HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe New Era, 1882-02-02, Page 5.1 i I'll, .1 , -1 I � I I � �, '_' I
I , , `_ I I I : I , . -, . ,
�, �, � , , � , � , � "� � I � I , I � : I I " ", I' I I � I
I ,_ I I �, , , I ,,; , � ..- .
�� 1, , 1 � I �
. I I � _. . I I, . '''"' ", I I 1�1 I
� I . � , -
, , I 1� �, , , " ,l ,_ 1: . _ l, I . I
- ,
I I :1 , ,; , .,: I I . � .
. , :1 : �, � � I
. � I I . ,
.
, � , I . I ..
" l! ,:1 I I � . I I . � . : . ��
. :,, � "I I � � � . I I . � I �."
1. '. , . I-
I ; , : - .1 � .
I �' . ; I - . � I � I .1
1 .1. . 0 . 1. .
� � . - i .
I . . .. , . , . . ..
. . . I. . I - - .
I - ....-
. _�r .. __ , .
. -. �' .1 . 1. �.. 1. �
" I - � - I .. , 1. �11 I I—, 11 7111_�,.7_ -1-
� I
I � I �
� I - . �
� I
. . I . �
I � � .. -,
I I ��
A I . - li .
" 11 , I I I
� , �, . .1 � : . k I
.. I . . . I I � . I . . I .
� . I I I . -
. . � . � 1. .. -
I , , I � - . I 11 . I . � '.
. I . I . I I .
. . I . ), , , �, I
. " .. I - , .
I I - RM -
� . �11 71, -1.11-1.,.l.".." � .
I I � .31 1 "I,."o!"-,, �----,;F-�-?,--7,�"--4----"�l-- - 1-1 ,�,47;��
�
I I I . I , � . ,� .1 I �, , IV ,
� , � I I- I � 90� 7
. � , � -- , I 7 77
, , �
� �. . � � k , . .
I � I I I I : ,� -
I . � . � I 1. I � � I . "� I
. I � . I . I .1 I
. I
I 1� : � I I I � _
I I I . � I � . . i . , �1. �
.. . I I 1. I 11 I '. � I �11 ,� 11 ; _
. I I I � I , I I I 1�
� . .; � I I � I I I I I I � I I 1. I I - 1, � � I : I . I',,
� m � ,. I . ,� . � � I � . I � ., I I - ': � I � � . � I I
I I I . I . . , 1 4 - I I .1 I 1. I � 1. , , , .�
. . I � � I �
� 1� I I � I . I I I i . : " . � I .
� � I . I . . I � I � I I 1; � � � I 1 4 , I I : , . .
�, _ I
. I . . .. I I 1A , . I'- � I I , ,�_11.11 .
. .1 � 1� __ � . I I I � I . . �, .
I I - �. � . 1, I
. I 11 ".
, 1 � . � . .1 1�1 . I I I
,
. � . I !P IS - eoeoch
1010 P. � , ,; . I
.,
. I INK r - Xto . �
. . I .
. - I . .
,
aseasure Of the I I q814jui6; the p'riftci.
coal log � , ,
- 01�5 and o6ibjects of wh.-h t, ely within
I � I I . to sirelpil. irc, �
I �
, 11 "I . . .
J a
down by Sir Johii either , in'bi tellOtt of,1868 pre�.eh(sitiTes . are � more � un . ited than 1 ours, an(t � , . - ' I
or in his Speech. in 187 . ,
1; , No ne has c6roteri-
, I I ,,, r I ;�hoie support sii �Tqlnh is always.afil� to ae- . :
�
. .
. . Dzu'VEIKElk ONSIX0,TAX ]PRPATZ
"
their 'province. " , (Heat, hohr.) -Th4 was
I
1"
I
ed that it wag unconstitutional or in excess - p' d upo
I - ' ?o P vibat: isthia i6al power that forcii,
1,
., - .
, N- 1. ..-.. 11 ,,, . *, * T". POP A
. :, - � 01 ii0ifivO .
L good Constitutional iaw,,imd the positi
. �., on ta.
I
of 'our juris,flotiou. -Xeithe'ri 1 call, kit be Sir JohuJs hostile attitude ? 'Should *9 not - ,�o
- ; Juri I I
.1
. .. t . � � *
, 011411811�47vx -
iaril'�er wAs, the same,',!p
klen by Mr"L F1 L 'e*ttion,
,
I
Contended that- it was till tons , to- the thin Is .
- I ' ' ! -
I y our' 'political differences aside "and "
. -
. -4 � -
' " . I
I "i by $irJehn� Stacdoxial on-
64- waii is 1 4
I
illt8rests:'Of the whole D5winio". Th
. I . � e it"dai6ne min fjy.6ur own krolri[lte? (�,V. '
a, 34.0t
Mr. It6gs,said there were.ty!o bj s in
josi ... I -bcc�asiong. Ron, gentlemen had an
grouild that the. hoO. gezitle
0741Y I -.1, 1. men Op- plause.) Although an. admirer of the Aticr-, - - -,
the Speech from the Thr9ne tbjalfldvershs�
, .
dowed all otheri, -and' the remarks Of all pro-
inb4tifided Will' i - Sir"John, . all. d- claimed:
' ' i ho -was ill,, g6llest constitutional lawyer
that
i
poefte justify- its disallowance' . �
,is that in ney General,' and having, ftill'60jifidence Jil . . . -
, pinion. � , given
-their,,.o. - , thO ' contl4insatiow � - big Governmopont,' heir managem'cni�d -
and in t I
direebood. to
vious, a eak6re had been mainly �
. .
'Wl
tut to deal 1 ith
iu -the Dominion., Ris , abilities- S168 a 6tit�s.
mOU' " ' - - " ' Ross)
, I I
Uc:L io�n, 'was ingufficient. � (Loud, ap. � . I
'M 1!4�- 4 _ � I I I the, affairs of 'the -Province,. so, vital di&� he .
I I ,
When bon-, ntlection on 'this
before .proVeding
them � .
an dt' I (Ur.,
OnStItUtIO118 �"IaWyOr llt,, � �
Phlus9l' side Consider th � . '' I
� . oe retaining this territory to the
Yid4dbi ttat
them:U would take occasion t6=preaQ 11414-
W ot"
V.. -Old? net. dcsij.�t' � Before" le;aring"thioi subie,
Ill
.
of the Cisime'd this arbitrary, a . , �
- I Ild tuaterial prosperity, fatureAfiflueticei;'dild i&� ,
,
. -nowoo3 .
fiction that the doveinment had kotog�
- I
. '110 w9ul4 read some of Sir Jolin'MkoiaoniAd's
I I I
exercise of the ve to I
, . '
whbl�Y uupr�c.edouted . t Tall0elcelit Of 'the Provinoie, .that if by his , :
mified �o wait,,. no longer for the'41114 44ile--
litteofaliDea C4,thie Lal 4ght he
_ ibjebt,' glad. I the
I .
.
Power N L � - the 6ppogition,, I . I I
vas a direct at&ck hpou".respoasible hon. frien'd; ,the leader :of
ment of the accounts bet*een the POU*ion
� I . -
,wQqd.b6:4@b to in''
. show that his action veto-
-
, I �
government ad ,ohlA, if , allowed surelY isuPplai�tiiji-the'Atiorney,G'Ofi'6raI and�ho'n. � , �
� apd,thiio Province, before. wakiii. the d1stri-
I g ' L
� ilij ,
;- this'biii, and' "k n Lby h6n;
. the' podition ta e
' I
lead , , .
I .
to, 'the break4 up-of'conledera'tion, hoii.' gentlimen opposite 'taking' Poggessibli,-of tile ,
,
'
Fund, a it
hutioll. of the Land Improtomoint . I
.._Qtlemelj L �
d i ., .
6pposite in. support'o f that Vet 6,
1wbQ
We I I
�re guilty of ,qveri troa - tr O�t& . I L
. � gentlemen Said. W I � easurr benches, rio would thpieb . . . �,
" ' y so.
bad announced their detertain ation to pay
dirwt1fopposid3o'the position formerly
'would,
L I . I cure hor'rikfita I L . L
I The Reform party. to the disputed territory, ba' *
GOW had doue.moie to
over to the muicipalities the 4111911110 to which
.
tak6* by that, gentlellian... , He hows
I L I I .
. . I
bring about ookifederition' than bon. ,gentl would gladly cross the'lloor,of the, Aotiss� ,: . L , I
I 13 I .
"their
. . they were �entitled- There. -ere Plenty :Of
. I.,
ever, before proceeding to quote Sir I Jobrf� give
I 'L .
