HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Huron Signal, 1882-01-27, Page 4sap
to
to
fr
Pt
of
ri
n.
t
ar
c
n
r
•
1
4
Tirk IJUr(4 ShiN.114, "Fitil)AY JAN. tS$t
THE HUItON SIGNAL' SOUND SPEE�'H was ma inch a ease. Vey teoek Hnu.e , f L'.a,n.,t.tir that the rGttutea
the whale Rritirii 8�ulwre, au : uthasritly mel )'
h' h " L �!F I tl tl
lspublished every Friday M Ile
ti1tLlccour hour. al (lair Ossa, its
toff the ttyaarct
GODERICH. (M TA1tIO,
And is despetehee te &U parte of . ttttesa&
tart country by the earbest mails and mum
B mineral admission it baa s cleat►
cin than any utter new apy�r la part et
Le country. and Is nae of tie reeteM. newnian&
mad most reliable )etraala la Ostarts
Po.sassi.g, as it dose, ale tsre•vola•ssssutlals.
ted being in addition to tis above. a shit class
family and dredde pe -t te dareeture a
most duo -task ad wedhat,
Tiaras. 11.50 In advsaos, p�stys pre -paid
bysblisbers; $L75, If paid before trig mouth.:
11200 if nut su pad. Tbls ruts will be strictly
enforced.
H*Ttn or ADVERTISING.- mete pas
one for newt Iasertloa ; thews oea per IIDw for
mice subsequentlasstttea, Ye.ry dual -yearly
nod quarterly cosOSda at reduced rates.
mete reieterI\G.-- 1-e bars shwa flrst-rlass
lobbing department In connection, and pssmes
ing the most complete out -tit mad best t.a Rtes
for terming out work to Oodertch. are prepared
to do b,ssineas in that hoe Al prices that cannot
he beaten, and of • gash` that cannot be
u rpassed. Tensa Cash.
• w io all wall cuucwodts t.. (a, su tM ISOMths t.• iIl.ulor the matter, andder- sought to a o,r.i ,wed , Het••, w itit the
The ][ember for Want Manta'
iii riot of the hue wombat fur pMI all t►at uu,e they n .k oF,ps,ttu- conn,,eluoce of the payorutctrl luttirLawre,
utu�l(. 1, refer t, lir. Todd. In has oily o•f e..Istenicauui t., Shu (intsrio I niJ thvet he w•:us not pre!•t of t„ euulply
the Legislature. icurk on f'ariiast.ia ry • •e N Gus ruwent their intenttnn of vetoing 1 wita their loquu,t. (,tpl,isudao. net
tar es« eh* Oct- He w.,aW neon powered to tette Wal t.•.uq :u t to ecu .. the protects o r
rat •r. uruatttuuona authority • tutu Kar o bis u
which hess tetutleweu opposite were ; the lace of a resolution of a majority of
humid to accept, th..uglt It. feared they the H•,use of Commune, in a caw 111
were he. the totally •.( the licit man in I which the rights of the whole Catholic
the s.asUe, they were se cunfirwud in population of New Brunswick, were
Sherr . tel wry*. mad tit their unbelief, 1 afectoyt but iotwithstaudiug their ur-
tlsa: •• ea en ra4t•I f r••.0 heaver., or une gent and earnest representation, his eou-
inae the dra.l a,uld not persuade them atttutional objection to the interferene-
tu hekete and repeat. 'Laughter., The with provinnial legirirtinu was so strong,
authority hr was Osumi to qu.•te, if not that he declined even t.. obey the wishes
t over.
r.
let an morel, had u..tlmutt ago sututwnawd of the Parliament be presided u
his exoectt••u of being one. Lau.Ltev.) Yet when one influential end wealthy
lu lt+, 1 .n .act Wail prsrd int the Lc}ie- sumeerter aeke hit (ambient to the vet. of
Later... of New Brunswick in relation to the Streams Bill, a hill which attuuh•.t
the ('o llll Soho.). of that Provisos. the rights of nobody, but that supporter
The L.eKisixture wise petitioned by the himself, he w:to re+tdy at once to aieriticu
Ronson Catholic inhabitants of the P. his constitutional principles (Applause)
vIItce not t.. pass the !till, claiming that 1Vho,the hon. gentleman cumtinue.1,were
it would Ire unjust and an infringement
uu their rights The Act was, however,
he British cohninto of t f ( ! t f
Abbe Adverse; of •.tart.• Metas The i haute ituly with toe whole question ea a vatic ) 1 I large i r f Romeo L th Inca to
•areatus' tin a.d the aeaadaryaward of ltuperial ouut.. I to co4,tsui •rasa.
