HomeMy WebLinkAboutThe Citizen, 2017-11-30, Page 22PAGE 22. THE CITIZEN, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 2017.
North Huron to repair police station roof
By Denny Scott
The Citizen
North Huron Township Council
approved an emergency repair to the
Wingham Police Department
structure which could total $20,000.
On Nov. 20, North Huron Director
of Recreation and Facilities Pat
Newson presented a report stating
the Wingham police station's roof
had failed, resulting in significant
flooding.
Newson requested that council
release emergency funds for her to
seek either a repair or replacement
of the roof, whichever is necessary.
Her plan is to have a company the
municipality has worked with in the
past, Ontario Roof Consultants,
inspect the roof and suggest the best
course of action for the municipality.
The urgency of the repair meant
that, instead of having time to think
on the issue, council had to deal with
the potentially -costly repair
immediately.
Newson said the consulting
company would be on -scene on Nov.
22 to patch the roof if possible.
However, if patching wasn't
possible, she would seek out a
company to replace the asphalt
shingle roof with a steel one.
Deputy -Reeve James Campbell
asked if a cap could be put on the
project because Newson was
requesting $20,000, a significant
amount of money for the roof
according to other council members.
Reeve Neil Vincent, later in the
meeting, said the price tag surprised
him and worried that it indicated
costly repairs to the infrastructure of
the building.
Vincent explained that, two years
prior, he roofed an entire house with
steel for $4,000 in materials and he
felt his project was more
complicated, and thus would be
more expensive, than the roof
Newson said could cost $20,000.
"I think this is expensive, looking
at the project," he said. "I've put a
lot more steel on a roof than this for
well under $4,000."
Newson said the $20,000 price
was from a roof consultant. Vincent
responded saying he wanted to be
sure the municipality was getting
value for that amount of money.
She later explained that, as part of
the consultant's visit and preparation
for a final decision, the interior of
the structure would be reviewed.
There is a crawlspace and ceiling
above a false ceiling in the structure
and she said that a staff member
would be going into those spaces to
verify the structure is in a
serviceable condition.
Newson, in response to Vincent's
claims that the roof would cost too
much, said the municipality had
"constraints on who they could
hire."
"People we hire have to be able to
work at heights, be WSIB [Workers
Safety Insurance Board compliant],
and have $5 million liability
insurance," she said. "We can't just
ask anyone who does roofs."
She did admit that the price was
not a result of a competitive bid, but
said she felt it was a fair price when
it was provided earlier this year.
Newson said she didn't plan on
spending more than $3,000 to
$5,000 on the repair however
Campbell felt $5,000 was too much.
The challenge with the project and
potentially with pricing, according
to Newson, was that there could be a
large quantity of snow on the roof in
the near future.
"We're exhausting all our options,
but we don't want to leave that
decision to Dec. 4 when [council
next meets]," she said. "We will pass
all approvals through the Chief
Administrative Officer [Dwayne
Evans] for pricing and options in
lieu of council being able to see
that."
Councillor Bill Knott, however,
felt bringing in a consultant was a
waste of resources.
"Spending $5,000 on a consultant
[and repair] and then spending
$20,000 to replace it in the summer
doesn't make sense," he said. "I'd
rather spend the $20,000 and replace
it now and, if it's going to exceed
that, let us know."
Knott said he wanted Newson to
find someone to replace the roof and
move ahead with the project.
Councillor Trevor Seip, however,
felt that spending that kind of money
on a structure that the township may
not have a use for in the near future
was folly.
"My concern is that this
infrastructure is right in the middle
[of council deciding whether OPP or
Wingham Police will cover
Wingham]," he said. "We could put
$20,000 to $25,000 in a roof and in
six months it's not being used."
Seip said he would prefer Newson
get it repaired for less than $5,000
and wait until council decided on the
future of the Wingham Police
Department before moving forward.
Newson agreed, saying that was
part of why she had contacted the
consultant before presenting the
report to council that night.
Knott, however, pointed out that
even if the Wingham Police
Department is disbanded and the
Ontario Provincial Police service
Wingham, the municipality will still
own the building and need it to be in
good condition.
Knott didn't find sufficient
support to push the repair, however,
and council approved Newson's
plan to repair the roof if possible
or, if repair isn't an option,
replace it.
Rediscover what
Huron County has
to offer.
Pick up your free
guide to
Stops Along The
Way and see
what's happening
in your area!
A Visitor's Guide to Huron County
What to See
Where to Dine
Things to Do
Museums
Snowmobile Trails Map
Available at many local tourist spots throughout
Huron County or pick it up at
The Citizen
413 Queen St., Blyth - 519-523-4792
Keep up with the latest
agri-businesses and the
best of rural living!
The most wonderful time of the year
Brussels' St. Ambrose Catholic Church hosted a Christmas bazaar on Saturday featuring
snacks, raffle tickets, a penny draw, silent auction and plenty of Christmas gifts for those who
visited the church. It was the perfect spot for those looking to get a head start on their
Christmas shopping. (Denny Scott Photo)
Author to speak in Clinton
The author of Growing a
Revolution: Bringing Our Soil Back
to Life, David R. Montgomery, is a
guest speaker at the Huron County
Soil and Crop Improvement
Association Annual General
Meeting (AGM) on Wednesday,
Dec. 13, 2017. The AGM event takes
place at Libro Community Hall in
Clinton.
Doors open at 5 p.m. Huron Soil
and Crop business takes place at
around 5:30 p.m. Dinner starts at
about 6:30 p.m. Speakers present
starting at about 7:15 p.m. The
evening finishes at around 9:30 p.m.
Tickets are $20 each. Continuing
education unit (CEU) credits are
available for participants. To buy
tickets, contact Huron Soil and Crop
Improvement Association (HSCIA)
secretary Sharon Devine at 519-868-
8946. You may also register for
tickets online at the Ontario Soil and
Crop Improvement Association
(OSCIA) Wild Apricot web page at
https://oscia.wildapricot.org/
event -2726369. Please register by
Dec. 4. To find out more about the
AGM visit huronsoilcrop.org.
Dr. David R. Montgomery is a
geologist and professor of Earth and
Space Sciences at the University of
Washington. His research focuses on
how soil erosion has negatively
impacted civilizations around the
world. Montgomery highlights
entrepreneurial farmers who focus
on improving soil health and
regenerative practices. The presenter
says it is possible for an agricultural
producer to improve their bottom
line while mending damaged
environments. The author shows
how no -till, cover crops and diverse
crop rotations can sustain the
indispensable soil microbial
ecosystem. This, in turn, protects a
farmer's crops and livelihood,
according to Montgomery.
To learn more about the author
and his books visit dig2grow.com.
The Huron County Soil and Crop
Continued on page 23
Over 25 colours al poinufis.fa
thous tzmI nrsMckpn
seasonal uron RId et
Professor Temple Gremlin alM
Showjumpm Ian Miller leach
haw la untlerslantl animals...
and human nature
The magazine of Agricultural Life
The Rural Voice
413 Queen St., P.O. Box 429
Blyth, ON NOM 1H0