L, I
I ��moa opposite; or' ' ' were as I . .arid "I I
, leaderso and,. talieIis s�aV ad a member of the O` *t* - I
Pposi ion
-funds in the Provincial treasury to enable
bon. gentlemen some further quotatidns'from
I � LL
.
anxious, orperhaps more.so., to -avoid anything rather than the Pr'dvidbe, ShOLu'Id "�te 4081)6ile� : . , . I
,
'
them to do so, and the ultimate rePaYMg11t.
Mr. Toda,s'work, he . d ,op - ,
"at lugualit, to the
that would 6nolto destroy it, And-indroler , that belonged to�bej.L (Ap., ' ' ;
� 0Vthe_teifitoiy _ . I
. I � '
.1 I by the Dominion Government- was assured.
.
I
92'a apetibit Of the British North America
I 4 . , L "
I
to slid* from' which side of the, House these plauge.).' But Sit Johia4liged ' I I I I
k ' ,
' b
,. There was ano, ilier ma�ter that on. gentle-
-
*1 ,
Act, these1poal logis atures possess p6'wers of
- I ,
'01141d ,new.per.
treasonable tendencies emanated, hd'wpuld feidtly well wh� he Could � .
I upoll.. .At the
"" L 11
.
119
I . . . men oppogite'w6re end to make a
V:r-i
legislatioh so -complete end absolute�, wAin
".depend .
� 4 . . �
quotethe conoiluditia words of' Sir John lqac,- red6fit'TOZYL Convention the hon leader of th ... 1.1'. I . �
� , , -
�W , ,
i-eady
I
.. . little capit4l out"of-the r e9cheat case
,
.
- -
their eiclugive,jurisdiation, as, th6se,enjo�e&
sple6ch' I I
i6fer' , opp�o
.donald in the same a I ab 6ition 11spoice out � rog ,i� -it, ,
I , I
I ,;76i6oso and Wag
-in which'the Supreme Court 1has held 11,10
by the Dominion kailiament, or'even .by the'
I I .1 .
�ed �to. ' Sir, John, Said- "The Goveruthent reported tha:tliisspoile6h wa�iath'ergq'perulous � ." -1. . .. .
I . I
property effelleated. for want of h6ire.should
Mother Country, ,in. their ies]��ctivp SI)h,eres.11.
I
of . the Dominiou. could Dot set, aild, they r,rotest,agaifistAbe indifference to Ontai - ib.Ais-,', - '", I I
'
. go to 6 1) i6ion Govornment-instead'of-to-
�- 0. Om 4
(Hear.) Hon.--ge-:utWff6wga�d-cfti-ut,&d- spee-cheg,-
. . 1. � .1
-.Woiild-ha�v�-bedii--guil,ty��f'-a-v-iolerit--w-rencli--piayed by-'his'-leadbre-A-0, - '' ---.-
, . ttawa-.-7�A-ppliuve.)- %
"" * I
. �to
the Proviincial: It was very, inuoh to re.
11.
,of theofil.6n. Mr. Macke
. lizie: and'the Hon.
I - I -
� f' b they -held a
OfAhe,cOustitution, I , t�caqsq, I Did the b . b ' - , I �
. I - or. fzerttlem-an me�4, y. that, co�vekl', . 1,
-pinion,
gretted that th 3 majority of that court had
4
n
Georg"rown -to show that it wag inte! did,
different- 0 they phould' set, u . . I-
. * I5 ,their ly to 1int �at'tho uupatrioti6�'ciihiS6 -Si� John . . ,
. . , .
come to that conclusion against the Opinion
- that tie Provi�ces should conced6 their right 8
. �
'
. �
Own j64-guio,ut-against th6solemn'decision of _ - � I .
� � was pursuiag.in'!re4ard tOL Ohtaji6 .. I . ,
. I interests 9 , - I
'
.
. of the Chief Justice and Senior Judge, act so
- I
iff eukering !�j 6 confederation, bilt'Mr. Todd
a Province, in a matter .entir6fy withi I I ,- � . . ",
- in the. 1�et'hiih'tell the bon. .,gentleman 'that if- the ", � -
'' . much oil account of the, M6rcer estate, bpt
held "that the rights'of local Self government
control:of tlist Province. " . (Loud aptola&6;') Ontario -Opposition desires to ree ; ` th t' ' � ' '
. eive,. a t , ,
that if their decision was upheld, by the''Privy
heretofore concedeoito the,iseve" 'PrdVi i
1111ces,
Had not, Mr. iftoss.asked-tbe': Minister of, cooimidekti ' ' I I
�
� I ion which they�zre entitled to from 1 1� ..
. Council, the Dominion, and not.the Province,
'ral
of the Dominion;'are not',in any wise impaired-
I �
Justice at Ottawa Set ng his opinion against Sir John, an I & which �. for -On I tario's interests
� would be entitled to Such estates in future.
- . ..
by -theie- having entered'irito� a federal cotn.�
,,_�
,gh,t, . - -, � .
,,,
the Act,pad4ed by. that Hot! �e�? Was -it he would wish them 0 possess, it is not 6i � : "I
.
The Attorney General was fully justified in
pact' and that n6 infringement upon- thoso;
. ,
that aft6i an expression of opinion like hat, gentle hiriti�ois to Sir JohWs hostile
. :� -
. appealing to the Privy Coitucil., ffon.geutle�
_'
'hi6h Would be at variance with coo:
rights' ' . I I
I . ,attitude . : ,
Si , r JZolixi Macolonald,should,:permit .an ,inter-, to WA PrOvin6e that it will be 6bta � iried, biit . I
.1 ,
� ' I
I
I men,.opposite sa I
1. fd that if t1l'a case went
..
-tit-tio- .1 usage, -or with tb:e'l I
. . . ibeity 9f action
would by bol'dly: -,,, .-. k. I . ''I . . I- , : ,'�
ferenco,with, their legislation?- ,,'He .
. � I , spda -Ing out .in meeting,.,! and, :.
, " , ,
. . ' t the Province, we would have to re-,
'&"- ;
I f.tioltothe Dominion the amount .
. expended
y . d'by the Pr6,�ihbe§, when
I
previous .
.
under ill =zit�Ol. of,the Imperial Go,v-
,
.
quote. the final� ,Words . in the speech, of � Sir I
� __-. I I . -P alulY' filling- him, that � while' in political I .
,Ti)hnMao4'onaid:-",Tbe,�C6tistituti6n,#hieh,� sy b ,� I �
� � � . pat y -With him on lJontinion questions,, ' ' .
" "" Do I I I I 1. I
I by the Province for. the Mercer Reformatory
ernment, Would be justigabf�`-bu the partof
� I
.had hifficitowo4ed so ea�ily'and so well, � the "Vital,in, te�rests of , at . e paramount . � � .1
. , aA� He'did not
.1 the,Eye and Bar Infirmary-.!--
beil�eve anything of the kind. The purposes
.
thoe'Domin' &p,IpoIg`ii'ge.)_, ThW
ion executive!'. �� (A ,
* -
bon. , membbi- for. Glehgarry. had . dehied the',
.
,Ontario .
conld.:noi suriiye-the�wfench that.'-w6uld be- tc�polit'ieafallegiance,�an tha I . �
* . ' I d t''in the cou'rse I . 11 I
� - I I
,
ive .the Domittio)a 66ver � rombut,,assurn6d. �Ile' 1p',��.Purgulng in regard to, tliis�bouhdary
'g . ,
'
. for wh;ch the money we s expended wbre so.
I
.
rights of. this .�legislitur'e to, intUrfer , e with
,�� , i
I
di e the, polic'y"or ques tion the"action of .question, ' e'4ill alienate from bi . .
t6 � P" , , , � , .
� , Sty �, . I :
t the -different
' �_ ' ` � "
ev�
laudable and deserving that the Dominion
.. .
rights of private prop and wayl
. . I ,ye y , in,
421,�Cg4� I
t receiVea
� ,iL sla i6vinces on: �C6 ' . I I � -
, tures of
I -
.�e in the'Pr ovince. Lethi .
Ab in p ilk �'�, I
reserved, by the.' tritisb� Nortfil Am '' '
Goverh&ent could not do otherwis e than cda-
dignant, because bi untent a
1-
'
out un6quiVociill It �4:rod he I . .