T,lee lareabrr Is. Glengarry cesisetaed ten, and Domini.• t+mttr,l it /i'ws-
isrd ens ter the Tertq. te crack. vincial natters, FI&, sums up then
L •' .Woes entve rustedwsthttaapo Jwe-
ihe eel-
" eruutent, the Royal vet: upas ►e•aalinv
••-tem is uuw exercised only widow can
" talo prescribed or easily sacertased
limits, and that no mere calculations
" of political expediency, or difference
" of opinion in regard to the pulley of a
" colonial enacttu ut, would suttice to
" induce the Crown to veto the mums,
" provided only it was within the legis-
" native competency of the eulogy, and
" chid mot injuriously affeot the interests
••
tut other partsof the empiax" Asimilar
" restraint has loco al,scrve.l bj the
" 1)uulini.,n Government it its euutr•,l
• over provincial le,tislatitw delegated ie paast•d, end the Romeo eo Catholic Bishops apparently with the full t:oucunroucu of
" them by the Iwpenal Parliatuent." and people, want uuwertme petitions to hen. gentlemen oppo11it). It was said
New no one -will coxstets, that the the Deviation government praying that that they were raising bugbears, but he
Streams frill was ant ete*rle within the the wet might he disallow•td, as being an. would say, touching thin genie c..nsti-
legislative competency of the Province • infrtn temeut upon the rights which they tutionel question, that the Constitution
to deet with, and he would all the et- ertluve•l as at religious.demonstrstion at was in dormer, sod the existence tai our
tenbion of the House to Mr. Todd's 1 the time of confedentiun. But Sir ¢rent confederation imperilled, and they
statement that no mere cake ati•ur 4'John Macdonald, then Minister of Jus- had the declaration of the leader of him.
political expediency was a sufficient reef~ I rice 1874 , gook the ground that the gentlemen opposite, that theconatitution
on for the exercise of the veto peewee, ; Legi.:atare possessed . exelosive powersouald not survive the wrench that would
because it was unduuleedJy f•,r nu other i with reervd to educational neaten,. and he gtveu it, if the I)outiuiuu authorities
he advise 1 the G,tvenor=General that he presumed thus to interfere, with the es-
tablished rigltta of the Provinces. Beg-
ging the pardon of the hon. • member fur
(3tengarry• (Mr. McMaster) for having,
and he a layman, presumed to touch
upon a legal and e.)ustitutional sohject
he would conclude his remarks :mon
this queatien (Loud applause).
Mr. Fuser—And for a layman' the
hon. gentleman has done ea.aedmgly
We are able tut lay yre our reeders
the fulilowiug very full, and accurate re-
port of the recent powerful speech made
in the Ontario Legislature by Col. Moss,
during the debate on the Address. The
speech has been highly commended,
even the Moil admitting it to be an able
nue, Thule who would like to get at
the "true inwardness" of the Boundary
Award should read it. The ground
taken by Mr. Ross is impregnable, and
he will be supported ie hid glens of that
FRIDAY, JANUARY V. 1881. , important question by the ballots of a
large majority of his coistitueuts.
•
Ma. Ross said there were two subject*
AF'R SETT' WARDEN.
On Tuesday last Mr: Pod W. J..Ln-
*tun was elected Warden of the Cuultty
t•f Huron. The t•de steal 26 t.. 21 in
favor of Mr. J,.hnstoa, against Mr.
Hardy, the able Reeve ..1 Exeter. In
:untie* to Mr. Hardy, we must state that,
u pat forth no etf4it to snore Lis eke-
:los—in fact, le siren, u.aosly opposed
his oolifinatinn. asked for its with -
»tea; severrl times, and nominated,
rind vote.! for Mr Johnston. Notwith•
*tending the circumstances above enum-
erated. Mr. Hardy came within four of
his opgwmeet. Mr • Johnston has got
the Wardeashtp•. lie got it in response
be- auk and p liadin_, such as a mean
t stutd� .adcpendtw,ce be•old not be
gitititr ot;httd he ir' bt1 le• death vhhYa-
�i.,a to tie 'rails*,- s L %n t1ids who
elected him, althou:h they knew that
Mr. 'Hardy was To' supernw to him in
ret respect. In his first utturanee, he
gave the naieiete L/ uadenbn'd that he
would revive that relic of municipal
darts ages- the H'arden's sapper. The
Warden's supper. is usually the big
drunk of the year. It was manfully set
aside by Mr Maine last year, at the in-
• stance of Mr. Graham. Nnw it is going
to be 'resuscitated by Mr. Johnetoon.
There's a Conservative reaction for you.
We niI1 look f, .r ;•Sher retregreasive
measures under the mime of Warden
.lohnatni.
Mr Johnston and his friends now
toast that he wovii net harts been elect-
ed \Ws:•ien but for the opposition of
Tux Murat. to his oaadidature. For
the sake of argument. we will grant this
contentiem: but What does it prove? Only
Whist Tut $ I:Alae stated in reference to
Mr.Johnston--that be watt sot a suitable
man ter the psaitine, and that there
were far more, deserving sten in the
County Council, When Mr. Johnston
found it.. c.uldn tb, electedonhismeritr,
he posed ma martyr bellore his fellows,
and when he could not overcome their
better judgment, he appealed to their
sympathywit htearfuleyes. What thebet-
ter judgment of tbeConaervativeCouncil-
lora would not allow them todo,theirsym-
pa Sties die New. will Dir. Johnston toll
hririeauis whether he was - elected on
his merits, or was his election caused by
the se-calle.1"martyrdom"in the columns
of Tux SIGNAL. Take your choice,
Warden.
