
in a blaze but the men were
able to stomp out the fire.
Geo. Henderson of
McKillop, has a freak of
nature. This is a young pig
with 6 feet.
• J. B. Foster's new brick
house at Zurich is being
Years agone...
rapidly pushed towards
completion.
The Catholic Church in
Zurich is nearing completion
and will be a credit to the
congregation.
The Leadbury hotel
buildings were destroyed and
Mr. Jones just escaped in his
night clothes.
Messrs. James Scott and
D. C. Wilson of this town,
leased a tract of land in
Tuckersmith for the purpose
of forming a game reserve.
Over 32,000 square feet of
granolithic sidewalk has
been put down in town at a
cost of $3,423.
Messrs. F. Holmsted, W.
O. Reid, A. Young and John
Weir, were doing the Pan -
America this week.
Messrs. Scott Bros. of
town sent a very nice organ
to the County Home of
Refuge.
Miss Bessie Young left
last week for Boston to
pursue her studies at the
College of Elocution there.
The first snow storm fell
on Thursday. The ground
was white with the beautiful
snow.
F. C. Hamilton, popular
citizen of Cromarty, will
move to Galt, where he has
an interest in a shoe
business.
J. J. Irvine of Leadbury
has completed teaming 2000
bushels of grain to Seaforth.
It is reported that Albert
Dundas has purchased the 50
acre farm of Samuel Dickson
in McKillop.
October 15,1956
Fred Eckart, Manley,
treated himself to a new Star
car.
The following in this
week's standing in the Pony
contest, Edwin Hawkins;
Chas Bateman; Frank
Grieve; Tom Sills; Andy
Calder; Sterling Habkirk;
Mickey Archibald; Dorothy
Wiltse; Geo. Crich; Loretta
Purcell; Jean Gemmell;
Douglas Stewart; Wilson
Broadfoot; Frank Phillips;
Ruth Gorden; Leo. Joynt;
Bobbie Venner; Jean
Dungey; Mary Cronin; C. G.
Sherwood; Clara Krauskopf;
Gordon McKellar; McKellar
Margaret; Merner Bordin.
The McDonnell Chevrolet
Co. of Hensall and the Lorne
Tractor Co. of Ingersoll have
placed one of their combined
chemical and fire fighting
engines in Hensall on a
Chevrolet truck.
The many friends of Dr. R.
P. I. Dougall are pleased to
learn that he is improving
nicely from an operation and
will be in his office this
week.
J. B. Henderson of
Seaforth, brought into the
Expositor Office a potato
grown in his garden. It
consists of one large potato
and three others growing
from it and from these 8
others are growing.
Last Saturday word was
received in Zurich that the
barn on the farm of Paul
Masse, Bronson Line, was
on fire and many of the
villagers hurried to the
scene. The buildings and the
contents were doomed as it
had gained too much
headway.
October 12th, 1951
Edward C. Milliken of
Millbank and formerly of
Seaforth graduated in Honor
Business Administration
from the University of
Western Ontario.
Mr. and Mrs. James Nash
of McKillop were host to a
gathering of friends of
Florence Murray, bride elect.
A basket of miscellaneous
gifts was presented to Miss
Murray by Veronica Lane.
Don Eastman had the
misfortune to fall out of a
tree breaking his arm at the
elbow.
Thos. Pryde of Exeter was
chosen as the Progressive
Conservative candidate in
the coming election at a
convention held in Hensall.
Douglas Stewart, son of
Mr. and Mrs. Jas. A. Stewart,
won the essay contest
sponsored by the Seaforth
Lions Club. The title of the
contest was "What our
hospital means to the
community."
Students of the Seaforth
District High School were
winners in the Senior High
School match at the North
Huron plowing match at
Cranbrook. They were
Douglas Keyes, Glen Nixon,
Elgin Schade.
Robert Dayman of
Tuckersmith has sold his
farm to Joseph Lostelle of
near Kippen.
A pleasant afternoon was
spent at the home of Mr. and
Mrs. John Davidson of
Constance when Mrs.
Davidson entertained in
honor of her mother, Mrs. R.
Lawson, who marked her
84th birthday.
Miss Helen Elizabeth
Maloney of Seaforth, and
Regis Aubin also of
Seaforth, were united in
marriage by Rev. E. R.
Weber.
The Salvation Army
Officer's quarters are at
present undergoing minor
improvements.
October 21, 1976
A ditch south of
Egmondville on the Kippen
Road was full of corn for
awhile Friday afternoon,
after a truck carrying a full
load of corn tipped over after
colliding with a tractor
driven by Arnold Van
Miltenburg. Driver of the
truck, owned by Vern
Alderdice, was David Lovell
of R. R. 2 Kippen. Ray
Primeau of the Goderich
OPP said damages were
about $400 and there were
no serious injuries.
St. Andrews Church,
Kippen, celebrated their
109th Anniversary Service
on Sunday, October 17 with
an inspiring address by Rev.
Harold Snell of Exeter who
spoke on "looking ahead."