. I Y on't is question,.-
- e. . *
.. firm them. He desired to refer briefly to t a
t
.1
chec� by, his (Mr. R ") 'reference :"tol -, the:
.1
.rica Act to, those Lokislatux'eg-.'� (Load ap- will. receive far �m6re,consioleratiooa, feom. ,qi,:� ' I ' - ,_
. . , . . I
� '
more important questions mentioned in t e
speqeh, the discussion of which had occupied
tolling Acti. in iriticholahis'Jogislature und
Goo . . . . 11 . er
Saufleld McDonald uiLd4t66k to overridd'the
I . . I
plauge.).,These utterances, T�ere made in,a- JO'h n� "' and may, bringiackjo a Sense ofd
'' ' ' I . - - � utY__ 1, . � I ,
the recireant members-l'of 6iiiarlo - :, , . I
I I
debate on,a motion in,the House of Commous, . it, the' Do. 1
�
so Up so large a share . Of the 'attention of
disposition of -a mau�s-lpropbrtyulidcii bi
. � . 3 will,
I I , . *
.asking the Governor in I , council d.W-Ildw miroiou�Houseo who;. 1ave basely �u . I 1�
, , I
- PpOrWd
bon. members, and he did so, as a layman,
and to deal with it -in a different mann ekthial.
,te .�, .�
the Act, until.the,Roman Catholius'aggrieve their own -proviric ' I
i I � I , . 4 . � d` -'the globliation 'of I e.: Sir � i.
I I with considerable- trepidation, from the fact,
he desired. The veto poWei?:-'��SS illvd"A,
.1,
Should bate all. -oppDrtunity,of.bringing, the John s0told to be. acting ", ifhe was . con fident I I.. ., ,.
'judicially
that the rbembe� for G'Ierogarty, in his speech
`6d,
then; but Slr4oh�. lefug6di"to' ihterfeido.`. Re.`
�
'
matter I
before the Prity"Coilucil.: he could countupon the Support 6f h ' 7'
' I . . I On. gen...,
'Macdonald
on -a previous evening, expressed the
1 ,. .
course was had to the. courLs to. declare that
.
I . I I
Sir John � I I ,4t,�Smcu opposite,
Qppogjffig'� the' motion. I no. matter how 'he t 'I ` '
.. I ramp es ,t : - �
"on
O*
It pe tliat t1hL discussion on tile constitutional
.
lOn's, ..' , .
aet!'bneoustituti I ' Le' t what th!
, us see 0
. ,,
It,,, waq;� J:oeicr�thelcs�.�Carrle L% against .
d' him' Provincial, rights.:; He sincerely': trusted � � - �, '
� , ,
___ ___ (l,u-esti,ana.na.yvv-befGr..ejl.i.a-LiaLil$.QJ=U-I-e-,-elftI
. d H . .
,t ,�age.
qase.'-.`HeWould-.read what
. .
� -'a vi ' d
His Exeeliedey;. ho hewould be-disalopointed in this. H � . I L
. wever, a ise .. - big �
by, - � 0, trust- '
'
.
to the legal members.
+,,,.,g,,,,,3,(.,on ,that
_
._
. gal YT� .... --
. was.sai y ance or , erine
r "pragie i'
Ir - �' �rE
- - j I
-,�adviseol. ,. Sir-4--ohni�-au-tholize& --ed-ottri-friends-o kak' � I
-by
41inisters '
--
., . -
,
.11 �� I I ppo e-w-oul"ee " I
�� , , . Alle-giaxi-t-Y.-
'of
. 0
Mr. Motemaster rose to a point of rder.
1
jadgment:-11 take ikto be, that under 'Con.
to ]p qr'm .1
the, minis,ter� f
Of, Justice' ; , the
1 1 . ancia � . .
the'Prov " I interests �involved, and ,not . .
�t"
He had already explained th-at be in,lao -no
I .
- hilerhtion we have had:'& f6deeal and - ' i
no a
,6iiinibing ' t the Statutes' sought only record their t t "' ' t* , f '' ,
, House of C . pro is against the ac ion; o, �
'
ill '
I
Shah statement in his Epeeeb, aoo� he th6aght
I _1
I legislative union; -that to the Ptbviricfal Leigis "'
*c6mmibted *the'
. ,,
to be disd,116wed,' were wit in t e 4 Domihidn�Goyernmebt, but back it "' b � ,
1, i hi ,,'ompefenc� 'the
� � .. I � , . - ,� I � up� Y:;,
the matter should not again be referred to�. -
I%ture is ` ' ' jisi�te,
. power .to. Is
,, '.
of the pr6vfficial egiblature, and t at'ite was, marilylduti�Aen words 'that will�,I ,,, � �
I h �
I I - I . :_ � . ;1 I . . bear�',llo ' � : I I
Mr. Ross said be was glad the hun. gentle.
. I
'within a range of. subjects, indeed. litdite1
. . '
I 6 .1 . �
ro o prop, I
t tred to .00mply With their request. miscons ruction. I Our fri6hols opposite hold ,',
'
inan had on matnr6 reflection backed oub of
I 1.
the popiti.con he biad talfen the ottier night.
I .
but within these' pxes4riboid, limi I ' ,
ts . t . he right
,
of the fiegislai�iie,ifj.,i.6sdlut�.,,.. . Jd
. I �Mi.. stic"
�. I
. - I I 14 . , �
(Applause.) That, was, done ii . 14 the face of a greAt1p9wbr .orgood, or evil to.tfi& province, I .
, � .1 I .
the protei . I 1:, eterrmne&dt. , , ,
� As 6f:,a lame number �6f'Roman .on this:queiti6n. A firm and d ' i i ' I .: � � .
' -a
. The bon. gentlenian was a speaks fluency
r"Of
a, aid -','As ..to tlai.�dwer to pass -Acts�
.. -
=Inologr
Catholics ,in'
. .. I I I , low I u eon. an open� eds . I I
the i. faae ''of - a resolu6 tit ` thicit,part, a.Cordial I a , - , .1 ��, I I % I "
- � �
;
. and eloquence, and on thia,occasim as on
pr, . -
11
1, operty, that t a Legislatu're It,,
of � mops,, opera ion- 1,;
.,: 'majo.rity ,of, th6 ft�ouse 'of!'Cona 6 -not mereiy,in form but in reglity�_ . "' " .' '
. " , ,' � . .
others he had no doubt allowed his volubility
that,power in 311,04ses to th6'lsame unlimited
.
! �.;
� .
in a. case in which,tho rigbts of Alie. whoY"With ,the Attorney General in the assertion fo. :
�� " , - .
.
to carry him in advance of his thon�hts and
.-
e'U',ut- d'i Itbe Impeiial.-Pirhimerob ,in the
. I
'Catholic .popul�ti'oil',of!,.ew-.Brnnsv�,ick were 'Our rights, will Aecure4hat weJustly claim..,, " :'
I
'';
hisJudgment. There was.no doubt that he
United Kingdom 'I have-not, the slightest
. - 1. I �
, ,
adeci6d� � hii.1'.'notwithstariding, their urgent While �, 4 �.hail,. beaited, and', thidd acoldi. - '' '
, . ;1 � . I
� ,
"' �'Pstitlftional '
made use of. the expressions -attr
S ibuted to,
to .
him. In addition expressing the hope that
,
I P11101 I is. I 1�
doubt." - (Ap'olit4e.) i Th :IEEon. I IC
' ' e -
s�ioner of Crown Lgridi had refoarroed 40,1_thel'
�
titi hi ; -
I and earnest'r6p,iesen a Ion, is co, nee,-, ma e �. i?-Ouc .a. way. ag, to &'n-
i ' ''."h I I I � i: �, I
c8c � ' l. oll.,
11 �
I Q.j' , , I "t, " , - ,tb ' . .1- I '' . ;
Mebtion,to itbe inter erence with pro5vincial vey� e, impresudilthaC their patty alle'giartoe , - - ��,�'_
i,o '
the lay'men would leave these coiistitfitibnal
-ungraciou-Via'u,nerlid wiii0ft iliis% veto p "", �
I ower.
legiilation*ag 8irong,:that he declined even will not be lessened� even if, I..
. 1 - I 1, Our rights are' de- - ,'
. questions for the legal -men to,dea I with; be
.� .''
-.bad been exer'elseid.w this ' h ' '
, ease, ' t a first. 'in-
'
1 I
to:'obepthe Wished Of the ParIfameat he pre. iji,edi wili,'but,donflim our d' 'Iers in their ' , , '
, . � . espo;l - I .
'one, ''and.
. pronfis3d that the legal members would leave
�
� ey had .of it, bejng,� h
6m�tioli:" th ' , , tough, the
I 11
sideol,over� - "Yet, When, Intl uential I .
, , , . . , - . couYse of insulCand aggression, anof-precip'Itata" :Nl
i I � -_ , , . .