i in the Speech from the Throne, that
ovenitaduwed all others, and the re-
marks of all previous speakers had been
tumidly directed to them, bat before pru-
oeeding to deal with than, he would
take occasion to express his satisfaction,
that the Government had now determiv-
ed to wait no longer fyr the tine' .oath♦
anent of the acctuttts between the D�•
minion and the Province_before makit
the'destribution of ;the d Improve -
meat Fund, and had: announced theft•
determination t, pay over to the muni-
cipalities the amounts, to which which
they were entitled. There were plenty
of funds in the Provincial treasury to
enable them to do so, and the ultitnate
repayment by the Duwinion Govern-
ment was :assured,
There was another matter "that bon.
gentlemen opposite were eudeavoring
to make a little capital out of -the
Mercer escheat c in whicp. theJ
prime Court" hasd, t
escheated for Want ttf bei'o
the Dominion Government instead of
to the Provincial. It wan 'very mach to
be regretted that the majority of that
court had count to • Gait eenolusion
against the•opiu.ipn oft the Chief Justice
and Senior Judge, nut w much en ac-
count esithe Mercer estate, but that if
theitliaiisionheas upheld ky the Privy
Council the Dominion and nut the Pro-
vince would be entitled to such estates -
in future. The • Attorney General was
fully justified in appealing to the. Priory
Council. Hon. gentlemen opposite said
that" if the ease went against the Pre-'
vince, we wonld have to refund to the
Dgniinion the amount expended by the
Previnoe ,fori the Mercer Reformatory
and the Eye and Ear Infirmary. He
did not believe anything of the kind.
The peposes for which the money was
expanded
wens so laudable, and de-
sery
serving that the Dominion Government
coteld not• do otherwise than confirm
them. He desired to refer briefly to
the amore important questions mentioned
in the speech, the discussion of which
had occupied so fax- so large a share of
the attention of hon. members, and he
did so, as a layman, with considerable
trepidation, from the fact that the mem-
ber for Glengarry, in his speech on a
previous evening, had expressed the
the hope that the discussion on the con-
stitutional questions ,now • before the
House would- be left to the legal mem-
bers. :
Mr. Macmaster rose to a point of or-
der. tie had already explained that he
GI trttt7, after a protracted trial, dun
,t•j which he has ,';.:,oletl the propriety
• f the &.ort as p-rlimas no prisoner has
. ter be use atilt:opted, has been found
guilty."
Tht jitn• ariivetl at this
• era• pn•l•er .lrt•i.ion. in about half an
..•aur.
guilty of the treason ,tv. Tne wrench
to the Constitution had Iwett given, and
reasons than political expetlteney, and
under pressure of political influence, that
this bill was disilIewad (Hear. hear.)
hall nit right to interfere attd to allow
the Act to eo into Operation. This mat -
In 1877 the Legislatu-e of Prince id- ter, hung referred to the law offloera of
ward Ialaud pawed an Act reepecu.tt the ('rown, they reported that the Min -
public schools, to which the !Lona ester of Justices was quite right, that the
Catholics of the Prutiuc.e tools uning Legislature was quite •competent to pass
e)tceptiou, and appealed through their the Side of Act, and it was, therefore, no
bishop to the Deu,initen sutho,rites for eorl)ueunioninterfer.nese(App4suse•)
its disallnwance. The th•err Minister j In the debate on the subject which took
Justice, Chief Justice )easier hes eerie place in the House of Commons Sir John well.
ftd.luvfew of the nate, refusal et, inter. Macdonald ap.ete as follows:—Tho hon. Mr. Rues proceeded to deal with the
fere,and attheugh admitting that some elf gentleman (Mr. 'Anelin) had ctnnpli- matter 441 the Boundary award. He
the provisions of the act al•pea'ed [tented the Iteminiton tieveniutent to a said, nut since confederation had there
severe and somewhat rrbitlaey• utd tee certain etteut ou the absence Prem all been aquest' upon whichitbehoovesthe
commending that the attention of the interference in the actions of the Local
Itteuthrant (3overn% ahould be carted to I L•afjslatures since Ct.nfederation. As
them to cousider the ee tency .•f oar- the tater primarily responsible on such
tain amendments theret., the Mini>oce of l subjects he cunld only say that he had
Justice was nevevthtless ..f rilttni,nr that 'ottani untfurta care t, interfere in no
the net should be left to irs oeterauen, 1 way whate%er with an) n
•Act passed by
and "that it was not pnep.- for the I any of the Provincial Legislatures if they
•• federal authority to maeupt to in- were within the scope of their jurisdic-
" terfere with the Jeta le or se- I tion. There were only two cases, in his
" cesearies of a measure of the l episwa., m whicfh the (Government of the
" local legislature the principles and ob.
'• jects of which are entirely within their
province,- (Hear, hear). This was
good constitutional law. and the position
taken by Mr. Fnnrnier was the. same
Waimea, was Juetitied• in advising the
disallewsnce of a local Act ---first, if the
Act was uncnnstutional, and there had
been an excess of jurisdiction, • and sec-
ond, if it was injurious to the interests
position that- was taken oy Sir John Me- 1 of the whole Dominion. (Loud ap-
Donald on several occasion.. Hon. ' plause.. 1,n the report of Sir John . c-
gentlemen had an unbounded faith in 1 Donald to the Governor in Council in
Sir John, and claimed that he was the 1869. And which was transmitted
greatest constitutional lawyer in the Dos I to the Provincial Governments s.r, the
minion. His abilities as a statesman limits within which the Dominion power
and constitutional lawyer he Mr. ROSS)
would not deny. Before leaving this
subjeet he would read some of Sir John
McDonald's utterances on this subject,
and thought he would Ise able to show
that his action in vetoing this bill. and
thea position taken by ben. gentlemen
opposite in support mf that veto, we. di-
rectly opposed to the position formerly
taken by ,that gentleman. He would
however, before proceeding to quota Sir.
