HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Exeter Times-Advocate, 1973-06-28, Page 115WELL OPENING — The men above aren't too concerned about the rather large leak from the side of th's
building. What they are in fact observing is the opening of the Moodie Well, east of Exeter in 1949. From the
left the men are B. W. Tuckey, reeve in 1948; L. J. Penhale, chairman of the PUC; H. C. Rivers, commissioner
of the PUC; and A. J. Sweitzer, reeve, 1949. (photo by Doerr)
.111,
Section 1, Page 27 THE EXETER TIMES-ADVOCATE JUNE 28, 1973
History of PUC
a.
— Continued from page 26
$20,000. debenture issue to cover
the cost of the necessary plant to
distribute electric power.
When the vote was held on the by-
law on July 22, 1915, 70 percent of
the eligible voters went to the
polls and there were only seven
dissenting votes in the unusually
"quiet election". Council passed
the By-Law in August and im-
mediately signed the agreement
*with Ontario Hydro.
Once the agreement was signed
erection of Exeter's new poles
and so on began in the fall, Street
lighting was discussed and it was
decided that 176 street lights
would be put up; this would cost
$2,640 per year for the hydro
power. This compared with the 55
street lights in use in 1915, of
which 36 were the carbon arc
type and 19 incandescent; in 1915
the village had paid the Electric
Company $1,550 for power for
these lights. There was some
interest in ornamental standards
with underground cable in the
business section from Anne
Street to Sanders Street. In
November 1915 Dr. J, W.
Browning, J. G. Jones and thirty
other merchants petitioned
eCouncil to put this type of street
light and standard up in the
business section, Council, on a
motion by Hind and Harton
refused to grant the petitioners
wishes. As a result overhead
wiring, wooden poles, with
somewhat ornamental fixtures
went up on Main Street. Some of
these ornamental iron fixtures
can still be seen on some of the
back streets of the town.
Sometime in 1916 the Ontario
Hydro high voltage lines reached
Exeter from St. Marys. The
"step-down station" was built
and hydro came to Exeter.
Stores, hotels, houses and so on
were wired for hydro if they had
not already been customers of the
electric company. "King" Davis
and other electricians had a busy
time. The number of customers
Alp. climbed until by 1920 it is
reported that there were
somewhere between 300 and 400
customers in the village.
The First Years
of the Commission
With hydro in Exeter, Council
under advisement from the
Ontario Hydro Commission
undertook to set up a public
utilities commission. Until this
was set up the Fire, Water and
Light Committee of Council was
the responsible body; this
meant, of course, that Council
dealt directly with Ontario
Hydro, So, as was stated earlier
in 1917 the Exeter Public Utilities
Commission was established and
Council turned over respon-
sibility for both._ water and
electricity to the commission.
The men. that Council
periodically engaged to run the
small waterworks were hen-
ceforth engaged by the Com-
mission, Herman W. Doerr, an
electrician, had sometime before
1917 been engaged by Council and
in 1917 he became the manager of
the waterworks and hydro ser-
vice for the commission; his
salary at this time was $70.00 per
month,
The early -years of the Com-
mission did not see any great
expansion of the waterworks
system. The primary job in this
department was maintenance of
the existing system and minor
periodic extensions. But Exeter
did not expand much at this time
so little additional main was
necessary. In the hydro depart-
* ment the commission's crew
which varied in size and in
members constructed the lines
and so on to the various parts of
the town. Hydro power was
delivered, for example, to the
canning factory and to the other
peripheral areas of the village.
Not only did the Commission
administer Exeter but also un-
dertook in its first couple of years
to administer the hydro facilities
in Dashwood, Zurich and in 1923
the immediate rural area. This
rural system had 130 customers.
Once a month H. W. Doerr and,
when he was hired in 1921, R. E.
Russell would go to Dashwood
and Zurich to read meters,
render accounts, do the
bookkeeping and make in-
stallations.
The Commission met in the
Library in its earliest years since
it did not have any building under
its jurisdiction. Electric and
water accounts could be paid at
the office of T. G. Creech the
express agent. Mr. Creech
received some small
remuneration for this service. A
few years later the building now
occupied by C. Fairbairn on Main
Street served as the Com-
mission's office and shop. The
Waterworks and Hydro depart-
ment payroll in the 1920's and
early 1930's included from time to
time various part time or casual
labourers as well as the small
permanent staff, Such names as
R, E. Russell, W. Lutman, who as
far as the writer knows was the
only employee in the history of
electricity in Exeter to die on the
job by electrocution, E. "King"
Davis, A. Kernick, B, Cun-
ningham, John Norry, Thomas
Welsh, James Parsons, Leo
Hennessey, Harry Lewis, Elmer
Reeder, Archie Ireland, Dewey
Ward, Ed Sims, C. B. Carruthers
and many others, Rosa Dearing
who was office clerk was the only
female employee prior to the mid
1930's.