�he Is
i y oltiestions to be dealt with by the lay-
coI.Umn8'Of the mail '' - _t,
pewslihper.�, T be.legdSi
, I .
w 6 althy supporter'. asks hi�s� c ohs 'en � to th � e , a' 1� c
Ohilict �ffiai would, , h be I .
d', v6rily bel* " d' , ' ' .
I leve
�1�titl
men. (Cheers.) He (' Mr. Ross) would, how.
.. -
It . .- ,
,of the Opposition had rephedj�-- t at lit.was,�l
'
, I
velto:,ofilie St trearns-Bill, dbih which aff6ct6d ., to our promising conledeiat" , , I I
... ion. ("ge, I
- - . -1 .1 . - *,�
.. . I .
.1 �orer, with the bon. gentleman's &aciou . s per-
.. I . . ,hty opin.
mission, prooeed,to give some weig
t . , , , t',, I ., 4f I
�
not custoulikryjp iy;e-no tee.* the-intentipa'l-
- .
to vet fe I W ia- , -
I t,Mr.'.To'dd 7 sgy4� oil
. I .ari, . ....
th,6-riglits"of Abbod'y but th", . I
- at.suppo�tcv bim- henr.) " In. urging, -them' lto,- this.;- course .,, : . , - � :,
;self;�hdwa� ready At once'to sacrifi4 Ili It * ' ' - - ' It '' � � _' �u,t�eir dw� ,
, .1 is ,. P was. urging t em- a.pourseJ
, '' * ',
..
. . . I 1�hl(,h he
. long of constitutionplautbori,ir,ff,'
this, E�tid,b6ij,;,ge,iiticr,n�li'�i6i.ti,d..�'n'ot��ay iii�t�,
.
'
i, I' I ,to ,,, I
�cons itutional,princip es. ,(Applause.) 'AVho interoAts, a, S a pArty.I I f be' Were'onl I i. , "..
I . � y ing, , -
00" I
,
hough
t A the bon.' gentl6man would ac6ept
Mr -with all' � atboriiies ,�Abi I - '
. Todd, a U.4, IS
,
' e Optioned, were gt to a party Avantaga, he'-,worilol ing . - I
. b6fi,�,_gerltlemau C . lifty of li 1""
i . 1. n.th -1 ,
�b ' ' '
V
. rith respect, and first be, would read the ,it.
I I terences of a 'gentleman who claim -ed to be.
p. Would state as file phi�ficb,tilat.'whIt
reach � . i,�, ll,�
w" uOt corrept. Ho.,sayg'sot.�sge 37'�:"'Thq-'
, I
I -wrench t6,the Con. etter �than t 'at . the3i,; should' continue in I � I..
,1-4r�aso�. llpw�, J4e� h -
'6ituti6a bidb6en given, and appaientl, : t6e. course, they,sg�m to 6 t�tnb.61 , , * �, I
Y with., . - 1. I
Yphrsuing,.,
�4 �becanse
.
a great constitutional .auth6rity, and whose s
praetice has been bef 0 dki`:_� ,�,
V.64-1Gkilif flic.'" Xquie,
1. I - , ... I . ,. i I
ihe,1dil Concurrence of bon; geuilemen:.-o�w lie had ti� , . I
I : I C muoilifaith-in the'indepen,-, I
-
I , ' bon rdember
claims, although a JAj,Vsn,`6�
99urse of disallowing an iieb ;to c4k�fi,6 att�h'..
, . .
posite., it was said that I they Were raising ,'dincb and manhood of the eledto . I '.
r .. 11 I 11 ra of On tario I
, �
foir Weagitrry would iiot di��ute. , He, would
.., .
tion of the P7 ovincial Gove�ii:�hentilwfts7ob-'
. . . .
I . ."�
.bugbears bUtbe would ssy,,,t6uch!ng, this to.beli6yethaftli�y will.hut�dphru 11 � I I
" I . � � . WiCh'indig- . I., � �, '41
. e'
r ad from an article in the Oweii Sound Times,
jectionable Z"reathrois, au4, g[voll. V.,
, 1. .1 ` t4em', .an,,
'i5f,'-1
'grave pom,iitational.questibil, that the �Con- I nation, that representative who sh6u14'- fail , � ' "
, . . � '
. 06ers and I ghter,) edited and conducted
. . aq, '
by -the bon. iii�omber fo� -North Grey.,(Mr.
.1 - - . or
opportunity� prompting, it
. - s " repeal 11 - �, i
amel - . .
Anent." ,, (Heilr, bear.) L 8oin'etimew.tbo' 1
I I
*
14i�.
a .- � ., 1. I "
in "I � ,�
tit uAloh was'' dang;r iind1he; existence' of � with,all bis.,PO �,.phzld ill. �
' '�' .. .. wer and .' v i oi * ce, It to "' Ii -
' '
our great.,donfederation.imPerill a�,-andthey rights of his, Province against erspo iation at .� � -
" , ' '
Creighton.) Mr.Rosoprocee4eat id
I dreudain
. . I I
1,11"Oesaity. _26f, 1h 6 ed Swl-:ShbkfAl,� .-L't e,Aiii3�.,;Kt:U'V1jjf..�
for'.' dffZl6wance ' but. ' Al �
,
badi'tho declaration of. ihe, lesdezo"� I Of, a, jeklous: �rivaI_ 11 I L..
... � �,,,t�",.;�., of- I--- _Qte instigation I (Cliders ) ", ,�', ,'�
_�____��_��-L'_Z_-.'�ao_ -,__f"d-_� � ;. - .' �' �..
.
. oonsiderablo interruptions from op�osition
�t Such a L' � tredrns�
Act was to .age L'T'll6y _ htha!;
vir6
' . L - 1, I
I . . . , , _ ,
-urvivoo I I - _167 i -
,co u ol n ot r AbAf-*�ieiidh�t�AL7!woulol, her A.our erritory7,lias7. �� t&16h�.4 t%t_'6'a't,L ]_�
L � ;
, , I I , r 4 * ' J
' '
11 Is 216102bers, an article on the disallowance of
_,O,)I,
' ' L
to corlsiaai� ille tiatter,�,'aud' du6tig'' all that.
I ,_ ,, , 'L .
111,91"riii if ihebominion, *antborifies po'resmn . . bortu a a , ri es,.are� s :,i Where'th( ,. , . "L ,
ju 9 ,
, _1 . -,! &u,rts and ,
I ,
- ,
I I n that
. I the Streams Bill i , �oaper, In which. the
- -, writer although condemning the jassage of
' I '
' 11
, to()k-.n(l*l b ppo . rtarkity o'f-dii'minuni�
time Ill I I '
itythe '
ed' thus �to iuterfere---Aith.j:the_ establishSol PrivY CoolncifmaY' decido fhoi�r ,t � b,� - e, , and . , �_ ,�
1. . L that L if We li'llVe I I �
. . I
i4gliti � of ,the' ProvinC68 116g,gin I g ''. tb . 6, r par I Occiopied more L than we. are- ' L 11.
I I
�� '
. the bill as an interference with private rights,
� I
eating Ontario (�iivernment, th"6ir i
� . I ., , �� "`�,'ell'
- , � ,
I-
tion Ofyetoiug'66 Act. NUUld 110W.:-1).111-
�, '', � , L . � .
I . hle.
don of�the hon.- tuber f6t,Glengarry (Nf . legally eutitlt4 iol-it is but just tl I
. r I . iae L
. 'L � I I I Jt should 1
� et, thought the vetoing of that bil I migl�b be
. . 17&ught*with grave'constitutioual con8equen.
.
,:'H04-
- . . 111_�
cecd� to pits fill authority. oil '.-C�oagtlt��'Iopa .
. - '_ .
,
oMmtei) forlaviug; Afid,he-a layinah, pre- be taken from, no. Bu� it was j ust because L L �
N1 I
t ' , " , i 't b , � -
,nmod to tpoa6h,upon ;i 46kal Sod con4itu. there " were different :opinions. as,,, o w ere , .1
cose. -Re (Mr. Ross) thought, the views rjx.'
''
�u�f;4!-,rity which -bon., gen'tibm'en opp6aitia.
, - . ,�
.NF re, boulid. to 440ept'. i46116 , e4oared t1hey-..
e
4
� ifouiFshbject'he L:WOUI d 'Conclude, hig:rematks th�se boundaries P.1ioull be that jho�r�L,��ag_alll 4 � , 'L, 1: I
1. ' - ' 1� . I I - I . , ., , ";,- . , `
- ' � - : ""',
. reseed in that irticle were ,mok in' aco
11 e Ord
. ":k, t ", _:,:
' , h all
were like the family- o I the ric ML �� ill� j&
�LUJ)o � � ' I
h' - �n" (L�ud dpplause�) L ' al'bitration at, all. ' ere, . as, no iL ega f- , , �-
U,�t 11 is questi( . _ ' If tu W, "
- " ' "
. with, high conatitu than the
tional authorities,
.