John. give hon. gentlemen soma further Sir John .after, three years further ex -
quotations from Mr.- Todd s work he perie nce of the working of the federal
said "Pursuant to the 82nd section of system, sees no ground for enlarging the
the British North America art, these veto power of the Dominion, hut limits
" local legislatures possess }.owes of the a .ercise of that power .to the two
" legislation as complete and absolute, classes .of causes only which I have just
" within their exclusive jw-isditiun, as quoted. Gentlemen opposite, Mr. Roes
" those enioyed by the htisninion Par- continued, say that the right of veto can -
of. veto cold ee constitutionally exer-
cised, these limits more confined to the
four followin classes viz.: 1st.' as being
altogether il�e�al or unconstitutional.
2nd. As being Illegal or unconstitutional
only in part. 3rd. In cases of concur-
rent jurisdiction, as clashing with the
legislation of the Dominion Parliament.
4th. As affecting the interests of the
Dominion fenerally. The Streams bill
comes within none of these heads, but
made no such statement in his screech, liament or even by the Parliament of not be denied. But no one did deny
and he thought the .matter should not I •. the Mother Country in their respxtive the legal right of veto. The question
again be referred to. •• 1 spheres." (Hear). Hon. rentlenn-n had was, is this a constitutional exercise of
Mr. Ross said he wis glad the hon. quoted speeches mf, the Hon. Mr. Mc- that power? (Hear, hear.) Upon what
Kenzie and the Hon. George ,Br,wti, to ground was the Dominion Government
show that it was intended that the Poo warranted in interfering with -the
vinces ahould concede their rights in en- Streams Act. Did it come within any
and on this (evasion as on others he tering into confederatie•n, but Mr. T•xid of the definitions' laid down by Sir John
held -'that the rights of local seif guy- I either in his report of 1868 or in his
had no doubt allowed his volubility to eminent heretofore conceded to the 1 speech in 1871.No one has contended
carry hits in advance of his thoughts •• several Provinces of the Dominion, are that it was unc,notitutiunal or in excess
and his judgment. There was no doubt •• net in any wise impaired by their law- . of our jurisdiction.. Neither can it be
that he made use of the et11rressiots at. •• tar entered inters fo;deral e.mpact. and' contended that it was injurious to the
tributeoi to hint. In addition to ex- that no infrineemen' lapca these rights interests of the whale Itoiitiniun. - The
gentlentan had on .nature reflection
backed out of the position he had taken
theother night. Thehon, gentleman was*
speaker of great fluency and eloquence,
pressing the hope that the laymen which w"old hr at variance with c;,u- only ground that hongentlemen upuo:-
would leave these constitutional rues- •• stitutinna' usage or with the !hooray of site justify its disallowance is that in
propleofOntartoto stand t•egether firmly,
shoulder to.shoulder, in assertion of the
rights of the Province, than upon , this
question of the northern and western
boundaries. All political differences
should be laid aside, and the voice of
this Assembly, the voice of Ontario, in
all its earnestness and plower, with dis-
tinct and mtequivncal utterance, should
be unitedly raised, and the Dominion
authorities plainly and emphatically tnld
that Ontario will stand as one man iu
defence of her rights of territory.
(Cheers.` He was, however, deeply
grieved to see, that while Ontario's re-
presentatives sitting in this House on
the left of the speaker, •have felt ion -
stained by a regard for public opinion,
nominally to record their votes for the,
notions of prnt.•.t, which the Attorney
General had tear it his duty, as.the,ts Hon. gentlemen opposite say that none
sponsible guardian of the right cf the of our territory has been taktan, that
Province to have. placed on record on our Iseundaries are est whetrethe
our jeurnale, yet the effect which Court.. and the Privy �Qeil may de -
those votes should have had as the un- Gide them to be, and that if we Ines nc-
snimous protest of Ontario, had been copied more than we were legally en-
weakeaed and 'rendered inetfective, b r titled to it is but just that'it should he
the apulugecti i utterances of hon. gnu. taken from us. But it was just because
tlemen opposite for their friends at Otte- there were different opinionsss to where
wa, and the hal.f•hearte.l, nay, evi- these boundaries shuald he, that there
dently reluctant manner in which those was art arbitration at all. If there was
votes have been given. (Hear, hear.) no legal doubt as to these boundaries,
They said they Were prepared. to stand there would be no dispute. There were
by the ,rights of the Province. • - But but two courses open by Which to deter -
they coupled that statement with the minethismatter,'ait appeal to the Courts
declaration that they considered their and the Privy Council, involving end -
allegiance to the Dominion was paten- less delays and costs, or an arbitration.
