The Huron Expositor, 1995-02-22, Page 1wEllxurpon •�it()it()
70 cents
plus 5 cents G.S.T.
(75 cents)
SCHOOLS
What could
be more fun
than a
carnival?
Dublin
pulls out
all the
stops.
see pages 5, 14.
Briefly
Seaforth says
'Yes' to OPP
Seaforth Council ' made its
approval of Ontario Provincial
Police Service official on Feb.
14.
Seaforth Council had already
approved OPP service in prin-
ciple but last Tuesday it went
ahead and passed a formal resol-
ution drafted by the OPP.
Posts were
erected to stop
snowmobiles
A local homeowner placed
steel posts in front of their home
in an effort to prevent
snowmobilers from driving on
the sidewalk, according to the
minutes of Seaforth's Transpor-
tation and Environment Commit-
tee.
No one should be permitted to
place anything on town property
without the town's permission,
according to the minutes.
Town sewage rate
Sewer service charges for the
Town of Seaforth in 1995 have
increased from $121,126 to
$140,483.
The PUC monthly sewage rate
will increase from $13.97 per
month to $15.40, effective
March 1.
Hensall woman
killed in collision
A 43 -year-old Hensall woman
is dead and a 37 -year-old
Dashwood man remains under
intensive care as a result of a
car -van collision near Ingersoll
last week.
Two others were critically
injured in the accident, which
occurred on Highway 19
between Woodstock and
Ingersoll around 6:40 a.m.
Woodstock OPP report a north-
bound vehicle driven by Gordon '
Hobson, 38, of Ingersoll was
attempting to pass a transport
truck when it collided with a
southbound van, driven by
Robert Reschke, 37, of
Dashwood.
Wendy Campbell, 42 of Exeter
was pronounced dead at the
scene. Funeral services for
Campbell were held Saturday,
February 18 in Exeter. She is
survived by her husband Gary
Campbell and children Tracy and
Darren Moir of Hensall and
Derek Campbell at home.
Police said Monday that
Reschke, who was listed in
critical condition after the acci-
dent, was still in the intensive
care unit at Hamilton General
Hospital.
Heather Eifert, 43, of Huron
Park, another passenger in the
van is in Victoria Hospital in
London, where her condition had
been upgraded from critical to
serious.
Hobson was listed in critical
condition in University Hospital.
Woodstock OPP Constable
Andy Doughty said police are
still looking for witnesses to the
accident, particularly the driver
of the transport truck.
Entertainment...
page 14.
Sports...page 9.
Letters...page 4.
"Your community
newspaper since
7860...serving Seaforth,
Dublin, Hensall, Walton,
Brussels and surrounding
communities."
1'
The Huron Expositor, Seaforth, Ontario, February 22, 1995
This Space
Could Be
Yours
Call Terri or Mary
527-0240
Investment
and
Tax Planning
"Seaforth
RRSP
Specialists"
11:11r2vesimertGentre
96 Main St., Seaforth 527-0420
GREGOR CAMPBELI. PHOTO
SHARP SHOOTER - Dublin -area native Rem Murray of MSU is one of U.S. college hockey's best
players. Mike Watt of Egmondville and Ron Mason, who grew up in town, give the Spartans a distinctive
Seaforth flavour in the hockey -mad East Lansing area of Michigan. See page 9 for details.
What is it
like to be
a small-town
doctor? A
London,:'
medical ;s _
student
finds out .
see
sae three
PUC names site of
new water tower
The Seaforth Public Utility
Commission has decided it wants to
put its proposed new water tower
on Brantford Street near Sparling,
and letters informing residents in
the affected area of the decision
have been sent.
Manager Tom Phillips says this
final phase of an environmental
assessment involves a formal 30 -
day notice period, but the site the
commission prefers is zoned
properly and can be tied into future
options easier, if and when funding
for construction becomes available.
Public meetings came earlier in
the screening process for three
prospective sites: the Brantford
Steet site on town property, at the
Seaforth and District Community
Centres and northeast of the
Seaforth Medical Clinic Building.