Ontleyinn had. del
; Speech the' her.. i ivered in
-
- L
par,, ble, they -were so. donfiri"d- jn-� their "evil '
L
ways aud in titeii. ullboilk(, thiiCeveii an a rogelre
. . - F, I I
Alt, Fr"er, And- for a-lay1gin. the . lion. dotibt as'to�,these, bouriddrics:, th " Id 6"'
" - - - . ,ere Nvou � a., � ..
8 ric'exceedingly well , I I '. 119 , di�ipute. There wero -but.. fwo,,C;bursm',',,�. I
' �," ' 'L
��e6tletiiauhas; 9 L I . . ,, 11 . .1 .t'' .1 - , ,
, -
.. ItR46 �Iouse that day. The,one was writ-
I
. ten under the bracing air of the Georgian Bay,
. :cOul ,
from hehien, or oneIrbinv-tho dea�d of "not,
detheratotbefieveindr6pent. (Lau�zb-
- -hic I
, L'. Nlr� 11�4 �j)i6ceeled. to deal with the that. open by Vi -,li' io t,lkermin6'ithi3 ulat er,-,;%A� - I , '
& , L �d , . d . H . . . I , S, L . 1. . -_--1 � ;. ",� , , ,
6"L - I
ter. t, the-' oun aryaW.ar . . e L Said, not appeal�tco.the:Court am the Privy Couuel,L"'' L., ; L-
I ,
Lo,�,ah
the other was spoken aeid, arid influ'cheed by
I
113"gil
t.r. 14e atith6riiy'lle was Abb;7tb: quote
�_
,wee couWooratiofi bad &"re'been a ,question' involving chill esg.dehip, and'edst6, sr. ." �
, ' " ' , , '� L ' L'� � , � �
the virul6tit political atmosphere that h6fe
surrounded him. Hon. gentl�men opposite
�
' 'L I � 1-
if not yet in,azigeli had not:116n& a"go" 4 pn.q.0 . tie-,
. 10
. 1, 1:
bittailon;4 : �
upon Which -it behoavei the pe6ple oftbatario to - Tbolatterivss'ehosief. Botlitbei % IL , :
I , . L � ' ' '' L 1�11
�t.o d . . � L I ".' I �
D "
Stan& together rnore;5rutly, shoulder,. h6ul.- bmittipti ,,tn"!'Fiiovitio,i�1'66v(iriimbnt,�agree'd 1 41.
.
have endeavored tar shirk 'tile 'real qucstion
ed -his expectation. of being Ono. :JL4ii&r,6i
I -,-),
in 1871 ail Act,w4i pss4edb?!thb LosgiAliburd
I . I
'. L ,, d , ,' �
�dbr, ittAsser,tion of the rights of the Province_ to the arbitration, they appoints ,an arbitra-, - �..,
I � , , , , . , ,. i
. here in dispute.' They' have'turneid. their
.
. whole attention to. proving that the dry legal
of New BrunsmiAia relati ' ih - ;' i
I . on tot e� Common
-jr, --1-g,-,-
Schools of that .Province_'`]'.be_ ,igl-40,nre.-
I
than upon this quest I i6noftbe�iio�Oiern' arxil, for, th ey COi lourred in the Lap
Ii L' . .1 of, LC ' P6inimehtcLf,tW . I 11
Wes L ber 'bo' ticaLolifferences inpirio, the House ommous vote �tho`'L : � ��
'a utidiri6s. All,pci It 1, C, :, �L ' - �' I
. . 'I'll � . ; . I
� power exists in the Dominion Government,to.
. veto Provincial legislation. No one denies
.
was petitioned by the Rin'rolarilbath L olic- , i . t;iial)'
I t-,
'
" �;: .
Should: b&.Iaid aside, and; i16-voke of � this' mooiey'nece84ry to pay the C6StL of,thc:rcfer�' ' . i�
- : .1 1, , - -1 ,L in.LC . � : :
pass an or er ncil. �- - '
I oice Of Ontario, in.all its'ear-. ence,, and they', Sed d . bit I I
A6semb y,'the v. �L ,
. I that such power is -conferred, upon then by the
'for,�
taults. of the Frovin�y �oU to 1�qss t I
., i b - he Bill
' claiming that it,would e -mbfust arid an In.
�
. I , I I
I ud 11 - ; � . � .
neAness and poi�er, with distinct a uneoluf-: 'agreeing i 'OL be bound Ioy.�the' aw'arol. It wag 11, �, 1.
' ,
'were
. B. N. A.- Act, What we ,contend -.'a
fiing,erneur, on t1logir right's.- 4"r' -
he. Act was ' ,
. Vocal iitterance,'sh6uld' be unitedly raisk: 'Acai they . � , .
as fully commiWd'to. the .
�
� L I ,
'as'
I
such power . is to :be ex-
thaf .
iner -
ercised in * a congtitu;onal in& lu'd iln,lfr�
"
, --ii-i"'""'i " " .. ojie��
however, _passed,,:aud th Ro'lu%' .Catb.__._,_
, , __ *I, ,.. _, e. �p
�
't*
ol the VominionLautboiritios pl Ain I y an d e'm' arbitration Wa's Ontario a not were' inz _ ; , ,
an -1 . �
, p4a�j6�1]� �j6ld_that Ototatio-will-sta*nd- a§ one ,hbri'or boun(I 'to, abidoi'. bL�o � thp:�,�Iec,iSio�n. I " � I I
.
the restrgints estabiished by 'co.stituiinnal
.
' The to veto Acte bi. t4e Impe-
gi h .
8 cops and-peop e sent numerous . p e LtIons'
,,
'Ing 4t'h-.'tt the',
to -the Dominion.Gd.vornmenk pray .
,
L ' . ...
. L I 1 4 b' ' -;-j . L'" . I - z -.-.. ,.I,,,. . I-— I
L, T11' t �� I i - i was an unanim9us, :.-kNyard . , ':
I I .
man in., defero6c' 4if her' rig ts i o I territory. . f ecis , 14?11, .1 . � I ,. I
" -41 hQir,7 c6uri' ' - ' ' I . -
"gri6ve ?e ti
usage. power . I
,,,f , �.,
Acin�ight'be'diia]16�,4d,.as�'b6iDg'an'in rjipge-�
.
(Chbers..) ,116 w�a,,11o,iyever_4 ol, e L � ,;� xdiatin� .
, , ; 11 qle,pl�. , .1 - , , . in no - rept - �.. " '� �
I , " I.
,ii � �,
r' ent; exists as absolutg-lfi tho
. fal 11iirli'am .
.
Q -IP i *
I . )ueom, as the power to ?veeo Providei-al gla-
. I 1. . ..
ment upon. tb�ii righ'tio Which'. they, ebj OV6 a �ii
.�Jigibug. � dd ,
I
66 .1 mb6giratibrf� - �-;tiiue�',Vf'
i, )see, t I t, while Ontario's ieptes�n6itives it, .W#,�', cowardly and unpr�cedeu� te
� ' 'L,.= ' � t�'.' " L.: :.�
I i li "'in; 'is ouse, on the loih.4 . ..sg - He Wonl(l4adolit th t it.it-c7�uld,bcsh.own: , , .:. ..
-the 'eak It I �L L .
� .
. lition does in'the Dominion, but she haS.notL
. -at�thb . ,
. .. .1 . I
.
So feileration i' . .�Bgt., Sir -'John', �IT.hcd6bala'*,�:
�� �" f ft.- - I '� � L 'I I �
, e 8 1
e . 0 fa ne4L'by &�regdic..fcor'pfiblic � that- there was arty.fraud,� gioss,partialfty or, ,, I
� .�. � C I.. I
'
. . once exercised it during hdr Whole r .
. sign. He�
n M 'inigjdj.-6t..Jagj' ' l- --`t_0""-
the - ice. ( 87�)j'L. 6k t 6�
. , . L . - .
Xll�toLrecoordtlleir of' I tet, on the pirt.ot the arbitra- .
I 'I. 131. intr - . I Y us for Jinproper,cow u .
hora
, , . I I .
, ,
.
. Would now with the bon. member for Glen-.
- . . " I
.g,ro ... : t'" s7 -egf9tattirep6oseiged c�elus .
lkad
. �
.
