The Rural Voice, 1983-07, Page 62PERTH COUNTY PORK PRODUCERS' NEWS
Pork Producers discuss
animal welfare movement
A high degree of interest in the animal
welfare movement was demonstrated by
the large number of North Zone county
directors who attended a special meeting
in Mitchell called by the Perth County
Pork Producers Association. Richard
Smelski, OMAF Swine Specialist,
chaired the meeting and introduced
special guest speakers Dr. Frank Hurnik,
U. of Guelph Animal Behaviorist and
Cedric Harrop from the OPPMB.
Dr. Hurnik told the directors that
history is a very good teacher and can
help to predict the future. The animal
welfare movement got started in England
after Ruth Harrison published her book
"Animal Machines: The New Factory
Farming Industry". Within a few years
legislation was passed in many European
countries requiring that all animals have
the right to five basic freedoms to (1) get
up, (2) lie down, (3) turn around, (4)
groom itself and (5) stretch the limbs.
Hurnik believes, however, that educa-
tion, not legislation is the best method of
changing people's behavior. For this
reason he is willing to meet with
livestock producers to share his know-
ledge of animal behavior and to explain
the animal welfare movement. He says
that any good swine manager will have
no problem conforming with the volun-
tary code of practice and will have
nothing to fear from the animal welfar-
ists.
He warned the producers that they
should get their own houses in order so
that animal welfarists will have nothing
to complain about. In his opinion, the
pork producers are taking an intelligent
and enlightened approach to the welfarist
movement. This is not the case with the
producers of white veal, which is the area
where the welfarists are beginning to
concentrate their efforts.
Hurnik says there are three possible
responses to the animal welfare move-
ment. One, ignore them, do nothing and
hope they will go away. Two, fight the
issue through the media and TV. Or
three, invite people to your farm and
explain how farmers work and how well
they treat their animals.
"The animal welfare movement is an
insidious cancer rapidly growing within
our midst and it is not going to go away,"
Cedric Harrop, director from the OPPMB,
PG. 60 THE RURAL VOICE, JULY 1983
told the county directors. "Any pork
producer who thinks it is a waste of time
for the OPPMB to develop a volunteer
code of practice should watch the city
papers for reports on the activities of the
extremists in the movement --- I call them
humaniacs." He went on to say that
some animal welfare groups have over
200,000 members and are beginning to
influence the election of candidates to
political office.
A few years ago Agriculture Canada
decided to finance a special committee
made up of representatives from pro-
ducer organizations, veterinarians, truck-
ers, the Meat Council of Canada and the
Canadian Federation of Humane Socie-
ties to develop a national volunteer code
of practice for all livestock. For the first
time a broad based committee has sat
down together to work out acceptable
methods of handling animals humanely
at all stages of their lives.
In answer to a question from the
audience, Hurnik said that the two areas
of pork production of greatest concern to
the welfarists are the permanent housing
of sows in crates and the early weaning
of baby pigs. He suggested that the
height, width and length of crates may
eventually be regulated as well as the
length of time a sow can be kept in a
crate.
Hurnik says Canada is the most
peaceful country in the world with regard
to animal welfarists, mainly because
Canadian farmers have seen what has
happened in Europe and the U.S. and
have taken steps to improve the handling.
of livestock. Hurnik believes that the
dialogue between the Canadian Federa-
tion of Humane Societies and the
livestock producers has led to an
understanding of good farming practices
and the development of a voluntary code
of practice acceptable to both parties.
However, we should not forget that it
is the animal welfare people who have
destroyed the sealing industry in
Canada.
After the meeting Hurnik said: "I was
very impressed with the quality of the
questions asked by the directors. I didn't
expect to see so many turn out on a hot,
dry evening. Obviously, pork producers
are sensitive to the problem and realize
there are no simplistic solutions.
Forward Contracting Rescheduled to
September
The O.P.P.M.B.'s forward contracting
program which was to begin June 13 has
been rescheduled to the week of Sept-
ember 26th. Weather and the uncertain
markets caused the delay.
Many producers are very interested in the
program, but so far the Board has
received few signed contracts. The wet
spring has made getting crops in the top
priority with little time for anything else.
Also, the packers have their problems.
Strikes have tied up major plants in the
U.S. and Quebec. When you add this to
the uncertain market outlook and all the
questions resulting from Canada Packers
move to Kitchener, very few want to tie
themselves down to long term commit-
ments.
With all this going on the Board believes
forward contracting just cannot get a fair
trial. By September the dust should have
settled. Then, both producers and pack-
ers will be in a better position to make
sound, unrushed decisions.
Health Study Questionnaires ? A
Reminder
The University of Toronto (U of T) still
needs at least another 200 completed
questionnaires to finish their study of
human health hazards found in the hog
barn. County secretaries have received
extra copies and more are available from
Toronto. If you or your neighbours have
not filled in the survey please do so as
quickly as possible. The U of T's deadline
is July 1st.
BROAD COVERAGE PROPERTY
INSURANCE AVAILABLE
The Board has completed arrangements
with Reed Stenhouse Ltd. to provide
Ontario pork producers with low cost,
broad coverage property insurance. The
O.P.P.M.B. Group Insurance Plan is not
a Board program. The Board just acts as
the umbrella for Reed -Stenhouse to
provide acceptable service to Ontario
producers. The program should be in full
swing by late July or August but
Reed -Stenhouse will begin accepting
policies in late June.
WEANER PIG MEETING IN JULY
The Ontario Weaner Pig Committee
annual zone meetings are scheduled for
early July. On the agenda will be the
election of zone representatives, issues
of current concerns and an update on the
year's activities. Meetings are tentatively
scheduled for:
July 5th - South Zone, Woodstock
July 6th - North Zone, Listowel
July 7th - Central Zone, Uxbridge
July 8th - East Zone, Kemptville
Your county secretary will be receiving
the details soon.