Among other things, the new
tower would be bigger and provide
greater and more uniform water
pressure throughout Seaforth.
Manager Phillips also told PUC
commissioners at their Feb. 8
regular meeting Ontario Hydro has
approved their capital works budget
of $175,000 for 1995, $100,000 of
which is earmarked for the Welsh
Street transformer station upgrade.
Commissioners were told earlier
in the meeting that the preliminary
engineering study to upgrade the
Welsh station to 5 MVA cost
$6,000, with the expected cost of
new switching gear approximately
$50,000.
No report has yet been received
on the PUC's other transformer
stationed on Chalk Street which
was damaged by vandals in late
December. It is still in Burlington
being accessed and an auxiliary unit
on loan continues to provide power.
The PUC manager spent
considerable time at February's
meeting updating commissioners on
the Municipal Electrical
Association's task force stance on
restructuring electrical service in
this province, which resolved the
industry should not be privatized
but Ontario Hydro split into three
separate entities for generation,
transmission and distribution. The
Seaforth PUC has four votes on the
issue at the MEA's annual meeting
in Toronto Feb. 26 to 28.
• The manager also kept
commissioners abreast of an
important retail rate study
concerning the MEA and Ontario
Hydro, and reported on various
seminars, meetings and
correspondence.
Th. vocal PUC is also costing a
fax machine on a trial basis, and
has received a registered easement
to allow for future water and power
for Lot 1 at the Munn's Bush
development.
Seaforth Deputy -Reeve opposes
landfill board decision
Seaforth Deputy -Reeve Bill Teall
said he was disappointed with a
recent decision of the Mid -Huron
Landfill Site board not to change
engineers.
The board re -appointed Conestoga
Rovers as engineering firm despite
the fact the local tender from B. M.
Ross of Goderich was $2,900 less
over three years.
Teall said representatives from the
municipalities of Clinton and
Tuckersmith were not at the meet-
ing when the decision was made.
Stanley residents differ on development proposal
13Y TIM CUMMING
Expositor Editor
A proposed development in Stan-
ley Township would ruin the rural
character of the township and pro-
vide menial jobs at best, some
residents said on Wednesday even-
ing.
Supporters of the Stone Lea Hold-
ings proposal, a large farm for
horses combined with a residential
development, said it offered Stanley
the hope for a brighter future. They
argued it would create much-needed
jobs for the young people of Stan-
ley.
More than 120 people attended
the public meeting at the Stanley
Township Complex near Varna and
many stood up to speak passionate-
ly on opposing sides.
Some opponents of the plan said
that farming is a viable industry and
a 100 -name petition was submitted
in opposition. The development
would create conflicts between the
interests of the farm and non-farm
residents, they told the meeting.
Stanley Township resident Leisa
Stephenson said the recreational
development didn't fit an agricul-
tural zoning. She also said the
council should not make a decision
without the completion of an envi-
ronmental study.
"How can you make an informed
decision without the information
necessary to make a decision?"
asked Stephenson. She agreed that
Stanley needed some kind of devel-
opment but that the Stone Lea
projcct wasn't the proper use of
land.
"Why should we take more agri-
cultural land out of use for building
lots?" she asked. "Our township has
a distinct rural flavour, we would
like to preserve this for future gen-
erations."
The jobs provided by Stone Lea
would be tow -paying and 'menial',
argued Abby Armstrong, who spoke
against the development.
Bev Hill, a lifelong Stanley resi-
dent and participant in Stone Lea,
said land is the main natural
resource Stanley has to offer.
"We are essentially a one -industry
Liability costs increase
town insurance rates
The increasing cost of lawsuits is
driving up the price of liability
insurance for Seaforth.
Seaforth Council was told on Feb.
14 its insurance costs would rise
about 30 per cent, almost entirely
because of liability costs.
Last year's insurance costs have
increased from $29,000 to about
540,548 this year.
"What's driving the premium is
the cost of the claims," said Randy
Fisher, of Frank Cowan Company
Ltd. at the Feb. 14 meeting of
Seaforth Council.