, OL . 1. ,
On 0 p .
c� 1 5 r . L rotest,wbich tho','AltoIrfi.ey, i6r I g; orAhat th6' award Wag of such im out-.. I ,
. . � 11 .
I . ' L . I .. I I
, � .1 - , I
'' 'as
- 1. IQ :arry's gracious permission, proceed to quote
� I
0 ra ' 4 iWeduiei.tio'toal 1' tt" '
Vve 6 ith ii us em-
p W
.
. re L I
� I � t 11"e s pon-� rag, 8 Oi is. c ara6ter a s t '
had t 11' ' o%carryits owrr.;con- , . I ,
-1 eral, ,' . fool lt� IlLs. duty, * i ' " LL
I ''I
.
hini the opinionsof one -Who although a lay.
,
.
and he,a vised.the G6viinor General that h.':
. L I . I
, I .
,gible�gitardian'o ?, -- ights of the Province t demnation on, its face, 'there, mi ,hf- be Soule �. , I
I f ih
- I ?I .1. - 0 ' 9, I
, � " I
1. man (laughter) bad a reputation as a oonsti. I
iklto��fc�,�.a LLA to; �]16
ha 'no right to n NY the. Act
e
I . . ., - Ig ItL; . L I 1,
eco e�chsefoi"r�pudiatii buttibthing:of',tb6 � ,.
have�pla6edl.onr r i on irh�iS, yet
.1 . ., ,our L .Jol . . I
" " '
. tutional authority no.t Only'in this Dominion,
L ' ,
. dfte _ b6, , �
. into 4dritiob., This in r ng te.-L'
.t� 99 '
�� ,
'I 1, I
av 114 cottia:bb Shown nothin�,Qf.Lthe'k-hq is:
OieAbet.*hich t se -votes should h e badIM I
ho L,
� t _.,� I.. � 1. 11, . . ' " i ' '
. the whole British Empire, an
but tbrb.0 . .
glot" be
to
WLcffiC6js,Oj the .
ferre to t e* la _ Crawn-they
� , . I
'as i's lordto8t'Lof' rotario, had Clail waS. too ��� ��--: �, :, ,� �
, : the 7 udaiiiiho 0 . hed. � The chAracterof,t`be'inehL LI, *,�, , -, .
. t , _ ,
'Lbeen 'If' L , , ,* !,.1�,,;1;,�',..,
I ,uthqrity 1.21, alf will e6zleedo super.
", .
-
LLL , L ,
repo ea that. the "Ministei of, ,Justice.. was',
"
� 4 �_ �! ,
wialiehe'i�'iroA rende*red lneftectiv�,z by� ,high- or eveu, an insinua ,on o wro -Aolpg,.�,,�.!..I', � ,
ti f
1, I I .. , L. I .. - I L , ng " . .
* , . .1 �.11 I 1.
, r to that'of the bon. member for Glen garry
lie
I himself. I refer to THr. Todd. In his work
,
, I . I
. I it
; I that'.
quite right tbe:� Legislaiti re. was qui e,
..
',.
ijeeg �bf, hoh.,L�, I
vho�apo ogetid uttem gentlemen -TheJa D" - :�,� ,: �:�,-'
30 Obi�i-Jndtice Harrison was, w 11 a i
V . - It, ' ' � - "'I L , ,
,, , � .. - Voj,t,eal� life"al S'L .� ", . I I I .
f r t i6ir friends at Ottawa": arid thp, ,
o' " I trong Supporter of L Sir Job , 4 � _' �
0 eftment in' ,
. on Parliamentary U v the British
I
competent to pass1he Solipol Act,, and it. was,
' 'i L "" I
therefore,, no case for b6minioii'ititer erenoe.
,,:oppostte, , �,L
L , , ;
., , � . . . 1.1..�
' � '
I - -r6 a, map w to, ,in, i '' . . I I .
alf .�, I . �. I
_ fieafted� hay; 6videatly Itictantinanner I ' ndeperod,ence of,�,cliaracter, . - 1,
L I I " I �
' b : 11
'LW '
. colonies,. after d6aling exhaustively: with 'the ,
. . . e ' on the , "_ ,
Is Take,) ,In the debat 4 ,.subje6t
-2 1. '
'I, .71.
'Voted h b )ri,gi . v . Q I'
i" L n , . , ,'(Hoar, a earnesa,, of, judpi�nt, And judicial ability, - L � I
' n hicli�ihbSe . . avp eI - I I . . I I ' ", ' ', � , L, , ".", 1 -14' L I
1. " .
N -ria) controliti colonial
. I . vhole queWon of Inipto
in Provincial.
(L P too
.w tell- pladii in the Mots'& . ir,,
ofCoininow;�S
8. VL
I P ,
. rj'�Ta I A I Sod itlLthe' rovince.
hear-.') ,,,/TIi6y Said theyw6ro prbpalsd to stand; Wa6,U119 ir I rau` � , �. " :,�
'L . , .
.1
' -riglits '�f , �. ' ... '
matters, and Dominion control
John Afabdonal& ipolie. its f6llows';'-Thd-hoh:
L. they �kS, 'Lt le , 'I,
,of -tile- Provihc�. Bu 6is, Hinc I re,presentative the Do- ' . "
b�_ th, t
'� . IL L ' -
' - , L . �'..�:�'
'was ']
'�IZ
.
"'. . =ttc.,",.414-..Sum&�,�..tii,iB--..--"- NYe.._bA7_Q_8L1_-,
�
gendgman (,*N1r. Anglin) 'had, 6ompl'imenteol.
. L, I
a, si . ap( ,z �,
", the dec laltation �atesinah of 16n, arg Six- ,.-
co pl d th t Rtatementwith L� IniniOn,
. A I * :,- I -
. ready - Aeon that�ift the colonies intrusted with
i .
the'Dontiv on Government -to a cbrtain extent
1. L L
TEred their' allco thL I p rieupe, t rs a col-lea6ac Of- 8i�- J61iti's' �
6611di� . . ance to e ,e or YeX 11 � . I
. L
=u
I responsibile government,,, the Royal veto
now exeraised'6n]
upon legislation is y within
limits,
ontheabsence from ilUillterforeu� - . 4 ,th
.. ippil"Mil . ata . iis -d . ine'c-'n' '
a - etions of, the I . c- Confe&,
. -
icy . 11 . , ,
a
on Wag Paramount to4heir, Allo co i"-&4 Government both of' -united 6n-� %, , � I
.1 I 11 .; '
'tort eit.Provirice. 1�s�y ia"' L c " 17 L �' __ -
- t
. .� the bom i6m' or for! Laijol tile Dorninionj a man' in,every.way In '
, ' ' . I
"
'(
Certain prescribed or easily-ascerbain-ed
'tie)
er�tion. '.'As the'offio"e'r'primarily r68 foohsibld,�'
" t Gicy. had � boldly.. (1641ared also. 'pently.qualirle&to repre.s.ent-tbe Dob�inioa-.on, r L,,-
�ji] ,,�
'a t I 'L . _ as had, , L I I �;,
' '
. mere calculations of politicM ex-
. and that
I -egard tb
pediency, Or difference of opinion in i
L -
rt -colonial enactment, 0ould ruf-
tho policy of ,
I ..
onsil,ohiti-l�ei�ts,ho.abulcloiilysa �h - at he had'
yl
taken uniform cave to .1hioirfern-l'in :..no,
'with
f their politi- unt- : . -,
member for Gleugairy, that' a, question oCihiS kinol." The third the
b, r. ' , " L'
., 1, . i '. - 8 " "Ed , . . I
a 116�iaildoi to th6ir,'ch�efs at. -Otfm6'-`was p re,. as bet*een ", these two, was jr, 1 ,Ward ...
0011 R ;�4 Ijy �h inVit, 1. Thornton, t I lie B I . at � nAl , ihW , . - ..
, , Y -,- , . .
- th a .,_ ritisl
reme. kVas thaf i
r,
the
wify'l. what&Ver .
I . any Ac�� pasiod :by
, 861 . � .�Mihister , ,
, ,
' - I I . I , . , �. . :',
*
. . I , , �L � 'I
&_t
fice to inducolhe Urown to veto same,
provideol. only 'it. was within the. -legislative.