As has been mentioned from
1917 to 1934 the Commission did
not undertake any major
waterworks construction but in
the 1930's it was becoming ap-
parent that something had to be
undertaken by way of a potable
water supply. In 1934 the
Chamber of Commerce
petitioned the Village Council to
undertake an examination of the
feasibility of installing a potable,
domestic water system.
Evidently men like L. J. Penhale
manager of the canning factory,
which was very interested in
water supply, Albert Traquair,
and other prominent citizens
were strongly urging provision of
a domestic water supply. Many .
people, however, had no interest
in the scheme, since they had
good wells. In March 1934 "an
informal meeting of a number of
representative ratepayers was
held in the Exeter Library
and the following resolu-
tion as adopted on a motion by
B.W.F. Beavers and B. M.
Francis:
that this meeting request the
Municipal Council to take the
necessary steps to secure
available information as to the
cost of installing a suitable
system of drinking water for the.
Village of Exeter".
The Council referred this to the
Commission. The Commission
engaged the services of D. H.
Fleming a Toronto consultant.
The Council agreed to hold a vote
on the debenture by-law for the
waterworks extension and im-
provement. This vote went 246 for
and 96 against. The situation
regarding water in Exeter at this
time was one of increasing
seriousness. Individual wells
upon which people depended for
their drinking water were
becoming polluted from weeping
tile,
In 1936 land and springs on the
farm of Mr. Garnet Frayne were
obtained and rights of way for a 6
inch pipe line to the old pump
house at the river also were
obtained through the properties
involved which were owned by
Messers Frayne, Yellow and
Dow. A reservoirwas built near
the old pumphouse with a
capacity of 250,000 IG to receive
the water from the springs where
a motor and pump were installed
to pump the water to the reser-
voir. The interior of the old water
tower was also cleaned and
painted. In 1937 the old pum-
phouse at the river was sold and
removed and the present pum-
phouse constructed.
In March 1937 the Commission
set rates as follows:
Private Dwellings one or more
taps $6.00, with bath $3.00; with
toilet $3.00; public garages
washing cars $25.00; public
garages not. washing cars $12.00;
bakeshops $9.00; dentist office
$9.00; doctor's office $9.00;
barber shop $9.00; theatres with
toilets $15.00; butcher shop $9.00;
stores $9.00; creamery $75.00;
school $100.00; Huron Lumber Co.
$25.00; flax mill $20.00; chopping
mill $25.00; V. Cann $200.00;
green house $20.00; hotel $60.00;
bowling green $35.00; arena
$50:00; CNR $250.00; Canadian
Canners $350.00; hydrant $40.00;
tank of water "cash" $1.00.
The Period of Modernization
The period from 1940 to the
present is of sufficiently recent
date and the records are more
readily obtainable so that the
remainder of this paper will be
divided into two sections. The
waterworks department's
developments will be traced
bridfly through to the present and
the hydro department
developments will be traced
separately rather than combine
the two as has been done up to
this point.
The waterworks developments
will be dealt with first. As in-
dicated previously by 1940 the
waterworks consisted of the
domestic system and the river
supply. There were two sources
of domestic water being tapped,
that is, the Abbott Well on
Marlborough Street and the
springs on the Frayne farm. This
water was collected at the
reservoir near the dam and
pumped to the system. The river
supply was used only by the
Canadian Canners for cooling
purposes at this time. In 1939 the
Commission was serving 308
domestic customers, 66 com-
mercial customers and 5 in-
dustrial customers for water. By
1946 these figures were 531, 85,
and 4 respectively. Ten years
later in 1956 there wee 890
domestic customers, 135 com-
mercial and 8 industrial. The
present figures are ap-
proximately 1,100, 137, and 13,
During the war years almost no
water main extension or im-
provement to the waterworks
was undertaken. The period 1945
to 1950, however, saw several
important developments. During
this time a third well, namely the
Kestle Well just south of town
was brought in in 1945. This well
was never used very extensively
since poor tests were obtained
and its Use was discontinued
within a few years. In 1949 a
major addition to the water
system was completed. In that
year the Moodie Well began to
contribute water to the village
supply. The cost of the 50 foot
well, the three miles of six inch
main from the well to the village
system and other works cost
$48,000.