mount to their allegiance to their Pro- The latter was chosen. Both the
wince. Nay, the hon. member for East Dominion and Provincial Government
Grey had boldly declared, as had also agreed to the arbitration, they appoint -
the member for Glengarry, that their ed an,arbitrator,. they concurred iu the
political allegiance to their chiefs at appointment of the umpire, the House
of Commons voted the money necessary
to ,say the cost of the rlference, and
played by hit lsaJ tat Ottawa. (Ap-
plause.) Did the h getitlenua moan
by rant, a,vertl))• 1" ia: et the uupetri-
utie mourn Ser Juhu M * Iru►sylrtg iu tw-
gaa 1 to Ontario interests. Let him tell
the hon• gentle...0a that if the ORtatto
(►pprition desires t.. rewire that sup-
sicerstion‘.whiob they are aHitled to
Rous Sir John, and whish for Osuario's
interests he mount with thew to p•enesv, /
it is not by :;eutle hunts ar to Sir Jubs's
hostile attitn,le to !lila !truantry 1baL it
will be ()bluntest, but by hnMty "a mkt
out in meeting" and plainly telling him,
that white is ;milkier! *pull. .thy with
him, .w IJ.auivau •lne.tioos, the vital
interests •'f Ontario are letraineunt to
pa,liticul alletgianee, and th.tt in the
emirate he is pureeing 111 retird to this
heinelrry queatioe, lie will alienate from
hint every (o/lservative in the Pruv.uce,
Let him ap•ak• out enc lmiv•atlh• on this
question, and he will receive far more
ewlsidurxtiott from Sir Jelin, au.l nay
britl1 back to a sense of duty, the re-
creant metubut-: of Ontario in the Du-
turniie:t $once, who have basil j• support-
ed the sp,siliatiou e,f tlniir owls Promote.
Sir ,l..hn seems t., he satiny as if he was
confident Le could t' -emit Mean the sup-
port of lona.' genthn.tco o . s-Lsitu, uo
matter how lie tnioeiles mu Provincial
rights. Ile sincereh• trusted he would
be disappointed in this. He trusted ma
friends opp.siite would see the gravity of
the l'roviueial tattooists involved, and
not only record their 'orient against the
action of the Dominion Governrnetit but
beck it up 1.y ,wanly outspoken
words that • will hear net' mis-
construction. 1)ur friteida upQ- 1.
hold a greet power for good or rill to
the Province on this question. .% firth
Rud determined attitude on their port,
s t+0rdial and open co -o .eratiou--Rot
merely in form but in reality—with the
Attorney General in the assertion of our
rights, will secure what we justly claim.
Mile a half-hearted and timid acpui-
esenoe, trade in such a way as to cote
vey the impression that their party
allegiance will net be lemened, even if
our rights are denied, will but confirm
bur despoilers in their course of insult
and aggression, and precipitate s conflict
that would, he verily believed, be fatal
to our promising confederation. -(Hear,
hear.) In urging them to this course,
he was urging them to a course, in their
own interests as a party.' if he were
only looking to a party advantage, he
.would like nothing better than that they
should continue in the course they seem
to be fatuously pursuing, because he
had ton Much 'faith in the independence
and manhood of the electors of Ontario
to believe that they will not spurn with
indignation, that representative who
should fa;l, with all his power and voice,
to uphold the rights of 4i►is Protince
against her her attempted spoliation at
the instigation of a jealous rival (Cheers.)
Ottawa was supreme. Was that not
virtually an invitation .to the Ottawa
Government to pay tie -regard to the they, paned an oder in Connell agree -
rights of this Province or respect its ter-
ritory
er- ing to be bound by the award. It was
ritory? Was it not equivalent to sac clover they were as fully cununitted to
ing: never mind our 'recorded vette,the arhitntiuu as was Ontario, and were
sacrifice Ontario's iutcrests to your poli- in limner bound to abide lay the deci-
tical exigencies if necessary, and v. -e will, aeon. That decision was an unanimous'
nevertheless, stand.' by you. !Cheers. award, and their course in now repu-
1e was also sorry to sen that the effect dieting it was cowardly au:1 unprece-
hf those protests in 'which they havelldented. He would admit, that if it
felt themael,es constrained to join, had 1 could lie shown that there etas any
been further weakened i':- the' total ; fraud, .gross partialityor improper con -
absence of any su1e nt from tli' "fl- ,
(pet on the part of the arbitrators, or
netts for the legal men to (lest with, he .. '' '
pp action preciously enjoyed by the pro- their opinion the cr,mneusation given servattve mewepapct's • m the Prov mare, ' that the sward was of such au nut woos
leraveised tphe of qutestioe legal
to be dealtmber ww with - , t rncee, wuldhen under the direct control Mr. McLaren was insufficient. (Ap- and the direct treachet r .:f a targe num- 1 character as to carry its own c,ncriaeiJinna•
of the Impel ;al Government would he plause.) When hon. gentlemen mn this her... Ontario's repo entatites in. the tion on its face
he the hymen. (Chaeta.) He ' Mr. ' ...usti(uble on the part of the dominion side of the House claimed that this ar- Dominion Parlrmneut. How is this ? thou Might be some
Kass J I excuse fns r ulinttnx it, het nothing of
•tur•Irrs has pre -1 1 executive." Applause The bon bitnry and wholly unprecedented exec Is one not forced to the conclusion that tt►t>rrottkl
4,tdttu• • _• t` tl
.1tLt
would, however, • with the hon.