I
ghylbf 0F.Provibelizl' L�dis]Xtures if they
. I L
�, . -
'the.
fit) I G. j �ayL:iio to', ,ton',,, than 71)6m, "I I d . il
- I I . I I I L
O to thoilottawa Oyer il.rQ O. . 'a JLPIAPartla 311 geo no ., ". � L "'
, 'be 0 h6 76,I.. ' thL , . -
. I I - t better
, I man coul d S JV6 IfaV eL
gal, "to the rights of �Yl.ro'vffice or roSpee,
'I
. ccm�etcncy of the colony"and di&) , lot injtiri-
.
w ti'll'
ct& Witfilib scope of' their Junsolic to .,
, L,
!, were only- two 6 -o , , ,
There ag'sA, in -bis Tupion,
oi in'
, , , 1. , , , .,4 �: �
I . I L I .0 , _ , - �
-
its tpvribofy�?' Waq�ji not equi.4;ilent to say- pilblic'.6tatement of ,,Sir, 'Pranois HincLs- �
I I , I
' '
. otisly affect the interests of-obher parts of
the empire. A similai. restraint bas been ob,
'overnment
*hicb� the -.Goverainiin� 6i the Do nion was
' ' iii,ad'v'iisina-ti�b:A'i,i'�116vi'a in'
'L n6eLof alo'6A�
'1111',Stjf
ing.4�uever mludou�r' recorded':voteg �aqriAce whose sympathies the, Ron, Mr. MdDoiigall 'L �
I ' i , i ',I in'fbis, Hotise -w6uld be againsi Ontario- " ��,� , ,. "
'Okit'�ri6'9'intei-�sbs��o..yotir-poli�i6a exigenciesi Sat . .1 , P �;, , i , , ,� - , , -
_', I . L
-, ,
- �"L`, ,ev
served ijy the Dominion (, in -its
I , control over pro'vinpiil legislatibn delegated
them by Parliamout.0 Now
,
�
T"It' was . -lin doll Stith tibli 61 -
J thel'A excess 0 3 urlg(li�3, t, , ,
and there L,4- beogro-iln' , _ � I 'f " i
I Ion,.
1.
.,.- .,� ,
. , ": - ''I �,_,,
,.if'mecessarv, an f 'A I ,
I d we'- will*,!,n�vei3Oielm, ,atand ', .that cach,o�tlie arbitrators for- hirnse f, g
, I .
b Y L YOU. L 1 ]y . I . ' I � i - 1. . � 1� , . I ' I
( heers.) He-was.41so Sorry to see: rate weig iing t Ic,evidlebee �addu4.d Rked , ;,.
. ' . I . - ' -
'the bou�olary 4� � , ;
. to the Imperial,
I
I s Bill was
one will contend that the Strea;m
and secondo-if itvas ihjurious to the interests'
'
, sahle L. - at was . .
thab'tb�, effect, of those prftesfain Which they,' �ou The" - aw � , I ��!. , I
' * .''
trai &refor6' Tha�1)616'rd di a not 1. , . .L' -
hiive�'felt�othemso�lves! co ri� Iiiod "to join, rtuanimolls.,,
,no
11 .not el I 'tli*n the legislative competency
ear
of, the whole Donifnion.' (t;6ud A�plaui�ej In
. L
t report -of Sir John' Macdonal d to tbe G ' '
t " V%
I . , , , ,
'' Fj� h,� , ' L' , 4 L ., "' , " ,!,;'
L
had �bQeu' further- wpa�edcd lo�y tho'ltofa'4 itudulyfavorOntavio; ,- eterrtqryaward�`6�d�4 1 .:,. , �,!
L ,,
.L. , �.� , �,�,
'Con'.
.
Of tbi g 11f�,'r7fit1w.l. deal With, and, he. would
, .
Nlr, Todd'a
call the atfention of the House to I
, .
� '
or in Cound -1868.� and, I was,
- il in , h`ch` exits
, . 1- 11�� . 'I ,G '',
ansmitted tWthe'.-Pro-vincia ovexnm
A!
' hoir'fefl far shooib-of wbit she ' .. ,,, -
absence of�,,�ny'\Sup�porLt''jroffl the claimed. - Ther
, ., , ' ' I , .� -
. roviucei was nothin'tt in i.tr-dierdor,e,,calling fcr,re � ,:' '
oervative*.n'ewspapers- in; the -P �,,L_��
it r
I I . L p , I i �
'
.
statement that tie more calcatation
. a 0 politi- ,as
Cal expediency was a sufficient reason for P, .
:
I
the, Jimits with' in, w . hie . hlb6 Do Alition p6w' I - I
- d* ,tion. When' that great' territoi,y 'in 10 "; 4' :
" t�eachbry of. a I' 6
and-L.thd dir6ct L arge num is wasi 'held bk' tho' H5 I olson . ��,Bay : " ,.
, _Oiital�()
of , ' �'� :representatives 'in '-the; Dorthwost-N
I . exercise of the veto poWr, because it Wag U 4
er of veto could be o6ngtittiiio'nall�'ei.eroirAe,-.1,
these limits were'confinod t6.thoi four classes
.ber L
' I I mpa`�y 'did -not �ir Jp I n,,q ( r, I ie'r 4prdsen-' � I ''� , , �
13 1 1 1
Dominion Parliarnept. .-',,How is .this T Co I I . ;,
I doubtedly f6r no other reasons than political
expedieu;y, and tinder pressure of political
. I
VIZ. :-Istj as being altOgethet'illegal or- 1111.
� �
bbing:ille�al,,or.
I , : I
ada gly 74 I .the
, str6ii 0 Y_ I .1
I,scv,he not forced to fho'oqh6lu�ion:that pairtk� latives.of United all , . , _., :. : , � I
,
, L I -
1, ,�h nd''P�rty.iiiter6fs, "are stronger, . with -of t�-�0,0',y o t " , i . t , '111.�
tiblbt . er o V,
his V t y cl
t6 . �
9 01 Y t,,r"
. 4 influence, that this bill was dissailo*e,a;
In 1877 the Legislature of
constitutional. - 2nd, as �uh-
.
constitutional only in�pArt. �;3'rd1.in,_CAS6S,Qf
' , � I . -I , I I
are'gar 4 s' if� "'
le S n a N116' �f
' I " -,' ol f6r,lthe, tge� Do'miuloh,au,th6rilt , o ' s rt'iii' _ '4 I ';
I
I I � 1. . I
thcose who acti,"thus, tian . .1 I I , "Ll 'by'right.,Of �Ii � � The
'of PrOvince.
(Hear, hear.)
I -
concuire'ut jitriidiction, wo'clasbing,-with tha
H, pit*'rebas'." at Oo . I . � .
,vital lntor�stg the. 0W. -,O So 0- o ni t, aY C y . I
- I - �
Prince Edward Island passed an Act respect.
. . -_ - I P '* Je4
legislation of the Dominion' arliati
,
. Id. we aceoun't ioi,'Ad' e�iddnt levity ah& Dominion:6overnmeaft have no title to t lf�'t f
Clon I I _ IL . I .,
.
"it,ory.,
it� Catbo,
ing public dchools, to which the Rom .
.P,L�P'4til;
. � . . .11. I
16s`*a1Te_d_fi -ng �_th q . i ro , te�odgtg'�� of. L thd`� Dominion.
d6risio'wwith which �the proper reference' � -ter e What, they purb�iS4 Jrom, L - ;
. ' q to, y ,xcepb , � �j
'.' "
n
lies of the Provibee t"k,,Arongekceptiq ,and,
.
I appealed through tbdit' lo,Olop to tile -V6.
,
generally; The Streams Bill��coftxiig. within '
none of these heads,but Sir John ifter three
ay , .
,LHudson�s c,,ompan`y,- Ontario in,- � I I
this questiorl'in'the speech from the Th�one, the: 0
" L -L I I I
-and the utterances of speakerg in support of, herits� the rights ,that Were ,held by the old . ,;
I I . ' ' ' ' '
�
I million authorities for its ck,'oollov&ute.-
The then Minister of Justice, (VAlf. JuAtic-0
"'
I
yearsfurtber eiperience of thp working' of the
federal system, sees no for enlarging,
Cur rights irre mpt by libm go . P, I �Y tb6'Hud.' -
�ntlernen opposite , OVince7of Canada. N,Vheu hel( t"'I .... .... L "" - . ,- 1.
and by tn6ir' otgaii in tlii�, City. I� Ithis� not OL 'Son's Bay,Cimpariy,, the Deminion it elivas I I
. I
I .
Fournier, in a careful review of the��bi-o to.
' 11 -
.-TIound
omlrii"�, "'; -, 1. It4 -
tho-vato power of the. _ 3
� question .,'vi�,tual IV affee�ihg',.Lonjgrio's fut ureo; by,these, very men, repudiated and" denied, - "L, t
'
fused to interferec arid although adm,amg
I ,
I - he 4u%llm�
,
the exercise b,f that power. to I O' as'sea
'L ,, .