In 1960 the Commission added a
fourth well when it sank the Hicks
Well primarily as a stand-by or
extra supply of water for dry
periods.
The major waterworks job
undertaken by the Commission
during the post war period was,
of course, the sharing and par-
ticipation in the Morrison Dam
project. For some years prior to
1958 when the dam was com-
pleted there had been con-
siderable concern over the
shortage of water in Exeter. In
1954 the Canadian Canners,
Council, and the Commission
discussed the water supply
problem. The Canning Factory
had for years drawn water from
the local dam; this had been done
using a pump and engine which
were set up at the dam. The
water was carried to the factory
in an above ground pipe. All of
this equipment including the pipe
were there only during the
canning season. In 1955 the
Commission built an 8 inch cast
iron main from the local dam to
the Canadian Canners plant. The
pump, engine and small-
chlorinator were set up tem-
porarily at the dam. 1955 was the
first year that the Commission
sold river water to the Canadian
Canners. Before that the Canning
factory had apparently operated
the system. In 1955 the Com-
mission sold 4 million Imperial
Gallons of river water to the
Canning factory.
But, as indicated the Canadian
Canners considered that the
potential supply in the local dam
was inadequate and felt the town
and the commission should do
something to relieve this shor-
tage, There was considerable
discussion in 1954 and 1955 that
the town and the Canadian
Canners had some kind of
agreement that if a guaranteed
water supply were forthcoming
the Company would undertake
expansion of the Exeter plant.
However, in 1955 Mayor R. E.
Pooley said that "the town never
had a written agreement with the
company — it was a verbal un-
derstanding that if the Town
secured an adequate water
supply a sizeable addition would
be erected" at the local plant.
The mayor went on to say that a
company official had assured the
town that the company would still
expand the factory if the supply
of water from the proposed dam
materialized. At the same
meeting Reeve MacKenzie said
that the purchase of Canadian
Canners by the California
Packing Company "makes our
obligation to supply water even
larger than before."
The Morrison Dam project was
quite a controversial issue at the
time. The Ausable Authority
under whose jurisdiction the dam
would be built was enthusiastic
about the idea since a dam
somewhere in this area had been
recommended in the 1949
Authority report. Andrew Dixon,
John Morrison and other
members of the Authority urged
its construction since it would
provide a reservoir to store water
for the low flow period and help
control spring run off; it would
also provide a recreational area
of some merit. The Council and
the Commission supported the
dam's construction for other
reasons; both bodies wished to
secure the water supply that
would be available for the
Canning factory since it
represented Exeter's principal
industrial activity.
The Municipal 'Board ruled
shortly after that no vote was-
required and the Council,
Commission and the Authority
which was the actual agency
responsible for undertaking the
work proceeded with the plans.
The details, problems, price
changes, tendering problems and
so on occupied considerable time
and cannot be gone into here. It is
enough for the purposes of this
article to say that finally in 1957
the contract was awarded to the
Pearce Construction Company of
Hagersville who had submitted
the lowest tender of $168,000;
there were three other bids,
considerably higher: The dam
itself was finished in 1958 and
named the John A. Morrison
Dam in honour of the Authority
Chairman. The dam provided a
storage capacity of fifty million
gallons and when the stop logs
were added an additional fifteen
million gallons could be stored.
This fifty-five million gallons plus
the local dam's five million
gallons gives the Commission a
source of some sixty million
gallons to provide to the canning
factory.
In the hydro department the
Commission was able to do very
little during the war years. In
1940 the number of hydro
customers would have been about
400, The rates paid in 1940 in-
cluded those given below:
Domestic - 3 cents per kwh for
the first 60 hours and 9 cents per
kwh for over 60 hours. The
minimum bill was about 83 cents.
Flat rate water heaters were 44
cents per 100 watts per month.
The Ontario Hydro rates to the
commission in 1940 were $34.50
per horse power per year. It will
be remembered that this was
— Please turn to page 29
the
St.
vas
ked
4,
Dr.
ys,
vas
St,
the
in
not,
be
rio
lso
an
St.
to
ke.
in
in
,on
,he
ay
'er
le,
so
to
ad
11.
rig
er
a
to
)1t
Id
rn
ilt
of
le
s.
g
ie
n
h
-
a
r
a