One of the issues which arose
was Bill 163 which, in rart, con-
cerns municipal conflict of interest.
In the past insurance claims were
paid for councillors whose conflict
of interest was a "bona fide error in
judgement" but that is changing.
"The act has taken out the grey
arca which used to be there," said
Fisher.
The premium for Seaforth
includes the town's coverage for
joint boards such as the arena and
fire boards, for which the town
receives contributions from other
municipalities.
town," he said.
There are economic forces beyond
the control of local people, argued
Hill, and as the farm industry
becomes more rationalized there
will be even further reliance on off -
farm income.
"Hopefully some of that income
can be generated through our com-
munity."
He said it is the developers' intent
to complete the project with local
ownership and control. It was bet-
ter, Hill argued, for local people to
develop the area.
"It is not realistic to think we can
build a wall around our river val-
ley," he said. "We can't expect
people to come here, spend their
money and go home."
The daughter of former Reeve
Anson McKinley, Karen Ratcliffe,
said she had been able to return to
Stanley Township. She wanted
future generations to also have the
opportunity to return.
Agencies give plan rocky ride
The proposal for a commercial
horse farm with accompanying
residences in Stanley Township
faced a rocky ride from government
agencies.
In a detailed four-page response
the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture
and Food said the proposal violates
several criteria of the Food Land
Guidelines.
The Ministry's concern was not
with the creation of a horse farm
but with the accompanying residen-
tial buildings. If the developers
want to create residences they
should be located in an urban area,
said Sharon Johnston, District
Manger.
"The residential development does
not require a rural setting," she said
in a letter. "Such a use can be more
suitably accommodated in settle-
ments areas such as the Village of
Bayfield or the Town of Goderich."
In the Ministry's response
Johnston also said the separation
distance between the proposed
homes and livestock barns is less
than what is required by the Agri-
cultural Code of Practice.
The Ausable-Bayfield Conserva-
tion Authority said in its statements
that the potential impact on the
Bayfield River Valley would have
to be studied prior to giving appro-
val.
"We feel that the information
provided thus far addresses the
market feasibility, jtot the environ-
mental feasibility of the develop-
ment," said Patrick Donnelly, Sen-
ior Planner.
The conservation agency
requested more information and
possibly more amendments to the
plan before Stanley Council
approves Official Plan and Zoning
amendments to allow the develop-
ment.
Ontario's Ministry of Natural
Resources (MNR) raised serious
concerns that the development
would threaten fish habitat and
water quality. Other concerns
included the potential of increased
nitrate levels in receiving waters,
reduction of available groundwater,
disturbance of rare and endangered
species and loss of hunting and
fishing opportunities.
An Environmental Impact Study
should be completed before appro-
val is given to the zoning and Offi-
cial Plan amendments, said the
MNR.
"This application appears to be
somewhat premature in nature with-
out the sqpport of background envi-
ronmental study to support the
location and boundaries," the
MNR's letter states.
The Township of Goderich
expressed concerns with the project
pnor to the meeting.
"This appears to be an attempt to
allow for urban development on
prime agricultural land," said
Suzanne Vodden, Clerk -Treasurer,
in a letter.
The Huron County planning
department says the residences and
the farm would have to be legally
tied together.
"The Planning and Development
Department is not fundamentally
opposed to the proposed concept
provided that it is strongly oriented
to agriculture," said Scott Tousaw,
Senior Planner.
The planning department, how-
ever, said six issues need to be
addressed:
1. Compatibility with local com-
munity.
2. Necessity for the large number of
proposed on-site dwellings and
phasing.
3. Market demand for such dwell-
ings.
4. Legal connection between the
houses and the horse farm.
5. Ability to be serviced by com-
munal facilities.
6. Assessment of effects on the
natural environment.
The Huron County engineer
expressed no objections in principle
to the development.
The Township of Hay expressed
no objections to the proposal. There
was also no objection from the
Huron County Board of Education,
the Huron County Highways
Department and the Huron County
Plumbing and Environment Depart-
ment.
see Seize, next page