graci+lttrTsertuitsat,Stf,ltti,ceeod,memberfor Glengarry had denied that cis° of the veto power was n direct party fedi-nee mad party interests are h. d h° thewts-n"thingel the
tghty opinions of con- , 'b1 t h h 1 1 I nerd a clauued. The cuaracta•r of the
tr:icon during Cie ow: week or tae. In Ren elnans•
1Watenbern a
1it . t maned Rourke atrtntmnal authorities, which he thought 1 '111 eg s K� arxl was sen andn,e ere.cwoul�sif allovsiednssu ely(leAdrt'. the ares and vier the vital interests 'of the men was too high for even an insin-
ktilrl ant ,s -o_e i.e ilei and lei. ,laug}i• the hon. gentleman wiiuld aecal►t with . indignant bemuse his t received break u, of confederation, hon. entlr- Province; Hew else could wee" a-•
'+allot of wrong aoimj. The late Chief
ter, aur! also it 'c til,;cb1 the life cif respm t, nnair first he would read the n 1 s .T01tice Hammen, war., While ill �.liticel
a check be his (Mr. Rte') reference to men a aid we were gni cmvert tree ,count for tho evident levity and der►slon life, aro warm supporter f l�t� o I n
third ) r or t'i • family. • n fihel• tt 1 1 �h
mote which the proper references
e to give some wf el •
A t mem. tic ). 1
tt erances tit a gent eman w to claimed ,the G tie Act, in which this !nista. "ton. The Ref .rm rarty• had dend
0 be a great ednstitutional authirit ,'tu tide Sentient McDonald d lotto about Confederation than
to this
with wh' h h', t.
wean who, in indepcudeitco of sn;u•acter,
) • re underunder- bring than hon. questirm in the speech from thin cls:tineas mf•
,,urns an 11 mei r. tic 1 Smith sup- and whose claims although a las 1 t th ' 1 d i "!7 d th ate f k 1 d
poses! t • 14 iv.. hell "tilled he his nephew, the hon, member far Glengary would man•
t r,m an deal with tt in a different manner than he acrid ate -thing whict sou d tend to de- gentlemen (T oaite and by their organ
.tan to T auto, lass 1,0ea foetid guilty '
by a . ,,otter's jury 1-' the murder of
ter i.,air.::
took to m•ernde the dtapsttun of .'fent amen opposite (or ear leaders. an/ Throne, an o Utterances a speaker.
tl • mon,, maid j miicial
Ability was unsurpassed in the Province.
Sir Francis Hinck., the representative
as lee in the Owen . own l Ttn. desired. The veto pe.wer was invoked Gtr•;; it. And to corder to ah• w from in this city. ,this out a question vat- mf the Dentition, was a statesman of
('cbeen and laughter,) ailed
and which nide of the House these treason• all ttiectinsr Ontsuuis felon her omw'er, lona and large experience, fur yuan a
'ttmndncted lin the hon. member for � then, but torr h,hn rrfu.,et1 u. interfere. 3 1 colleague of Sir John's in the govern•
R:eeuut't.• was had t" Inc courts to ee. air.e tendencies tem noted he would , her iuttuence, aid her financial premier -
mem -TM o
1 ( n � meet) _,toad
North re Fr. Creighton. n. i 111.. Wes a and the
Grey g
s
quote w ., its. But hon
n t the concluding words f gentlemen ss. it is .
that act unc.•natitut c . e Bair John : � no
leecceden to read amid considerable in- 1 dare a i mel. Let c. bis Ikaminian, a men !n everytea eminent -
see what elle lodges said en that tease Sfac,lenahl in the same able speech an I moment whether Ontario gets this 100, , Y
dispute. He world read f s property under his will, and to were as anxious or perhaps more so to ; in support ,f our rights ane met by hon,
a 1a•1 • f f um yc•:uw' o f •a.;e. A moi. 1
wa tally eeeee a the fo1leeiilg h%m to p He id teed what as sato by Chas. i Y and ort a t ueata.n of this trod. The third
orate e'mn Ute dluJlowanoeeofthe Streram •
hill in that paper, in which the !triter .•1 takepitit�ils that nnderd.osJ.tJerati.,n c:..+aid net act, and they would have Teen neat importance to anppi,rt theirpsnliti i'1he mapIireetsoetween these two, was Sir
although condemning the p:tsaa;e of ihs Edward Th•ntann,the liritiah minister at
we have hada federal and not a . legial*. ' guilty ei a• violent. wrench fat the Con- ' chief at Ottawa, although the action of n'esitin mn, than whom as an impartial
r:J • as an interference whin rithat
i
Rt
it•
' t use they that ch- f.' d . to
it u i• n ' mit 1f teem ary heal a di re u ec 1 hostile theiro• -
t e n u that t the Pr,vi tit differ- Pt
i et•ial 4
Y
Ltogi.•
„ )tilno t
r:� ht.yet,thought tho f better could.
vetoingthat gas he trot
chosen.
