Village Squire, 1975-03, Page 4The three members
from Western Ontario
It's a tough task taking on The Big Blue Machine,
the bureaucrats, and the time clock
If a dozen years ago someone had
suggested I'd be sitting in a deserted
diningroom of a Huron county hotel having
coffee with three local Members of the
Provincial Legislature all of whom were
Liberals, he'd probably be laughed out of the
province.
After all, Ontario was a Tory province, had
been for more than 20 years and seemed
likely to remain so. And western Ontario,
particularly the Huron, Perth, Bruce county
area was as Tory blue as you'd ever get.
•But the subtle change in the public opinion
in the area began to become apparent in
October of 1962. John Hanna, who had held
the Huron -Bruce riding for longer than some
younger people could remember, died and
the riding was up for grabs. The
Conservatives named George McCutcheon of
Brussels, a former Huron county warden and
a man who appeared to be in a good position
to continue the Conservative reign in the
riding.
The Liberals nominated a young man who
was a former Queen's Guinefts winner in 4H
work, a graduate of the University of Guelph
and who was widely known as the farm editor
at CKNX television.
In an area where elections had been
foregone conclusions for many years, an
exciting election race suddenly erupted. The
result was a speaker, and a bit of a shocker.
The young liberal, Murray Gaunt, pulled an
upset, though a close one. The result was
even closer in 1973 when a regular general
election took place and McCutcheon again
challenged. But in the end, after recounts,
Gaunt won.
That same 1963 general election saw a
young Mitchell businessman, Hugh Edig-
hogger take his first stab at provincial
politics. It seemed a hopeless case. Here was
a young inexperienced Liberal against Fred
Edwards of Palmerston who had held the
Perth riding for nearly 20 years. In 1963 it
WAS a hopeless task, but Edighoffer wasn't
discouraged and tried again in 1967. This
time the impossible was accomplished and
Hugh Edighoffer was the new member of
Parliament.
The most recent upset is still fresh in the
2, VILLAGE SQUIRE/MARCH 1975
minds of many in the area. Long-time cabinet
minister Charles McNaughton decided to
retire to the security of a past on the Ontario
Racing Commission. It seemed to be almost a
routine.matter for a handover of power to his
executive assistant Don Southcott, a former
Exeter newspaper publisher. •Southcott had
been being groomed for the position for
several years. There were even rumours that
a cabinet post waited in the wings for him. He
was heir apparent from the day of the first
announcement of MacNaughton that he
would retire.
The Liberals, meanwhile, were going
through their usual act of trying to pull a
candidate out of the hat. The platform on the
nomination night in Hensall, was nearly as
crowded as the public school auditorium,
which was packed. There were plenty of
candidates, but none was well-known. One
stood out. He had an organized campaign that
had signs plastered around the auditorium.
He spoke confidently while the others seemed
hesitant. His voice boomed out so that the
microphones were hardly needed. His name
was Jack Riddell but many present didn't
even know how to pronounce the name (as in
riddle) let alone know much about the man.
His press material said he was a school
teacher and part-time businessman. He made
an impressive showing, so that it was obvious
from the start he would be the winner of the
nomination but it seemed too much to expect
this virtual -unknown to come close to the
smooth, professionally polished Don South-
cott. And there was also the fact that young
Paul Carroll, a Goderich school teacher
running for the N.D.P. was likely to split the
anti-government vote.
But between nomination night and election
night, something mysterious happened.
There was obviously a large amount of
discontent in the riding over the govern-
ment's policies of centralization in both
education and municipal reorganization. But
Riddell seemed to have a certain charisma
that attracted friends wherever he went. For
him everything went right.
For Don Southcott, meanwhile, everything
went wrong. Typical was the fact that when
Premier Davis and a group of representatives
of the Big Blue Machine flew into Goderich
airport to lend support to Southcott, the plane
skidded off -the icy runway and into a snow
bank where it sat for several weeks before it
could be repaired.
The campaign went on and the rumours of
upset grew. But no one was brave enough to
predict the eventual result: a 300 -vote
majority for the Liberal in a riding that had
gone Conservative by 6,000 votes in the
previous election.
The victory, coupled with another the same
night in Toronto by Margaret Campbell in
another former Tory riding bouyed up the
Liberal party and -persuaded Robert Nixon to
stay on as party leader. Two subsequent
by-elections saw another Liberal win and one
by .the N.D.P. The Liberals started to see
themselves as possible winners of an election
expected this year, and the Conservatives
started feeling their necks for the first time in
30 years.
But back to the men who have turned solid
Tory support in midwestern Ontario into solid
Opposition territory. We're having coffee in a
Clinton hotel diningroom in mid-morning a
week after the perrogation of the Legislature.
They're joking back and forth the way
students do after vacation. They're compar-
ing notes on hints of wherti the budget may
come down.
What, I asked them, was the hardest thing
to adjust to on going from being an ordinary
member of society to being a member of
Parliament.
"1 think the most difficult thing for me,"
Mr. Gaunt began, "was the learning process.
You're thrust into the situation where all of a
sudden you have people coming to you to look
after constituency problems of one nature or
another and you've got to be able to get the
the answer and you've got to know the people
whom you have to go within the government
and you've also got to learn the procedures in
the House. You've got to get the feel of 'the
system.' It really took me about two years
before I felt at home.
"If you have a problem with Workmen"s
Compensation, for instance, it took a while to
know who to go to. It was a trial and error
kind of thing."