, h, eit, p o iy fl this defecti�o .:' - ' I .
ii'd her,'firiancial Now,''they ilaiine., i'a � our' faces* "
. ,eri her in pencei a I-' I., . 11, . I 1. I - L '..
' "! i
that soine of the provii3ions of the act appeak-,
�,%(caugegbftly which I h'avejust qu okob: �� G on- �
". ,� 1.1
, d , , 4 ��
, , -it 9 `.,Bat bon,., gent ernell say it 16A titic'"b6uglit halgely with Ontario, money, an . .,�� I
&6s I pe . ri y. I I
'100,606 'attempt'.
ed to be severb and somewhat arbitrary, .gwd
tl&-%On oppoifte, Mrj Ross continudd, isaytt,f,iai�'.
L i16 a the'r Oritirio; gets this . ghtS,. L- 11 1, " .�. ", I
m0md6t Wh � by,!R, to dd�tiVo L U'S of, oar ,' I ri
,,, I I
recommending that the attentibn of this Lieu.
I .
I
theRght of veto oannot-be d6hied,_,-jBu .� I � ) L O , I
I � ,. ,,
. .1 . I
square )2�il6�of,.tei�itory,or,�not;'�a�d-ati�thiS Afrl.S. Dawgon, sitting as.,dn"o Aario Tepre- :, LL ' ' .
' I '
I
11 tenant Governor should be called to'thom, to
I
. 1,
,Ono dia, Y dtbA) legal right 41 Yeto;,", ,Tfie'
' ,
� I .
locatpe, it Was thought of the first importance oentative for th
" , - , I , , L is -very torrit4y; moved for the , :
't ',' 01taWa.,
Consider the expediency of certain amend-.
'
. -
, � I's ereile
question -thi's 4,colistil;utiobal ex
t eir , dp�oihtmahtof
poli6oal, chief at
0 011ppor It �
t L I a14 ,thd-hostile committee at� � L,,.. �1_ �
.
" '
ent8 there , the INJinigtex of Justice W
.... � in to � is " i "' I a"'
11 tT - ' ,
61, illat p Oe Hear, ,hear.) - poll what
L
'h th -hctio ag, .
th 0 ph ' t th,
4 h -of t1hat WAS ireC�lv, Ottaiva,-'�iid'bLq�"irbia'n,��oported sing ,� ,Q
�, ., ,,�9, 4 I . - I � I � I .. ��
'
ilovert .,... 0, "'i n the' th" I ,�t sh�ula
I � 0
.' 6
pic'.
. I
1
i
s he -, million Govornment,war.
, r i 6e. ! 3 i -4 ' t , noWn aWalA, 4
, ., ,� to tb I t �p 1,
to .
best eir P*0 'bcoause,4 i aced bur�,bo,tinA4,as far,. � . __4t,.��
I-— .� . I , , � , ,,j
L
, . " tltlt it " net
be left to it opera t 'd
to tt"pt to
. I ' 4 Strilanif
ibh 't 16,
=i ilte�tgn , ,,,, I ` , 5 - Aof.,
I , . I
,
" hit WIS 0. !�Joalo S of- fario, -,it�'tJio�ta;k�'of-t�b'-�V66�s'. , While in big �L�
11 On
f at S rqrpsa West I .11
, I I I .1 �
I �k. ", ' ' I I �
L : 'I
' "
� `!-bei'ie
'ovidpilco �
"Ait
, per for t . Sea. . I
" 0
, P h 71 a . thority .
. ai ol,
w . - 1. , L 'bug I
b ia ite , iffiff. Utho, deflnWf
I�C"' �' , ,.
&Ill � Ill :1 an ,r,,:i 6se"re4, ,sworn
d' h 6 unle P ov - a c6m
. . . 0 � thi ej:bef6ro.
I , S 1, ,er,' ,, . , �, '' , : I
is f
i't rf ... wi th t . all, or .0, 3 0 so.
k / e It d.t .....
L
I
. . I ,, , I .., I . .
I 11 . �,,.
. ... 1 ,,,�- , I I .
* -
':
� - ,. . 11 I I
. I � . , I ,� . .: I , , ,� , I . I - - _ I . I
. , I ,) 1� ��, , I .
11 . I � - �. ,,, I - I � , I I I I : I I
� 4 "� , ,, � !
: , , , . , ", , � , �11 : : 1
.
I
. . I
. I
�, . .
� . , 11.1 _' .' �
,� - I ! ' _� -
4 � - L .-,,
. I . I . . _-,
. '. I L I � ,,-�., ,,
I , � , , -
. I . ` �
. . - I I I . I . I ,
., J . 11 � 1 ". I , , �L . L
, � . I , I , � I .�:"�',.:� 1 , . , 1, . . , L 1
� �' �, : ' - �: : , L � �, , '� � . I : , I , , , . � I . i
� , , . . L" �. - 'L " ", , , . . L. J
, L L I . � . � I I , . . . . I , .
�i�,4% ,; '. L ' �� I I I I , I . , L . , . I , L I L I �, L I . I . 1�
,
. �
I LL I I
, ,�, ' L 4 � , � :- I'%
I I ;1---, �� 1 ,�;��,
, "' " "
. .
. . . . . . .
. . I
. - 11;-. ,
C " I . . � - I ,
. .. . .
�
. . I . , - ' ".L`�4 " . ��
. I �
. I .
. . � : �,
, .,
'. I . . ., I � ... , I . ��
. . . . . I � :
.... I �.
. I ..L . I I , ". .11
I
� . . , . , , ' 4 :� ,�]�� � ' � -1 ,
.. ., f�,
, - I � I 1, - I . � �,.'��,��,,�,�,'��
I " �', , ` 'I; ''. . . ,�, , . 11 � 11 - . . . " I L, . I
I �, . . �;_'' , . " . " ... �e
, , �
. � , , ,.�,,��.",�"',
,.
I , . ,:. . 11 . � ,,,, " , ,
: .� I L �, , . , , '��_ , . , .1 � , , I 11.1
. . . �
, , I I ,� I .111 � , 11,
,., . �, � , , , � I !�, " , � � 41.� - I : ,
L. ,�, �,, I �. 1,. p: 11 . ... . � , , e % , , i
. 1 "T I I . .
, ", � � I" , , ::,
�,.,
L . I
1- � . . . , _, ,
I L . 1 � . -
I � 11 . . .. . .: ,�� , : � . .
. " . . � I L I , 1 . I I . I .1 , I . I I
� . � , . . . . .. � . " , _., , , .
-
11 ,
� . " , , I ,. , � ,.'� , L . �11
I . � 4 . : ._�_ : . . .
I . I , I il � I I I _ � , .1 `N1 , , I � . � - , I ,� . '.1 "' � . I I
I , . " " -1, � �, . I I . i � ". I .: . 11
. I '....- '��4'�-,, . V. 4� - : .- � 1 ,
.
. � ,
. .
I . I I
. , I . . I
.. .
.
---'-' " , .� L " ( ,., , , , , �, -
. 1'�., I
� I 11, . � '.
I I . I . -1 , , " 1� ,:., , � � L, ,
I I . I .; -, ,
, � - ., � I
� :1 .. I
,
I , , " . 1 � .; , . . ' � ,
. ", '�>L � : , , 1:, , : " - , . , . � I , � I" , , �', - � , , , -.11 �� .:,, . : � � . �,,
I � -
I . . . I , _/ . . I , I I 11 ,
-� - , � , . I I � I . I , I I
I I I - , , I I
�. . - *
, 1. �
I � . .
.., . . . .
. � " . I
." 1. . I V, � __, , ...j., � , ot�'_ . -
..1. .. 111: "LL �� ' L " ' _ '- ! ' ' �:"" "�, ',;
L'.
. � I 1,
:_11 . I . . - I 11 1-1f;,��4 ,.�__ ,� I
' . I � ... � � I
I 11 , I ;1 - . � ; .
' " .
. " ". , I
;L�" .. 1%�It.11ln �: -L:�'.�,��'.". ,� ! . I , : ,� f!�� 4 .:,_� I.: � , �, !�
- , :.* .. ' " , �", � - .' ., .' 'L '� , � , �1, , . �1 .. . ; . I -.�
__ . ,
I
I I I ,
- � : I I . ,
, L , L ' � . . . I I .� "�'.,,� �,� I I I "', , � �,
I � I ! � � . I
, , I . ,
. . ,?� , , � � , -1 " L" I I I
. �, I , I � I � L I ( .:. ( "I ,: , . .1 "
I I I � I � I I I I , � �
I , I . I . 11 " . 1 I . I L L I I I L L � . . I I
I