' latnre N er•lumittld the p.awo!r a• loris- 'eat ,t11173"11:
pinio a, cher ahould met up their i *'ince. is it n"t known, that dt is only 1v" have the otitic statement of Sir
bill unight he frau,gLt with grate tomb- 1 late within :a range of suhlttts, :::deed ; own judtmeut against the ',peen de- 1 jealeetuly of (Intent) 1 progress and influ- prancis Hinck. -whose s m thiel the
to da likewise int a'!f-defence, and as tntionl leo lie enc. P Hr Mr. Rosa I !united, but within these present -eel inane] of a Province In a matter entirely . ence by another Province, when rep -es- lion !air. McDougall said n tlpiiia Hawse
thought the alone ex relaid in that ar-
limits then •ht f the Ler , t • within the control ..f that Province.' entatirea are more united than ours, }
is Mons from oppM►hn uwmen, an ty quahhtrl Go reptetsent the minim
won w a w re le referred to. flit .loan said: -'(1(1(1 s, ware Miles of territory ..r nut r
the Clinton .in E. k' the Cmuserr. s oxpll n d t "The tinverRment of the Dominionall the, because it was than ht oft 1
attves are t•.uryint Ir e.tiu:b•:t politics ire
':
tt a their •thi sn•i 1 e r acts.
t•. atter .rt(, ,ru
`•an the net •rest "f t t • Duty."- it aimpiy
hsestn.a its_ ttuhe 4)3 Cie Liberal party
this art ty cnnhina x n.ajority of Lib- ticlu were• more in accord with high con- ` " t. a on• Yah, a"' w•unl.l be against (►ntario--that each of
roll it I,ltaolrts ; v it Slut to bestir , Mn the r s•tch redone.' Mr. Justice strew_ said.- "Aa L iia appaloosa. Had not, Air. P.o ss whose support lir John is always Gbh to
t st.tnttusaf authorities t the arbitrators
Y i t i to that pewee t.. par Aet• afferent/ pre- asiceo1 the initiator of Justice at tittau•a'deptntl open that is the real power that
thestselves, and hen,eti•rth eimtestevery
e.
. t ' •i .. •..:. •rW se u
election, m rma pal t n pno-
to h it gattt}etn an ?fad dehvettd m the n „ K ptnhmg he i:eldence adduced, fixed on
nAo was written ,, , ,• to same boundary. The award was
t
Hnnse that day. The - perty, that the L•gt,lature hes the ltmw- I to set up his j int n against the Act i forces irJ ,hn s hosttlo attitude. Should '
h Hou 1 we net t} a u
1 a t the � that se ss. it en 1 our political differences ern all (macs sono n pan right lfrrenc
t mal ! nes
under the clear bracing air of the gtor- faulted
therefore . unanimous. That, award did
laical rounds- We •u't like this s.trt ion Ba the ether was s token amid, extent as the lmperwl Prrilameat t that afro r an expression s.f opinion like I aeido and stand as one man by our own
K R ti ( in the 1'nited Kinr•l.nt:. 1 have the:. sir Jtdtn Inuenmt.11 should leer• Province'.' ;Applause.) Although an ad. ^'d nnduly4avorOntario, The territory
tit thing, Lot u t5e r.luia;cri.%hats d.b it, aIId 'ut;'h etltofl try, the ciru,ent• pditialp' net the aiaKhtest doubt. Appwwe. )'mit an interference wail their betide- ruiner of the Attorney General, and hey-
;
ay- awarded her fell for abort of what site
heneef• •rah ''its the . iutereats . of the atmeselfere that 'ltataurrmltsrlhirn. Hon, The Hon. Co,ssatsinsi..ner of croon Lands tion ' He would quote the final words in :fall z,ntidence in him (Internment and in I claimed. There ryas uothiug in it chore
m:. ' h,: et C•►ne: :v lt.i: r in n!ticug''"Herne:r ,e•wsite have endeavour- had referrcvt to tF» ustsracnests manner .the speech ••f Kir John Macienaid:-- their management of the, affairs of the I 1"t" ea' for Intnniiation. When that
N Y 1 rl V. shirk t�te real question herr in; ;trent territory in the North-w••.t was
where• soratr, are vn :`rnd simply i, Id,t etre. T Bey have tensed their whole in which this veto power haat tarn ewer. "The l .,nstitutiom• which had hi ben., tn..vmce, so vital riial. he consider the t }tend a the Hnr)atwi's ling Cone -Any. ray. did
Wee ore els t , a J i w ; sviygaRW s 1 AO. ►attaiinia• La main{ that Cho dr1'legal ' eissd in this slave, the Beet olaWsatiru: worked s„ ensiip and se. well. (•Said not retaining this territory to the material S i ^
etiE$ Is the Ihenhiiun (inrerrt bee d it keit thas►s1Rls th�col Miva l survive the wrench that would t e given hr Mp erity, future influence,
and ad•'; United Johnand o the representatives the . t
nr.rti t jt1 t9 N' hi will be ittmeritthe .Hail net:li ter. T:,e Trader of 1 if the Diesi tion Government asrmned to • a•ancement ..f the Province,. that if b y t h
meet to veto Provincial !Natation. NO tooly ! of that Cts y t" this tee roman whirl
i�,Mhtrsea+ est her nesever all al'nead one denies hat attc1 sower ii ca.ufen«I the t.ep,ekh'n replied, that .1 ass dictate the ln,liey air •mtwtion the action his h• ntrienot the lender .f the tip;x,ait•'the Dominion authowit7ies now assert is
u :mil., - e'•tk • 1, ?att. npm t them hy'the Il. A. Act. tWhat . not enst"mary to in... n.rtier. , f Ate its• t of the Legislatures of the . igvrcr.: I'rte• •ion supplanting the Attorney (ieneraj itheira be right of purchase, from that
we eonfend for, is that trochpower is to . trnuan 1.. ret,. Let ns. ,c••• en of Mr. • t'rnt•e, on nibject. reamed . by the. and Lon. r+tettletrlcn rappjwsssite taking polo i C9,'v. the Dirmiaa iea'tarnlsent harp
T,sld aeys,m thtoe arms h tenth:nap , 1Rriti•'.t se 4tneric4 Aet to t woe screa dt •.f the tome -dry bvuchas. t totari,> 'nth(
A merle:414e It pccetle+fiM the Basil -le t•xen lama in a con,titnti nal msmirt• mount not say that Mr. T e LI, with all- Lsttuktorea F, cwt app Luee1. Titers w.ntld thereby secure her tights to the
tin titts to that territory exc••pt what
ice sentinel,* .,r.• •law feet week. A lane a'rd uod7 the resfttsinte eatablis"n" by authorities within 'hie reach. would state
bate en a motlaen in teltat. Oh
Moura•. •t• Cede- l di.vpntted territory, he would gladly coats than Pnrc
t)d finin the
hes }1i, cot rights;
r m• , the floor of the House and take his teat
amens. ' akin. the (here nor- :s e•otned ' as a member of the Opposition, rather 1 till,aLWf N Id 1.y the old 1't.•: ace t f
pens ti/trtitte►al 1.111%. T11e powe•T to ret.,
named \Walsh, r M• 1►a•1 horn entering } meta of the Ingpenal retoaneent, exits as the hcactiee that which w a+ ober r••r-
fTpn1 . to iJ•, 11 • ,, MAA ffame n!, ; n•l. ' rest. He ata. at page' 't. t "Th. teat•
l�MeeA h•, i as ahtsnlnflid in the Q•ten, ax the power
ae+tr. iD1F tweeted- • liar. IM hal before t*' ,r rx•
• • 1 tee dtaa,lnvf the Art. path! the 'Leman • than the Proytn would be flea algid a^ •ben held I y the 1fu.lsou s
i fn veto p 4'1 'Metal legestatemn abaft in tire; .o (leavened t Ftty Comm any, the Dtt�m,••n tail" war
tr c aa: relit j�r,11sh1 on ! D.,minu•n,i.et ilhehasnotonceexerc•iaed it „ trm: ..f o�wlit••• t foe :•, t It. ('tNh•dieti auarierr.l sfi.•,sid lime . n ere of Shut.writ.aylhati,elongw,l robot. Ap. i
lite. al ili{aloha snot l.ntttsalt its tl:I eall 1111 heath.* f t i' hal rtortnnttt f M'fsjinit the matteP •td c F panto ' Bat Kit T ham 1 11 k by th••se very tern rel•uaiatts and y tatabie aeo•iewe se sent en tto ail 1rystar t1 p„pin ons pr' to 1"of pr'mptin its repeal ••r am nevertheless carried a,reitset hint. Hi i the leader of the Opposition "spade outt true,ltl,ney,andattetett by i' to de-
•' gieMtfe foiled Hilt sof a hM we-.bhlota+aimtbanpiaugh of braewhoad- .. nta•tst-(Test. hem. Potoetimes I exceilehey however advisid by hi Mica- ; in meeting. ' and it was retorted that hit �~ wsofmar ri„hts.kir.J. t{. Dar►-
te 7 � � ► onefh a f.:o.•es•tA , latrlgiltcr has a reps- t the 't' d tM I. sold . adtiestl h `tie• 1 l ethnrisvd . h lathe 1 ons.tMtirytasan(hetatin esrntativeten. resp.* a ration as n ee milieu tans alit enty not 1 rf•t this eery territory, mot fotM•q-
thct�e'^ee't jail•pairtlluislenttimes frn• ttisallw�arcer ►,rat t?,s f�tewsiats r1,-Ninithv(Juaticr:nfuvss the against tie ittdi'tereneebateatiop•,int,nevse. e•fth.1lr.afit e•rttwtniteosa steepseidoting h.r• whsle reign, He wound t'.enc•'.t-.oaccoracndo
etthaled. ?Ion tJia tlsunt sn uwr (a w ;Ili:
haild awl dwrtrped Ansa. tnMtgttttnldtsitosrhjr,ti.asshlPfee. uJtyLefmre the Petty ,C• rtlp'i?. n.t pari«etly tss11 wM, hecareld depend u n y, now ai/h the iron tnemlter f er (aentttsr- ,"teres, and give thew an.rtunity Jentanthe tannest. it was,Ab the toren TtContention the on,ect'vetittegmt-htIargolywith
Ad) tio•rrajfl c0 uin-,,-Cft•,i wifN the d TP' Mme- "T'4'a+++rR Tory
glee i responsible for tb•• hoe' n ltfr t' 1 1 Itecesss y o ate s "art the elkets y . . •e tr-, a apses taw r a goers nus protbt ed
I
I